58 pages • 1 hour read
Tarryn FisherA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In the novel, pregnancy is symbolic on multiple levels. It serves as a woman’s way to exert power over men and their relationships. But it also represents the highest form of love: that of a mother to a child. For Seth, pregnancy represents his virility and his desire to carry on his genes: The women in his life are only vehicles for carrying his children. This is why he leaves Regina after she declares that she will not try to get pregnant after her miscarriage. Seth's view that women are secondary to the children they can provide him manifests in his drugging Thursday after he impregnates her. He never states why he doesn’t want a child with her, but it is clear he wants to keep her as a mistress, just not as a wife. This is a blow to Thursday because she knows Seth really wants children, and it is infinitely cruel, not to mention criminal, on Seth’s part.
The concept of “trapping” someone in a marriage with a pregnancy is explored several times in the novel. First, Thursday’s mother encourages her to get pregnant so that Seth will not have another choice but to be at home more often; she does not know about Thursday’s miscarriage. Despite Thursday’s strong desire to keep Seth, she disagrees with her mother, believing the idea to be extremely manipulative. Later in the novel, she wonders whether Seth would have stayed with her if she hadn’t had a miscarriage, not knowing that it happened by Seth’s design. In a gendered reversal of this trope, Seth traps Hannah in their marriage by hiding her birth control, which leads to her pregnancy. This image of trapping women in a pregnancy represents a woman’s loss of autonomy and power within society. One of the powers women do have is their ability to become pregnant; once that is managed by men, a woman’s power over her situation disappears. Hannah as a character represents this concept. She remains ignorant and powerless throughout the novel, kept in the dark by Seth and completely helpless in her situation.
The idea that men hold power over women is prevalent throughout the novel through Seth’s character. Seth holds a different kind of power over each of his romantic partners. Seth has mental and emotional power over Thursday. When Seth places Thursday in the hospital, the doctors are eager to listen to his words over Thursday’s despite there being no actual marital relationship between them. Because Thursday’s identity is so deeply intertwined with Seth’s preferences and desires, she becomes mentally and emotionally dependent on him. Seth holds financial power over Regina after having fallen near bankruptcy during their marriage and taking out many loans in both of their names. Seth remains in Regina’s life because she depends on him to pay off the loans, and they also maintain their affair. Seth’s power over Hannah works in two different ways. First, he has physical power over her, using his temper as an excuse to become physically aggressive toward her. Second, he has power over her knowledge; he determines what she knows about him and his relationships by purposefully keeping her unaware and away from the others.
The concept of perfection is a motif with which Thursday attempts to come to terms during the novel. Perfection is an idea that she has tied to her success or failure as Seth’s wife. Within the first chapter of the novel, Thursday’s obsession with perfection becomes apparent as she remarks about her picturesque dining room table and how she has readied herself for Seth’s arrival home. She remarks that her concept of the “perfect” wife originated from her parents, who have very strict ideas about what a woman’s role within society is. Women, according to Thursday, are expected to live up to an unattainable standard of perfection for their husbands. It is her drive to have the “perfect life” that leads Thursday into her obsession with finding out the truth about Hannah and Regina.
While Thursday feels she must devote her life to attaining perfection, she endows Seth with a godlike status without him doing anything to earn it. She reflects on this later, as she begins to wonder why, exactly, she placed so much emphasis on pleasing him. This power imbalance—that women must constantly strive for perfection while men inherently have it—is something the novel explores. Seth is revealed to be far from perfect, but so are the women Thursday idolizes. At first, Hannah and Regina represent (opposing) forms of female perfection that Thursday will forever be unable to attain. Hannah is the beautiful young pregnant wife while Regina is the consummate career woman. Thursday, a night nurse, is neither of those things. Even when the facades of the other women’s perfection drop away, Thursday can’t take the pressure off herself; she invents more reasons to strive for perfection despite knowing the quest is futile. This, the novel comments, is the main way that patriarchal society traps women into self-doubt, even to the point of insanity.
By Tarryn Fisher