29 pages • 58 minutes read
Willa CatherA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The palm leaf is a common Christian symbol for victory and Christ. The Bible notes that the people of Jerusalem threw palm leaves at the feet of Jesus as he entered the city just days before he was betrayed and crucified. The palm leaf on Merrick’s casket symbolizes both his success as an artist and his betrayal by the townspeople whose inability to recognize the value of his artistic successes condemned him to a life of bitterness and exile. The palm leaf also fits into a larger motif of Christian imagery that depicts the sculptor as a sainted martyr for his appreciation of beauty; the townspeople condemn the artist, just as the public condemned Christ by calling for his crucifixion. This connection is made explicit when Steavens recalls a conversation in which Merrick bitterly explained that he “has nothing to fear from the judgment of God,” suggesting that it will be less stringent than the condemnation he will face from the people in his hometown. He also compares his art to a “Victory,” which evokes the palm leaf motif as it develops the theme of The Artist Against Society (334).
The town symbolizes the collective social expectations that paradoxically protect and condemn the townspeople. The only physical description of the town is of the Merrick homestead, which is falling into decay on its exterior, having been beaten into disrepair by the elements. Within, the house is decorated by excessive displays of materialism, such as “fat plush upholstery […]; hand painted china plaques and panels and vases” (331). Meanwhile, the room itself is “unheated” and “smelled of dampness and disuse” (331). This contrast suggesting the shallowness and inconsistency of the townspeople; they display the trappings of financial security and middle-class stability but lack warmth and are decayed at their cores. Willa Cather develops this symbolism further through a motif that depicts the townspeople as a single entity as they rely upon one another for protection from life on the prairie. Individual townspeople occasionally “[shuffle] out from the group” (329), but the men lack any sense of individual identity. She also describes the group in increasingly derogative terms such as “uneasy,” “awkward,” and “stoop-shouldered.” The cumulative effect of this imagery is off-putting to outsiders, such as Steavens. The depiction of the town and the townspeople illustrates the conformity that the danger of life on the frontier cultivates and contributes to the theme of The Artist Against Society by framing the artist as an outsider.
Like the town, which represents the people and their social expectations, the body of Merrick represents more than the physical return of his body within the theme of Exile and Homecoming. Cather also fits the body within the motif of the artist as noble and pure. While looking upon him in his casket, Steavens describes his head as “splendid” before linking the “rigid stillness” of the corpse to nobility. This connects the appearance of the body to the former spirit of the artist. The author maintains this connection to develop the motif when Steavens observes the features of his teacher’s face and imagines that its lines represent his struggle to “[guard] something precious and holy” from society (331). Later, Steavens observes Laird sitting with the body and contrasts Merrick, a “porcelain vessel,” with the rough countenance of the lawyer, a “lump of potter’s clay” that has the potential to appreciate and understand the artist (332). This motif further develops the theme of The Artist Against Society.
By Willa Cather