logo

53 pages 1 hour read

Roland Smith

Zach's Lie

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 22-26Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Zach in the Box”

Part 3, Chapter 22 Summary

Sam searches futilely for Zach at the Grangers’ and Darrell’s houses. Zach’s hotel room is also empty. Sam examines Zach’s backpack and finds Neil’s journal. Zach waits at Peter’s trailer. Zach knows that keeping his old journals and continuing to write caused the mess he is in, but Zach also feels that the journals represent his old life, and that keeping a diary helps him cope with his new life.

Alonzo Aznar and Berry break into the Grangers’ empty home, searching for the family and for Neil’s journal. Peter refuses to tell Paul where the Grangers are, and Alonzo threatens to kill Peter when he returns if Peter does not talk. The men discover a message from Mary to Zach on the phone’s answering machine. She and Wanda are staying at a different hotel. Mary leaves the phone number. Alonzo knows they are in L.A. and plans to go after them once they have Zach.

Sam watches the men leave the Grangers’ house. He wants to follow them but worries that Zach is inside. The house is empty, but Sam finds Zach’s old journals and Commander IF. Sam knows who the men are and realizes they are onto the Grangers.

Part 3, Chapter 23 Summary

Zach returns to the Nevada Hotel, deciding to speak to Peter in the morning. He lies to Sam about where he was, insisting everything is fine, but Sam knows Zach is in trouble. Sam shares that as a little boy, he loved music and was a good musician. Sam also excelled at languages. Sam attended different schools and became a spy, rising to the rank of colonel in the KGB. Sam married and had a son, but while he was embedded in another country, his son became ill. Sam’s employers did not tell Sam. Sam’s son died, and his wife left him. Sam was furious at the KGB and suspected they would soon eliminate him. Inspired by music from his childhood, Sam decided to share their secrets and defected to the United States, where he has hidden from the KGB for twenty years.

Finally, Zach stops pretending that nothing is wrong. Sam knows about Zach’s situation and Neil’s journals; he saw the men in Zach’s house and says that it is too late to fix things. Sam will reach out to old spy friends to contact Zach’s handlers and alert the U.S. Marshals to intercept Mary and Wanda. Sam will take Zach to the sheep camp for safety. Sam does not carry a gun, relying instead on subterfuge.

Peter, tied up on Aznar’s plane, gives in to Aznar’s deadly threats and tells everything he knows, including where Zach is staying. Catalin, frustrated at being unable to reach Sam by phone, goes to the hotel.

Part 3, Chapter 24 Summary

Zach feels guilty for ruining their new lives in Elko. Sam reassures him that it is not his fault: Aznar knew they were in Elko and would have found them eventually. Sam did not mention Neil’s journal to his own handler, assuming that Neil is using it to make a “deal.” Zach angrily asserts that Neil is not making a deal but wants to take down Aznar and assure his family is safe. Sam calms Zach down. If they encounter Aznar, Sam wants Zach to trust him and follow his directions. Zach agrees. At the sheep camp, Zach worries about Mary and Wanda and about leaving Catalin.

Alonzo Aznar captures Catalin when she visits Zach’s room at the hotel, and he takes Benat hostage. Aznar, henchman Paul, and the hostages go to the sheep camp. Aznar sends Benat into the tent with Ander, Sam, and Zach. Aznar claims no one will be hurt if Sam gives up Zach. Sam tells Zach to “remember the number eight” (197). Aznar, wielding a gun, enters the tent. He promises to let Catalin go if he gets the journal. Sam demands he release Catalin first. Aznar reluctantly agrees. Zach gives Aznar the backpack but is surprised when the drug lord pulls out opera magazines, instead of Neil’s journal: Sam made a switch. Aznar moves to shoot Catalin, but Sam says he will never get the journal if he kills anyone. Sam, Zach, Aznar, and Paul return to Elko where Sam has hidden the journal.

Part 3, Chapter 25 Summary

Zach thinks Sam is so calm that he must have a plan. Zach also believes Aznar will kill them both after he gets the journal. Sam directs them to Elko Middle School where Neil’s journal is in his workroom under the stage. Sam promises Aznar they “won’t spring any traps” on him, making Zach think Sam is trying to give him a message (202). In the auditorium, Sam’s punching bag sits in the center of the stage. In Sam’s workroom, Zach’s Jack in the Box is on Sam’s recliner in the center of the room: its usual lock was replaced with one of the padlocks from the trapdoors. Sam has set a trap, placing the heavy bag on the trapdoor above the box, creating an “upside-down Jack in the Box” (205). Sam gives the key to Aznar, who opens the box and finds Commander IF. Zach pulls the trapdoor lever, dropping the bag on Aznar and knocking him out. Sam fights and disarms Paul. Zach retrieves Commander IF.

Uncle Don and the marshals arrest Aznar and Paul. They rescue Peter from Aznar’s plane and arrest Berry and Aznar’s pilot. Mary and Wanda are safe. Uncle Don says that Aznar can still get to the family from prison, so Zach will be leaving Elko for a new life immediately. Zach denies knowing anything about Neil’s journal. Zach thanks Sam, who promises to get the journal to Neil and to tell Catalin the truth. Zach worries that Aznar’s organization will come after Sam, but Sam refuses to hide, saying he can take care of himself. He wants to “stay with his flock” (208).

Part 3, Chapter 26 Summary

Zach writes a letter to Catlin. He apologizes for not writing sooner, but his handlers would not allow him to write until the family was ready to leave for their new lives, and only under the condition that they read the letter first, considering the trouble his writing caused in Elko. Zach says that his sister is angry at the move and losing the part in the musical, but his mom is handling the situation well. Zach wishes he were in the mountains with Catalin and Benat and wishes he could keep in touch, but this will be his only letter. He also wishes he could send himself in the letter, but instead encloses Commander IF, hoping he will be as good a friend to Catalin as he was to Zach.

Zach is now Mack Greene, a name he chose himself, and Wanda, looking more like the original Joanne, is now Christine. The U.S. Marshals appropriated Aznar’s private jet to use for witness relocation. When Mack and Christine board the plane they find that their mom, who has been testifying for the DEA against Aznar, is already on board. Mrs. Greene is unusually happy as she greets them. The pilot introduces himself over the speaker system and says his co-pilot will introduce himself. A thin, blonde-haired man with “tired blue eyes” enters the cabin (211). He is Robert Greene who is, in fact, Neil. Mack and Christine run to him.

Part 3, Chapters 22-26 Analysis

Readers learn the surprising backstory behind the enigmatic Sam and appreciate the similarity of Sam’s situation to that of Zach. Smith brings the novel to an exciting climax, pitting Zach and Sam against Aznar. Themes of who to trust and what secrets to keep dominate this final section. Smith offers readers a satisfying ending, but leaves enough ambiguity for reflection, as Zach assumes another new identity—and a new lie.

Like Zach, Sam is in hiding. He tells Zach, “I spent most of my life pretending to be someone I wasn’t” (208). Because Sam broke his trust with the KGB and gave up his secrets to the U.S. government, he was relocated for his protection and given a new identity. In this way, he is also in a similar position to Neil, trading secrets for safety, and exposing wrongdoing.

Sam knows that secrets can be both good and bad. He keeps his identity a secret, as Zach tries to keep his identity and that of his mother and sister secret for their protection. Secrets, however, can also be deadly. Aznar will kill to keep his own secrets safe. Sam’s modus operandi as a spy is lies and deception. Yet Sam knows that everyone, at some point, needs to trust someone else. Zach trusts that Sam wants to help him, but initially does not confide in Sam, thinking he can handle the situation alone. Zach’s lie isolates him from others. Fortunately for Zach, Sam already knows his secret and Zach trusts him.

Zach wrestles with feelings of guilt in this section, as he attempts to rectify the “slip up” caused by his journaling. Zach likes his new life and friends and knows he will lose them because of his writing: yet Zach also knows the writing helped keep him emotionally grounded throughout frightening and new experiences. Zach feels he has also destroyed his family’s hopes for their new lives. Additionally, Zach believes it is his fault that his new friends Catalin, Benat, and Sam are in danger. Zach empathizes with Catalin’s fear and helplessness because it was what he experienced when Aznar and his men threatened his family. Zach’s guilt reflects his empathetic nature and his desire to protect and preserve his family’s new life.

To beat Aznar, Zach must master his self-recrimination and fear. Smith ups the stakes for Zach and increases tension for the reader by giving Zach a difficult choice: to keep Neil’s journal, the only chance his dad has to stop Aznar and stay out of prison, or to give it to Aznar to save Catalin’s life. Although the choice is symbolic, as the journal is not in the backpack, Zach chooses to protect life. His choice reveals his strength of character: He is willing to sacrifice his family’s future with his dad for greater cause. Smith reveals the true extent of Aznar’s cruelty in these final chapters. Aznar is casually willing to kill women, children, and the elderly for his own gain. The violence Aznar inflicts on Peter, combined with realistic details like the drug lord’s knife and automatic handgun, add teeth to the threat against Zach.

Trust pays off as Zach follows Sam’s lead. Zach stays calm despite believing that Aznar will kill both him and Sam and springs the trap on Aznar. In true thriller style, Zach, the hero who has been a victim throughout, turns the tables on Aznar, defeating the antagonist. The Jack in the Box, which held the journals that compromised Zach, becomes the trap that ensnares Aznar.

With the family reunited with Neil, and Aznar and his henchmen in jail, the novel’s ending is a positive affirmation of family and the triumph of good over evil. Smith does leave the reader with questions, however. Zach’s issues with lies and identity will presumably continue in his new life without the therapeutic use of journaling to mitigate them. Mrs. Greene’s smile onboard the plane implies that she has worked through her emotions about her husband’s criminal lies and forgiven him, as we deduce that the information in Neil’s journal was enough to keep him out of prison. Readers may find that this neat conclusion stretches believability. Finally, readers may feel a disconnect with Catalin’s character. A prominent figure in Zach’s life in Part 2, Catalin becomes merely a pawn for Peter and Aznar in the story’s final section. While Zach cares about Catalin deeply, he severs his connection with her by letter. This action illustrates the emotional isolation that Zach and others in the Witness Security Program experience and the difficulty of living a lie.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text