61 pages • 2 hours read
Aleksandr SolzhenitsynA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The Gulag’s labor camps were essentially “murder camps” (331) which simply prolonged an inmate’s execution and extract valuable labor from the condemned. The inmates who are worked to death are starved, beaten, and mistreated beyond even what was inflicted on normal inmates. Solzhenitsyn acknowledges that some of his compatriots blame these inmates for bringing about their own fate. Solzhenitsyn defends the inmates, such as the women who were imprisoned for having sex with German soldiers, as being products of the society which now condemns them. He points to World War II as an example of “the most righteous war in our history” (335) which nevertheless ended with tens of thousands of Russians accused of treason and sent to the camps. Solzhenitsyn then criticizes the apologists for the Soviet Union, who he believes blame Stalin for all the Gulag’s problems. He notes the irony that, during World War II, many former inmates were asked to fight for the same state which had imprisoned them, even while Nazis uncovered mass graves in former Soviet territories. People in communities affected by these atrocities might, understandably not wish to fight for the Soviet Union, and Solzhenitsyn is shocked neither that people would resent Stalin’s Soviet Union nor that, as a result, the Nazis could quickly invade so much of Russia with so little resistance. He criticizes the Soviet Union as more heinous than Nazi Germany, and he criticizes Western countries for their failure to help the Russian people.
In a short chapter, Solzhenitsyn explores the idea of revolution and resistance. He addresses relationships between Ukrainians and Russians, as well as the spirit of resistance among prisoners of the Gulag.
Solzhenitsyn describes the chains and handcuffs used to secure prisoners in the Gulag. They were used “religiously” (346) to keep prisoners under control and to inflict additional pain. Inmates were also assigned numbers in place of names, and this practice was another attempt to dehumanize the prisoners. Some brave prisoners fought back against these practices and even managed to win some concessions from the guards.
Throughout Russian history, the Russian people have endured “a succession of tyrannies” (348). Solzhenitsyn believes that the Soviet Union is the latest in a long line of tyrannical regimes, but that the Soviets’ use of the Gulag is uniquely cruel and tyrannical. For example, Lenin, whose own brother attempted to assassinate Tsar Alexander III, was allowed to attend university. Solzhenitsyn believes that, under the Soviet regime, Lenin himself would have been sent to the Gulag. He describes the pleasant conditions of Lenin’s imprisonment and exile under the Tsarist regime. Solzhenitsyn credits the Tsarist government for being more lenient than the following regime, but also criticizes it for allowing the Russian Revolution to take place due to the relaxed treatment of prisoners such as Lenin. Solzhenitsyn points to the numerous escapes and uprisings in the Gulag to suggest that the inmates did not “put up with it” (354).
Solzhenitsyn describes how his attitudes to work duty evolved over the course of his sentence. Settling into a specialized work role allowed him to clear his mind and gave him more time to think about writing. He wished to write a poem but struggled to find an opportunity to write. Without writing tools, he had to memorize every word of his work, using a specially made rosary to aid the memorization. The guards did not take away the rosary, as they believed that he was a religious person. He knows that other people wanted to write and that they used different methods to preserve their words, but each writer was too scared to talk to another. Eventually, Solzhenitsyn opened up to several writers and they shared their work with one another.
The people who made regular escape attempts from the Gulag were known as committed escapers. These people knew the risks involved, but they couldn’t stand their confinement. The committed escapers were the reason security measures were so tight, but they denied that their behavior might negatively impact others.
Solzhenitsyn recalls the life of a committed escaper named Georgi Pavlovich Tenno; “the urge to escape had been with him from birth” (362). Tenno was multilingual, acrobatic, and completely dedicated to escaping. Solzhenitsyn recounts Tenno’s various escape attempts. Tenno planned carefully but often ran into unexpected problems. He talked to other committed escapers and learned more escape strategies. He constantly searched for weaknesses, opportunities, and allies. Because Tenno was prepared to die, he believed that he was prepared to escape.
Solzhenitsyn’s description of the chains used in the Gulag provides a useful metaphor for the inmates’ captured minds. Just as their hands were locked together, their minds were shackled to thoughts of their own imprisonment. The Gulag’s influence on Solzhenitsyn is a constant subtext in the book. Throughout, his focus wavers and switches to the camps’ brutality. Many chapters begin with a limited focus—such as the chains and handcuffs—but quickly return to the routine torture Solzhenitsyn and others experienced. Some part of Solzhenitsyn remains captive to his trauma, the memories of which hold him as securely as the cuffs formerly fastened around his wrists.
One of Solzhenitsyn’s acts of resistance was to compose a poem. He had no writing tools, so he had to memorize every line of the poem. This massive undertaking required tremendous mental effort, especially within a punishing physical environment—and yet, Solzhenitsyn’s effort was a testament to his desire to fight back and reclaim his identity. The Gulag had robbed this writer of his ability to write and had nearly erased his personhood, but through mental composition, Solzhenitsyn could defy this oppression. His authorship was his rebellion.
The desire to reclaim identity also appears in the story of Tenno. The committed escaper routinely tried to break free from the Gulag, but his efforts always failed. His attempts were not about the desire to be free, but the desire to reestablish agency in a world which denied it to him. The Gulag trapped and confined Tenno, turning him into a passive inhabitant who had no control over his destiny. Tenno fought back against this. By trying to escape, he was showing the Gulag that he refused to be passive. The act of trying to escape was more important than escape itself. Tenno had no plan for what he would do when he was free, but he wanted to reclaim control over his existence.
By Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Fear
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Philosophy, Logic, & Ethics
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
World War II
View Collection