57 pages • 1 hour read
Isabel IbañezA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Inez says her goodbyes to the excavation team and pays a final visit to Cleopatra’s burial chamber. Kareem encourages her, “Don’t be sad, sitti. You’ll be back” (328). Before they board the Elephantine, Whit tells Inez that he is returning to England to marry his fiancée. He also mentions that he was looking for a spell written by one of Cleopatra’s ancestors.
On New Year’s Eve, the boat reaches Cairo, and Inez finds Elvira safe and sound at Shepheard’s. Elvira explains that she followed her cousin’s trail. Ricardo intends to send both young women back to Buenos Aires at once. Elvira’s actions make Inez realize how her own disappearance must have worried her family, and she apologizes.
Elvira gives Inez a letter from her father, which she found in her parents’ hotel suite. In the letter, he cautions Inez not to trust her mother, explains that the ring he sent to her helped him make a major discovery on Philae, and entreats her to never stop looking for him. Inez wonders if her mother is holding her father captive and resolves to find him. She tells her cousin all about her adventures. Elvira insists that they attend the New Year’s ball and gives Inez a beautiful gown made of ivory silk embroidered with gold flowers. Elvira wears a nearly identical gown, and Inez observes that they look like twins.
The narration shifts to Whit’s perspective. He plans to stay in Egypt for a few more days to settle old scores and ensure that the enemies that he’s made in Cairo don’t impact his life in England. Ricardo gives him an envelope full of money and asks him to find out if Lourdes is in Cairo. Whit goes to one of his contacts with ties to Tradesman’s Gate, an Englishman named Peter Yardley who works for the Antiquities Service and sells stolen artifacts. Whit gives Peter the money from Ricardo to settle his debts. Whit tells Peter to be careful at the warehouse in Bulaq, and the seemingly casual comment alarms Peter. He aims his gun at Whit, and Whit kills him.
The narration returns to Inez’s perspective. Later that evening, at the ball, she introduces Elvira to Whit, who mentions that he is a lord. Inez is hurt that he kept his social rank from her when she shared so much of herself with him, but she still grants him a dance. Whit explains that he was trying to keep an emotional distance between them, but now he wants one last memory of her that he can carry home with him. Inez spots Mr. Sterling in the crowd, and Whit resolves to reclaim the ring. Inez wants to help him, but he tells her to leave the matter to him and kisses her cheek at midnight.
When the cousins return to their suite, Inez is heartbroken at the thought of never seeing Whit again. Elvira notices her cousin’s sadness, but Inez insists that she and Whit cannot be together. Elvira has arranged to meet one of her dance partners the next morning, and Inez asks her cousin to wake her so she can act as her chaperone.
Inez awakens the next morning to find a worried Whit at her door. He informs her that Elvira was seen leaving the hotel in a stranger’s carriage. Sallam gives Inez an envelope containing a note from Lourdes and tickets for Inez’s passage to Buenos Aires. Lourdes tricked her enemies into abducting Elvira instead of Inez and urges her daughter to flee before they realize they’ve taken the wrong person to the docks. Whit adamantly opposes Inez’s plan to rescue her cousin, believing it is too dangerous. She seems to concede his point and tells him to contact her uncle. As soon as he leaves the room, Inez hurries from the hotel and hails a cab.
Inez investigates the warehouses at the Bulaq docks. A man grabs her from behind, and she kicks him before realizing that it’s Whit. He urges her to leave because he’s afraid that he won’t be able to protect her, but she refuses. A group of guards attacks them. When one of the men points a gun at Inez’s head, Whit surrenders his pistol and offers to take her place as a hostage. A familiar voice orders the guards to bring both Inez and Whit aboard, and the man sedates Inez.
She awakens in a tomb. A battered Whit informs her that she was unconscious for hours and that he’s found no sign of Elvira. The man with the familiar voice returns with the guards, who beat Whit. Inez confirms her real identity, berating herself for using her cousin’s name as an alias during her travels. The man strikes Inez when she says that she doesn’t know her mother’s whereabouts, and Whit threatens him. When Inez continues to protest that she doesn’t know where her mother is, the man tells her that “[her] cousin will share [her] fate” and orders his men to seal Inez and Whit inside the tomb (368).
Whit uses a trick taught to him by a deceased friend to undo the ropes binding his wrists. Then he unties Inez, and expertly uses a strip of fabric to bandage one of his injuries. Inez realizes that she is looking at a rawer version of the man she knows, “someone who was no stranger to surviving” (370). When they fail to discover anything in the tomb that might help them escape, she collapses in tears. Whit embraces her and tells her the story of why he was dishonorably discharged. He served at Khartoum under General Charles George Gordon. The general was ordered to retreat, but he held the city against the Mahdis and sent Whit to meet the relief force. However, the relief force was delayed for months because they refused to let an Egyptian crew take them down the Nile and were waiting for a Canadian crew to arrive. Whit disobeyed orders and returned to Khartoum alone. By the time he arrived, Gordon had been beheaded by the Mahdis.
Inez attempts to soothe the guilt and shame he carries, saying, “I think you’re more decent than you think. Practically a hero” (373). She tries to comfort them both by insisting that her mother will come to her rescue. Whit and Inez kiss passionately, and he tells her that she tastes like roses. They hear muffled shouts from outside the tomb followed by a loud noise. Whit puts his arms around Inez and pushes her toward cover.
Inez hopes that her mother has come for her, but their rescuer is Ricardo. He leads them through a tunnel into the Valley of Kings. The sound of the blast draws the kidnappers’ attention, and one of them shoots Ricardo in the arm. The group’s leader is Mr. Burton, the American businessman Inez met at Shepheard’s. Lourdes stole artifacts from him, and he and his mysterious employer are convinced that Inez knows where to find her. One of Mr. Burton’s associates is the blond man who left Philae with Lourdes. Mr. Burton orders his men to retrieve Elvira, then he shoots her. He threatens to kill Inez next unless Ricardo tells him where to find his sister. Ricardo guesses that Lourdes has gone to Amarna to search for Nefertiti’s tomb. Inez attacks Mr. Burton, and Whit seizes one of the guard’s rifles and shoots Mr. Burton in the head.
The authorities arrest the kidnappers, and Elvira’s body is buried in a cemetery in Thebes. Ricardo receives medical treatment in Thebes before returning to Cairo with Inez and Whit. Back in her parents’ suite at Shepheard’s, Inez grieves for Elvira. She touches the trinket box, has a vision of Cleopatra after the Battle of Actium, and feels the defeated pharaoh’s turbulent emotions—“Rage. Despair. Sorrow to have lost everything” (385).
Ricardo explains to Inez that Lourdes became obsessed with searching for alchemical documents and would often stay in Cairo rather than going to dig sites with her husband and brother. During the couple’s last trip to Egypt together, Ricardo realized that his sister was involved with smugglers, and Cayo began suspecting that she was having an affair. Ricardo lost Cayo’s trust by urging him to forgive Lourdes, which is why he sent the ring to Inez without consulting Ricardo. The last time that Ricardo saw Cayo, he was headed to Cairo with Lourdes. He searched for them for weeks and then invented the story that they had perished in the desert. Inez suspects that Mr. Sterling is Mr. Burton’s boss and the associate Lourdes double-crossed by stealing the artifacts from Philae. However, Whit and Ricardo believe it may be Sir Evelyn. Inez is determined to stay in Egypt so that she can avenge Elvira, recover the stolen artifacts, stop her mother, and find her father. However, because Ricardo controls her inheritance until she marries, he tries to force her to return home by threatening to cut her off financially: “I will not help you destroy your life” (390).
The narrative moves to Whit’s perspective. He receives a telegram from a woman in which she cuts him out of her life. The young man drinks to the point of inebriation, berating himself for kissing Inez and for his futile search for the alchemical spell. He concocts a last, desperate plan and sends a telegram to his parents.
The narrative returns to Inez. Whit comes to her room while she’s packing for her journey back to Argentina, and she’s hurt to see that he is intoxicated and emotionally distant. When she says that she could marry the young man her parents chose for her so that she can access her inheritance, he pulls her close and says, “Marry me instead” (394).
Whit’s older brother, Porter, sails to Egypt. He holds a telegram from Whit that reads, “INEZ FELL FOR IT” (396).
In the novel’s final part, The Perils of Extending and Withholding Trust turn deadly for those close to Inez. The adventure story’s suspense intensifies with a number of thrilling events, including Elvira’s kidnapping, the fight at the docks, Ricardo’s daring rescue, and the deadly final encounter between Inez and Mr. Burton. The plot twist of Mr. Burton’s villainy also adds to the story’s mystery and adventure: “My mind was still unable to connect how this man was the same foppish, kind gentleman who had delivered our mail, who had asked me to dinner” (382). The mystery leaves the identity of Lourdes’s nefarious business partner a secret, but Mr. Sterling and Sir Evelyn emerge as likely suspects for Inez to investigate. The novel’s final chapters are filled with suspenseful twists and turns that pave the way for the second book in the series.
In addition, Part 4 develops the story’s romance. Balls feature in many love stories, but What the River Knows subverts the trope by lacing the scene with melancholy: Whit says, “I want one memory with you dancing. One thing that’s mine before we part ways…” (351). The young people are sure that they will soon be separated forever, and their time together ticks away like the countdown to the New Year. Their confinement in the tomb brings Inez and Whit both physically and emotionally closer than ever before. He is fiercely protective, as demonstrated by his threats to the kidnapper who strikes Inez: “Touch her again and I will end your miserable life” (367). When the pair believe they have only a short while left to live, they choose to spend that time in a passionate kiss. In an important development for their relationship and Whit’s characterization, he shares the details of his dishonorable discharge.
Whit’s backstory connects to the theme of Power Dynamics and Colonialism. The British relief force arrived too late because they didn’t want Egyptians piloting them on the Nile, and Whit had to disobey orders to follow his conscience. This information allows Inez to understand the shame that drives him to hide his past and his emotions behind a wall of cynicism, and she responds to his uncharacteristic vulnerability with tenderness and gratitude: “I caressed the hollow of his throat. I knew what it cost him, to reveal something that he felt tremendous shame about. Something he would have carried alone” (373). Ironically, Inez and Whit’s abduction has the positive effect of bringing them closer than either of them ever expected.
The novel’s ending complicates the theme of Living with Grief and Loneliness. At the start of the novel, Inez believes that both of her parents are dead. By the end, she believes that they are both alive, but her emotions toward the two characters have completely changed. While Inez is determined to find and save her father, she realizes that the mother she loved never truly existed, and her sorrow becomes tangled up in pain and rage at Lourdes’s treachery. Inez gains a new and fathomless source of grief when Mr. Burton kills her beloved cousin right in front of her. She blames herself and her mother for Elvira’s murder, and the loss increases her resolve to stop Lourdes: “I wanted to hunt my mother down. Wherever she was, I would find her. She would pay for what she stole from me” (385). The time that Inez spent grieving for her mother makes Lourdes’s betrayal and its deadly consequences cut all the deeper.
The resolution also subverts romantic tropes and complicates the theme of trust. Typically, in a rivals-to-lovers dynamic, the couple is initially opposed to one another but grows close by the end of the story. What the River Knows subverts this trope by casting doubt on Whit’s motives at the very end of the story. Whit doesn’t know the extent of Inez’s fortune until the argument between her and Ricardo in Chapter 37: “‘I’m an heiress, aren’t I? I ought to have enough money to buy a kingdom.’ […] Whit looked between us, deep lines creasing his brow. ‘A kingdom?’” (390). In addition, the timing of his proposal is suspiciously close to the arrival of a letter from an unnamed woman, likely his fiancée, cutting him off. This implies that Whit proposes to Inez to access her money and keep them both in Egypt. Inez immediately senses a change in Whit when he enters her room in the final chapter, suggesting that he is no longer someone she can trust despite all they’ve been through together: “The person who had held me in the darkness was long gone. That person who had comforted me, kissed me desperately, saved my life. This person before me was a stranger” (394). The author doesn’t directly reveal how Inez responds to Whit’s proposal, but the wording of Whit’s telegram in the Epilogue implies that she said yes. Whit’s foreboding message to his brother suggests that Inez has once again placed herself in danger by trusting the wrong person.
Inez’s search for the truth turns up far more questions than answers over the course of the novel. Beliefs she once trusted as inviolable truths, such as her parents’ love for one another, are destroyed. The uncle she thought murdered her parents turns out to be innocent, while her mother and the young man she loves harbor hidden motives. It remains to be seen whether Inez will be able to stop her mother’s smuggling, protect Cleopatra’s tomb from Mr. Sterling, find her father, and untangle her complicated relationship with Whit in the next installment in the Secrets of the Nile series.