logo

57 pages 1 hour read

Isabel Ibañez

What the River Knows

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapters 13-17Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2: “Up the River”

Part 2, Chapter 13 Summary

Inez no longer trusts her uncle, but she still finds herself drawn to Whit against her better judgment. In the morning, the brawny Mr. Fincastle and his daughter, Isadora, board the boat, and their presence makes Inez uneasy. Inez hides herself and takes out the wooden box again. As she holds it, she has a vision of Cleopatra crafting a potion, and she realizes that the pharaoh worked magic. She spends the rest of the day working with Kareem in the kitchen and wondering how to reveal her presence to her uncle. That evening, Inez helps serve dinner in the boat’s saloon, which allows her to eavesdrop on Ricardo, Whit, Mr. Fincastle, and Isadora. Mr. Fincastle’s comments about the opulent boat cause Inez to realize that her parents’ deaths have made her uncle enormously rich.

Part 2, Chapter 14 Summary

The next day, the Elephantine continues up the Nile. While Inez is hard at work scrubbing the deck, the wind scatters some important papers. She falls overboard trying to catch them. When a crocodile approaches her, Whit calls her by her first name and loses his ever-present flask diving in after her. He promises, “I won’t let anything happen to you” (146). Whit pulls Inez underwater out of the predator’s path, and he presses his mouth to hers so he can share his oxygen with her. Mr. Fincastle and his daughter shoot at the crocodile, and the man turns his rifle on Inez when the crew hauls her aboard. Whit explains that she’s Ricardo’s niece and vouches for her. Although Whit insists on taking her to her uncle at once, Inez calls him by his first name and tells him that she considers him a friend now. Ricardo wants Whit to take Inez back to Argentina, but he refuses and argues that “she’s earned the right to be on the team” (153). Her uncle agrees to let her join the search for Cleopatra’s tomb after Inez explains that she can sense objects touched by Cleopatra’s magic. Ricardo dismisses Inez and makes Whit give his word that he’ll respect that Inez is off-limits.

Part 2, Chapter 15 Summary

Inez urges herself to forget about her feelings for Whit and focus on uncovering what happened to her parents. When the young man stops by her cabin, he is superficial and flirtatious again. Inez joins her uncle and the rest of the excavation team for breakfast in the saloon. She learns that Mr. Fincastle is in charge of security and distrusts Ricardo. At his daughter’s insistence, Mr. Fincastle apologizes for aiming his gun at her. The Elephantine is headed for Philae, an island “famous for its legendary beauty and history” (164). Ricardo suggests that Inez can use her artistic skills to capture the temples they explore, and the idea thrills her. Mr. Fincastle protests, “A lady such as yourself isn’t used to the discomfort of rough travel” (167). However, Inez assures him that she will rise to the challenge.

Part 2, Chapter 16 Summary

Inez tells Ricardo that being in Egypt helps her hold on to her memories of her parents. He explains that his late wife, Zazi, suggested that he ask her parents to finance their archaeological work. Abdullah, the team’s expert on ancient Egypt, is Zazi’s brother. Ricardo mentions that Inez’s mother liked to play pranks on the team with “an old silk scarf that can shrink anything it can cover down to the size of a charm” (170). Lourdes was in charge of keeping the team’s records, but Ricardo refuses to tell Inez where the records are located. She accuses her uncle of lying to her and demands to know why he hired Mr. Fincastle when her parents hated weapons. He retorts that she didn’t know her parents. Inez demands answers about their disappearance, but he insists that they continue this discussion later when she’s calmer.

Inez finds Whit on the deck and asks him if he trusts her uncle. He answers that he doesn’t even trust his own parents, and Inez realizes that she doesn’t trust hers either. A storm shakes the boat, and Whit moves as if to comfort her but stops himself and tells her to go to her cabin. When Inez looks for her uncle below deck, she finds her mother’s diary among his things. In the final entry, Lourdes wrote that her brother bruised her in a fight and that she feared for her life: “I don’t know what I should do. He is my brother. But he is a murderer” (176). This convinces Inez that Ricardo killed her parents. She considers fleeing from the boat, but, realizing she would likely die in the storm, she decides to stay and learn the full truth of what befell her parents.

The narrative shifts to Whit’s perspective as he and the rest of the crew fight to keep the boat from capsizing. He briefly thinks of his promise to protect Inez and then reminds himself that he has a duty to a young woman back in England.

Part 2, Chapter 17 Summary

The narrative returns to Inez. She resolves to avenge her parents’ deaths. In the morning, Whit comes to her cabin, assures her that the Elephantine sustained no serious damage in the storm, and asks her to prepare to disembark at Aswan with uncharacteristic politeness. Mr. Fincastle and Isadora have another appointment, but the rest of the team heads to the Old Cataract Hotel to meet Abdullah and his granddaughter, Farida, who is a photographer. Abdullah decides that Inez deserves to know some of the details of their operation because of her parents’ deaths. He explains that he’s been excavating sites for over a decade “so that future generations can learn about [Egypt’s] history” (186). No one on the team is allowed to discuss their findings or take anything from the dig sites.

The narrative shifts to Whit, who goes to a brothel. He learns that Mr. Sterling is the patron of a woman named Blanche and bribes the madame to permit him a half hour with her. Even as Blanche begins to undress, Whit’s thoughts are on Inez. He covers the woman up with her robe and explains that he is after information.

Part 2 Analysis

In Part 2, Inez struggles with conflicting emotions and faces grave danger in her investigation. Her rivals-to-lovers romance with Whit develops further in these chapters. In a turning point for their relationship, he dives into crocodile-infested waters to protect her, and Inez feels “an electrical current […] in every corner of [her] body” when their lips meet for the first time (147). Although the incident convinces Inez that they are at least friends, Whit disagrees because she hasn’t shown him trust: “[I]f you thought we were friends, you might have not lied to me, pretending to be someone else on this damn boat” (151). On top of the secrets they keep from one another, their romance faces new obstacles in this section. Ricardo warns Whit to stay away from his niece. Additionally, Whit’s narration in Chapter 15 hints that he is betrothed. Despite his employer’s orders and his duty to his family and fiancée, Whit continues to grow more attached to Inez as the story continues.

Ricardo’s expedition develops the novel’s exploration of Power Dynamics and Colonialism. His team keeps their “astounding discoveries” top-secret so that they can protect Egyptian artifacts from foreigners who would sell them (186). The mission is noble, but it’s worth noting that Abdullah is the only Egyptian member of the excavation team. Whit, Mr. Fincastle, and Isadora are British, and Ricardo and Inez are Argentine. Meanwhile, the crew members, who perform most of the hard labor, are all Egyptian. Although Ricardo’s expeditions seek to preserve Egyptian history, the team’s structure resembles the colonial government in that it concentrates power in foreigners’ hands. The novel subverts the established power dynamics somewhat by having the protagonist, who comes from such a privileged background that she has “never stepped foot in [her] kitchen back home, not even to boil water (134), choose to work alongside the boat’s crew.

Ricardo and Inez’s difficult relationship advances the theme of The Perils of Extending and Withholding Trust. Her grief over her parents moves Ricardo to have a rare forthright conversation with her in Chapter 16, and the magical scarf he mentions becomes vital to the plot in Part 3. However, this moment of confidence and closeness is short-lived, and Inez is not alone in her suspicions: “I wish I could [trust you] […] You might be family, Inez, but you’re a stranger to me where it counts and I won’t risk everything merely because your feelings might get hurt” (171). Ironically, Ricardo’s efforts to protect Inez’s feelings and the team’s expedition leave both perilously vulnerable to Lourdes’s schemes. By repeatedly refusing to be honest with Inez, he drives her further and further away. This distance makes it all too easy for Inez to believe that he’s a killer when she reads her mother’s diary: “I fear for my life. I fear for Cayo’s life” (176). Like the letter to Monsieur Maspero, the diary entry is planted by Lourdes to frame her brother. As the adventure continues, the distrust between the relatives threatens to compromise the team’s mission.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text