64 pages • 2 hours read
Mario Vargas LlosaA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In Canudos, work begins on building the Temple the day after the Counselor and his followers arrive. It will have two tall towers and be consecrated to the Blessed Jesus. Newcomers arrive each day to join the community. Every evening, the Counselor preaches welcome and makes prophecies about the imminent end of the world. Buildings known as the Health Houses are built for the sick, and a hut called the Sanctuary, where the Counselor snatches a few hours rest from the pilgrims eager for his attention. Maria Quadrado, now known as the Mother of Men, is in charge of the Health Houses.
Gall has been waiting eight days in Quiemadas for Rufino to contact him again. Through his window, he overhears propaganda from the Progressivist Republican Party, led by Epaminondas Gonçalves. The police deliver him a notice expelling him from Brazil. Gall is not alarmed. He finishes his article to L’Etincelle de la révolte and tries to post his ad supporting Canudos in Gonçalves’s opposition paper (per the events of Chapter 1). Two days before his boat is meant to sail, some men arrive and bring Gall to meet secretly with Gonçalves, who proposes a plan: Gall will bring arms to the rebels in Canudos, because they share the same enemy, the Baron de Canabrava. Gall accepts the proposal.
João, a young sertanejo, loves listening to the stories told by travelling minstrels when they visit his village. His favorite is of Robert the Devil, a brutal bandit who did penance “going on all fours, barking instead of speaking” before rescuing the Emperor and marrying the Queen of Brazil (56). He lives with his uncle, a shopkeeper who does business with bandits. When the National Guard rides in, the villagers point out the shopkeeper as a collaborator, and the guardsmen shoot him and his wife to death. João vows revenge on the guardsmen and the villagers, joining a group of bandits and becoming known as Satan João for his cruelty. Years later, leading his own band, he takes brutal revenge on his old village, murdering all the men and raping the women. One day, however, he hears the Counselor preach about a sinner who “repented, lived a dog’s life” and went to heaven (64). Satan João tells him who he is and the Counselor renames him Abbot João, an apostle.
Canudos learns from a group of pilgrims that soldiers are on their way to capture the Counselor. They march out to meet them, carrying religious relics and a wooden cross, ambushing the army at dawn. Many die, but the soldiers are put to flight. To honor the victory, a street in Canudos is named after Big João, who led the attack.
Galileo Gall and Epaminondas Gonçalves discuss Canudos the night before Gall is meant to pick up the weapons. Gall mentions that Rufino used to work for the Baron de Canabrava. He gives Gonçalves another article to post to France.
Antônio and Honório Vilanova are brothers who work as merchants in Bahia, having fled a smallpox epidemic in their hometown. Antônio travels, supplying sugar, cloth and other goods to villages and haciendas, while Honório runs their store at home with their wives, the Sardelinha sisters. The 1877 drought destroys their business. Their store is looted and they lose everything they have built. They wander the parched backlands surviving on scraps. Both Honório’s sons die. As they are interring the second, the Counselor arrives and demands they give him a proper burial. When Antônio tries to pay him, the Counselor refuses the Republic’s money: “You haven’t learned to count, my son” (79). They build a new business dealing in animals and salt, but a flood destroys that one too. Antônio considers it the third “warning” sent so that they would do something, “but I don’t know what” (80). Wandering once more, they settle in the hacienda at Canudos. When the Counselor arrives, Antônio falls to his knees. He asks, “Have you learned to count yet?” (81).
The chapter’s last section is the article Gall gave to Gonçalves. He celebrates Canudos’s victory over the army detachment and reveals that he has met an emissary, an impassive man who says all land belongs to God. Gall tries to persuade his readers that Canudos is not a reactionary movement and wonders at the Counselor’s buried motivations.
In response to the embarrassing defeat at Uauá the army sends a much bigger force, armed with cannons, to Queimadas. Unprepared for the conditions, they are near starving not long after beginning the march.
Galileo Gall rants at Jurema, Rufino’s wife, because her husband has taken another job that has delayed their departure. She defends the Baron de Canabrava for having looked after them and doesn’t understand Gall’s position on Canudos. She identifies the emissary from his article as Pajeú, a feared bandit. Suddenly, the house is attacked; Gall shoots two men but others escape with the rifles. Comforting the hysterical Jurema, Gall is seized by an “ambiguous, urgent, intense” urge, and rapes her (94).
In the town of Natuba, a baby is born with short legs and a grotesquely enlarged head. His thick hair gives him the appearance of a lion, which becomes his nickname. Rumors abound that he is the son of the devil, which intensify when he reads a poster despite never receiving a single lesson. He soon begins writing correspondence for the villagers, but this doesn’t stop people bullying him. The tinsmith’s daughter is taken sick, and a healer claims she is the victim of a curse; because the Lion was seen talking to her, he is identified as the one who cast the spell. The girl dies and her father prepares to burn the Lion at the stake the next morning. This is when the Counselor arrives. He ensures the girl has been buried properly, before rebuking the tinsmith for his “ungodly” superstition (100). The tinsmith unties the Lion and when the Counselor leaves Natuba, he is seen following.
Galileo Gall awakens on Jurema’s floor, amazed at what he has done. For 10 years he had kept a vow made with a fellow anarchist who was a compulsive sadist, not to touch another woman. This impulsiveness goes against his belief in rationality. But Gall has no pity for Jurema. He hopes it was Pajeú who stole the rifles. Then he hears footsteps and a voice.
Guides helping Major Febrônio de Brito’s column desert the soldiers and arrive in Canudos, begging forgiveness. After the Counselor has finished preaching, he sends Abbot João and Pajeú with their men to the mountains where the guides say the army is located. The army’s artillery proves deadly, and the jagunços beat a retreat. Victorious, the soldiers stretch out on an open plain. Realizing their guard is down, Abbot João counterattacks. The soldiers are slaughtered, their corpses looted, and the wounded jagunços taken back to the Health Houses.
The voice at Jurema’s belongs to Caifás, the guide who brought Galileo Gall to Epaminondas Gonçalves. He has come to warn Rufino that Major Brito’s army is recruiting guides to Canudos by force. Gall thinks the men earlier were not only there for the guns; but also to kill him. Suddenly Caifás lashes out, stabbing him and wounding him in the face with a pistol shot. As he is about to kill Gall, Caifás reveals that Gonçalves sent him, because “[h]e needs an English corpse” (113). But Jurema seizes his hand; after a struggle, Gall gets the pistol and she does the same thing, stopping him killing Caifás.
The parish priest of Cumbe, Dom Joaquim, has a weakness for drink and women. He establishes a relationship with Alexandrinha Correa, a water divineress who lives with him as his “caretaker” (117). One day the Counselor preaches in church, railing against “bad shepherds,” humiliating Dom Joaquim (118). He leaves town whenever the Counselor is there, whereas Alexandrinha grows ever more devout, finally departing with his followers.
Galileo Gall and Jurema are huddled around a fire in the wilderness, having escaped Queimadas. Earlier, their mule died and Gall fell on top of Jurema, raping her a second time. She simply lay there and when it was over gathered branches for the fire. Gall remembers that the rifles were English, not French as Epaminondas Gonçalves had promised. He starts to suspect the plot is connected with England. His wounds are causing him immense pain, but he vows to reach Canudos and join the fight against everything the “bourgeois” Gonçalves represents (123).
The Counselor’s arrival in Canudos gives him a chance to put his utopian ideas into practice. His priorities are religious first, with the building of the Temple, then for the wellbeing of his followers, with the construction of the Health Houses—a primitive kind of hospital. This follows immediately after Gall’s article, emphasizing the contrast between their ideologies; ironic given that Gall’s argument was an attempt to show how similar they in fact were.
The interlocking timelines become more complex from Chapter 4. The Counselor’s arrival in Canudos takes place in 1893; Gall’s narrative in 1896; the introductions to Abbot João, the Lion of Natuba, Father Joaquim, and the Vilanova brothers at various unspecified times in the 1880s and 1870s. In this way, Vargas Llosa deepens his kaleidoscopic picture of life in Bahia through this historical period. Gall’s life is of an outsider observing the urban society of Salvador and Queimadas from a remove. He functions as a reader-surrogate, caught up in the politics without recognizing the ends of the plots in which he is involved. Key details, such as Caifás shaving his red hair, are highlighted as pieces of a larger conspiracy that is unveiled slowly. Vargas Llosa uses this technique, inspired by mystery novels, to build the sense of larger political players pulling the strings.
Structurally, Gall’s journey is the opposite of the Counselor and his followers’ journeys. Whereas they spend years travelling the backlands and eventually settle in Canudos, refusing to be moved by military threats, Gall abandons civilization to enter the wilderness, hoping eventually to reach Canudos and witness its authentic revolution. His rigid European rationalism begins to break down; he kills two assassins sent by Gonçalves before raping Jurema after 10 years of celibacy. The “sudden, incomprehensible, irrepressible impulse” that makes him do this contrasts completely with his scientific philosophy of human motivations, the idea that human character can be determined by the shape of people’s skulls (101). Gall’s inability to change his ideas is thus established as the root of his tragic fate.
In contrast to Gall’s rigidity is the story of Satan/Abbot João. He exemplifies the most dramatic shift of all the Counselor’s followers. In Chapter 5, his extreme capacity for violence makes him the most feared bandit in Bahia. But beginning in this chapter, he becomes the Counselor’s fiercest defender. On the literal level, this exhibits the theme of The Radical Power of Religious Fanaticism: An inveterate thief and murderer, granted a sense of purpose by the Counselor’s religious vision, becomes a revolutionary. But Abbot João’s story also shows How Stories Create History. His obsession with the tale of Robert the Devil mimics his own character arc, providing him with a model he strives to emulate. Vargas Llosa shows the power of fiction operating on an individual, whose subsequent actions shape the war. Left unresolved is the moral question of whether João can ever adequately repent for his appalling actions.
By Mario Vargas Llosa