56 pages • 1 hour read
Dorothy DayA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Day goes to Washington to protest the imprisonment of the suffragettes. She has a struggle with some men who try to grab the banners that they are marching with and is put in a police van: “Our banners were carried, protruding from the back of the car, and we made a gay procession through the streets” (73). Day and her fellow female protestors are tried the next day and the judge determines that they are guilty, but postpones the sentence.
They are arrested for picketing twice more. At the point of the third arrest, they are refused bail and taken to the House of Detention. They are sentenced in the morning. Day gets 30 days. Some of the leaders get six months. The women are taken in wagons and then by train to a workhouse. Their leaders tell the administration that all of the women plan to go on a hunger strike. The guards grab the women roughly and when Day tries to cross the room, in order to be nearer to a friend, she is seized. She resists, which just makes them grip her tighter. They throw her down on a bench, and when she again tries to be with her friend, they toss her to the floor and “pummeled and pushed and kicked and dragged” her (76). The New York Times later called it a riot.
Day participates in the accompanying hunger strike. The guards keep bringing in aromatic food to punish the prisoners. Still, she resists. Being in jail leaves Day with a lot of time to contemplate ideas, including what is right and wrong, what is good and what is evil: “Never would I recover from this wound, this ugly knowledge I had gained of what men were capable of in their treatment of each other” (79). However, she does get to experience firsthand the hardships that she had covered as a journalist.
As their imprisonment wears on, Day asks for a bible. She begins to read the Psalms from her childhood, which comfort her. However, she does not want to be dependent on God, especially in defeat:
I was like the child that wants to walk by itself, I kept brushing away the hand that held me up. I tried to persuade myself that I was reading for literary enjoyment. But the words kept echoing in my heart. I prayed and did not know that I prayed (81).
Day keeps leaning on God when she feels like she isn’t supposed to. She wants to be self-sufficient and believe only in the movement.
Day eats a bit of bread on the eighth day. The hunger strike ends up lasting for 10 days. They are given a few meals and then are finally transferred to another jail. There is more freedom there and conversation is allowed. Day begins to forget how her reliance on religion had helped her but also made her ashamed.
After returning from Washington DC, Day rents furnished rooms in various New York neighborhoods. She works for The Liberator magazine, which is the replacement for The Masses. The sheen of working at a magazine has faded. After a night out with her friends, Day sometimes goes to morning Mass just to be in the comforting environment of a church. She feels a need to be “there in the atmosphere of prayer—it was an act of the will” (85). Though her faith at this time seems to be due to some sort of gravitational pull, the conversations she has with her friends are about ideas and revolution.
Indeed, at that time, it seems as if workers would take control of the means of production. She and her young friends are living in the present moment. However, they really don’t know very much about Marxist ideas. Lenin is rising in power. He has left the farm that he had started and attends law school. He begins to see a woman who helps the poor in the slums and then develops his idea of a revolution led by industrial workers. Eventually, Lenin’s proletariat becomes a dictatorship of elites, frustrating Day. She and her friends are not poor, either; rather they are taking on voluntary poverty in order to help others: “The word charity had become something to gag over, something to shudder at” (87). Their goal is justice instead of welfare.
Later in the year, the former editors of The Masses are put on trial and Day is subpoenaed as a state witness. She works with the defense attorney and ends up being a bad witness for the state. In the meantime, World War One is in full swing and Day cannot continue to live a life free from any knowledge of the war. She has family members who are nurses. Though Day is a pacifist when it comes to war (but not the revolution), she decides to become a probationary nurse at King’s County Hospital in Brooklyn to fill in for the many nurses who have been sent abroad.
Day begins work as a nurse at the King’s County Hospital in 1918. Her friends complain that she is freeing other nurses to go to the front and assist the soldiers. Day insists that she is helping the poor. The hospital is a free hospital, so this aligns with her ideals.
When she works at the hospital, Day sees the closeness of life and death. In fact, the war coincides with the heart of the influenza epidemic and many of her patients die. Day reflects that “[n]ursing was like newspaper work. It was impossible to suffer long over the tragedies which took place every day” because all of the nurses were just too busy (92).
Day also begins to go to Mass with another nurse. She questions humankind’s purpose. Why does the Lord watch over him? What is the meaning of life? She begins to think that worship is necessary for human beings because only then are they truly themselves.
Day ends up being a nurse for a year, but then she is drawn back to her first love: journalism. As a nurse, she is too busy and exhausted to really even experience Armistice Day. This perhaps leads her to feel like she is missing out on the major world events that journalists count on and wish to experience and analyze. Day tells the head nurse that she is leaving. Her supervisor is very displeased and retorts that Day is only quitting because she feels that she is too good for the work.
Day then mentions that there is not very much to say about the next few years of her life: “I never intended to write an autobiography. I have always wanted instead to tell of things that brought me to God and that reminded me of God” (94). She also does not want to write too closely about people that she was friends with because she does not want to reveal intimate details of their lives.
Day is arrested again after she moves back to Chicago. This only serves to make her a bigger supporter of the revolution. She has been staying with a mentally unstable friend in IWW housing and they are arrested in a “Palmer Red Raid” for being prostitutes (99). They have to wait on the street for the police wagon while barely clothed. Day is ashamed because she feels like she has been careless by staying in the house, where women are not allowed. She is picked up as part of the red hysteria of the times, but also because of her carelessness. Day hates to discuss this incident, but she is glad that she had the experience “of thousands who had worked for labor” (99). As a picketer, she always feels a vulnerability, like she is in the wrong, but there is incremental change coming from the labor protests.
When she is in jail, Day feels the anguish of the other women imprisoned there: “It was a valid experience, I felt, and I was sharing, as I never had before, the life of the poorest of the poor, the guilty, the dispossessed” (104). She also remarks that she was inside yet outside of the incident because of her privilege. Indeed, Day is able to get out of jail because of her connections.
While in Chicago, Day lives with Catholics. They do not try to convert her, but she begins to learn Catholic terminology from them. Day likes that they judge actions over talk. She is also attracted to the fact that Catholicism is the religion of the workers.
The book Day is working on sells that spring, as do the movie rights. With the $5,000 in proceeds, Day returns to New York and buys a beachfront house on Staten Island.
These chapters show Day’s gradual turn back to religion. When she participates in a protest for women’s suffrage in Washington DC and is jailed, she experiences extreme cruelty from the prison warden, getting kicked and beaten. One of the only things that keeps Day from going crazy during the eight days she is on hunger strike is a bible. The Psalms from her childhood give her the strength to continue striking. However, this source of strength is also a source of shame. She does not want to depend on God for fortitude. Day wants her conviction to come from the labor movement and socialism. Though she does not wish to acknowledge it, religion is one of the things that helps her to pull through a difficult experience.
After getting out of jail, Day finds solace in like-minded friends. They believe in justice over welfare. “Charity” is a misnomer. In order to truly help someone, one has to actively take part in that person’s suffering and sacrifice their own comfort to assist them. However, in the midst of agreeing with her friends, Day also begins to go to morning Mass. She writes that she does not think she made the decision quite consciously, but that her body somehow brought her to a place that her soul craved. This is the beginning of Day’s transition from living a life in the natural world to existing on both natural and supernatural/spiritual planes. The religious pull gets even stronger after Day becomes a nurse in Brooklyn in 1918.
When Day goes into nursing, some of her pacifist friends balk because she is freeing up other nurses to go to the European front, thereby aiding the war effort. However, Day knows that she is doing it to help the poor and sticks to the job. To cope with the flu deaths all around her, she begins to go to Mass with another nurse. She starts to question the purpose of life on earth: why did the Lord watch over everyone? As she prays at the hospital, Day begins to again think of worship as necessary because it allows humans to explore and find the essential parts of themselves. This introspection, this stripping bare, in Day’s estimation, actually allows a person to not only analyze their relationship with God, but their ideologies, as well.
After leaving nursing, Day is imprisoned again. This time she is caught up in a “red raid” in Chicago. Standing out on the street in her nightclothes after being dragged out of the house, Day experiences the shame of a woman who might actually inhabit that role. Throughout her night in jail, she feels embarrassed, but also like she is truly experiencing the plight of the destitute. To be able to truly understand the life of someone else allows Day to be a better advocate for them.
While in Chicago, Day also stays connected to religion. Living with Catholics plants the seeds for her later conversion to Catholicism, as she realizes it is the religion of the masses, of the poor. She also appreciates that it is a religion that lauds action, just like her political beliefs emphasize taking action.