42 pages • 1 hour read
Doris LessingA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The chapter opens with a newspaper clipping announcing the death of Mary Turner, wife of Richard “Dick” Turner. The announcement also mentions that the house servant, a native named Moses, has confessed to the crime and been arrested. The narrative then switches to the reactions of “the district,” the white farming community to which the Turners belonged. Interestingly, though one of their own has been murdered, none of the white farmers really mention the murder. Charlie Slatter, the Turners’ neighbor, handles the case himself, though the silence of the community is seemingly agreed upon without him needing to saying anything.
Moreover, though the farmers are surprised by the news, they are not shocked. As the Turners are disliked by most of the community, no one really grieves for Mary, either. The Turners shirked their social responsibilities and never engaged with the other families, thus breaking the social code of the small white community. The community also dislikes the Turners because they lived poorly, and in some sense, as poorly as some natives. Their house is considered a hovel, one similar in design to even some of the natives’ houses. Their lack of decorum affronted their neighbors in the district and their sense of white superiority. Though some do in fact pity Dick Turner, they despise Mary to the point of thinking she deserved to be murdered. No one asks questions, but several questions cloud the murder. One question is why Charlie Slatter took such command of the incident. Another is why and how Mary had managed to be murdered in such a way by her native servant. People suspected why, it is revealed, but none dared say anything.
Other narrative inquiries reveal that Charlie Slatter was the first person informed about the murder, not the police or Dick’s assistant, Tony Marston. Due to possible gossip, Charlie wrote a note to Sergeant Denham informing him of the murder, then drove the five miles to Dick’s farm, taking command of the situation. It is also revealed that Moses gave himself up willingly. When people wonder why he had done so, it is suggested that the natives do have some sense of obligation to in doing the right thing, despite the white man’s belief that they are all crooked and evil. When Dick Turner returns to his farm and the black policemen realize that he is traumatized, they do not touch him, as he is white, and so leave him for Charlie Slatter to help him.
As Charlie approaches, the narrative shifts to his story, explaining how he started with nothing and became a wealthy farmer. He has a temper and once killed a native in anger. He has a sjambok (whip) he uses when farming and convinced the Turners to get one. The weapon is revealed to be a key component of the murder.
Charlie arrives to the Turner farm and finds a calm Moses and a bewildered Dick Turner. He escorts Dick to his car. He then questions Marston about why he did not inform Slatter of the murder himself. Marston did not know until later as he slept late and was not awakened by Dick Turner. Marston explains that he found Mary’s body on the veranda, but that he moved it inside as the dogs were licking at the body. Charlie views the body with contempt and disgust, though Marston does not see this look. Charlie then asks Marston, whom he dislikes for his newness to South African life, what he thinks happened. His tone warns Marston, causing the young man to question what he should say. Marston seems to know more about the murder and the state of the house than indicated initially, but is frightened by Charlie’s guarded, subtle inquiry. The narration reveals that Marston’s youth and newness make things difficult for him. Because of his unique background, he views the natives as human beings and has a sense of morality that is at odds with the way things are done in South Africa.
Charlie snubs Marston when he mentions that he has an idea about why the murder occurred. The older man tells Marston that he had better leave his ideas for the sergeant. When Denham arrives, he treats Marston with the same superior attitude. There is something guarded and hesitant in his questioning as well, and he looks at Charlie several times, as if the two men are silently conspiring. Marston becomes so angry at the way he is being treated that he finally explains what he thinks happened. He also suggests that what has happened is not as simple as “black and white.” Denham tells Marston that they want facts, not theories, and that he can say what he wants at the trial. Denham, too, looks at Mary’s body with disgust, and this time Marston sees the look. Her body is loaded into one car, while Dick is placed in the other, leaving Moses to walk into town to await his trial and execution.
Marston is disgusted by the entire ordeal and decides to leave it alone. The narrative then explains how Marston leaves the farm, wandering around and taking odd jobs. In the end, he settles into a desk job, which is ironic in that he had come to South Africa to escape a desk job. In the farming community he left, Marston is viewed as a young man who did not have the stomach to “stick it out” with farm life.
The chapter begins by explaining how the “store” is a monumental institution in South Africa, and holds meaning for many South Africans that often links to their childhood. The store is where social life takes place, where families receive mail from abroad and where Mary herself spent much of her childhood, for better and worse. Mary’s family often went to the store, where they received letters from family in England and Mary’s father spent his money on alcohol. To combat her embarrassment and fear of her drunken father, Mary had to endure her mother’s dramatic protestations where she attacked the store owner for selling her husband liquor when they needed the money to survive. Mary’s parents had a broken relationship, and she often found herself an unwilling confidante for her mother.
One occasion that caused Mary happiness during childhood was the death of her two elder siblings from dysentery. Mary was always overshadowed by the two dead children. Their deaths brought her parents together for a while in mutual grief, though this “good time” did not last. They were soon back to bickering. Mary eventually went away to school and was delighted to be away from her quarreling mother and drunken father. She eventually found a job as a secretary. By the time she was 20, she had a nice job and great friends, and lived an independent life in the city.
Mary’s city life becomes filled with work and fun. She gives no real thought to the native question or concerns herself with them. Instead, she is happy to be alone in the world after the death of both her parents. Mary lives in a girls’ club, and though she is at the age to marry, never gives it any thought. She continues to dress as she did when she was an adolescent, and has many suitors, but is never serious about any of them. She loves being social, but never feels the need to settle down as her friends are doing.
Mary’s world soon shatters when she overhears some of her supposed friends at a party one night. They are commenting on how she refuses to get married and still dresses like an adolescent. Though they are not devastatingly mean, Mary interprets the gossip as them strongly disliking her. She soon sets out to change her appearance and begins dating seriously, though she scandalizes herself by running away after saying yes to a suitor who proposes to her and tries making out with her immediately after. Mary’s entire outlook on life changes due to this gossip and she no longer feels social and confident. Her work suffers. Her employer notices and asks her to take some time off. Mary soon has a nervous breakdown.
The narrative then switches to the point-of-view of Dick Turner. Dick is a struggling farmer with bad luck. He has dreams of being successful and of marrying, but cannot think of having a wife and children until his farm is successful. He first sees Mary at the cinema, where she spends most of her nights since leaving work. Dick is claustrophobic and hates the cinema, but somehow allows himself to be talked into going as he is in town for supplies for his farm. He sees Mary in the cinema but does not yet know who she is. Dick falls in love at first sight and even dreams of Mary. He makes a special trip into town later to find her after obtaining her name from someone else, but is surprised when he locates her as she does not look like the woman of his dreams. Mary seems to embody everything that Dick does not like in a woman. Their first date is awkward and Dick returns to his farm, confused.
The narrative shifts back to Mary, and the reader learns that she has become obsessed with Dick as a suitor. She thinks that Dick Turner is the solution to her problems and wonders why he has not returned from the farm. Though Dick also sees Mary as a solution to his problem of marriage, he is reluctant to see her again and indeed stays away from her for months. She has just about forgotten him when he returns to town and proposes. Mary accepts the proposal and the two marry quickly. Mary is relieved that there is no honeymoon.
The narrative begins by highlighting the plot of the novel. The reader finds that Mary Turner has been murdered by her servant, Moses, but no concrete motives are given. The narrator hints that most of the white farmers may know the real reasons for the murder but that no one will admit to those reasons. The silence on the part of the white farmers is indicative of their fear of the natives, especially when “breaks” in the social hierarchy like murder, rape and theft take place against whites. The silence on the part of the white farmers, including Charlie Slatter and Denham, is both an acknowledgment of their fear of native uprisings and their staunch refusal to change their beliefs that “white is right,” regardless of the circumstances.
The strict social rules that the white farmers have in place are supposed to be followed by everyone in “the district.” It is suggested that Mary and Dick Turner did not follow these rules. Because of their self-imposed roles as outsiders among their own kind, their misfortune is viewed as well-deserved and self-inflicted. The role of Tony Marston in the narrative is symbolic of what happens to those who push back against the strict rules and roles of the white farming community. He effectively becomes a cautionary tale to other would-be defectors. Like Marston, Mary and Dick Turner are added to the list of cautionary tales for their refusal to follow the rules. This closing of ranks highlights an institutionalized racism at the heart of the white farmers’ code of ethics, and is a racism that even the group’s apparent enemies, such as the Turners, hold dear.
Chapter Two flashes back to the beginning of Dick and Mary’s narrative, showing how they fell in love and ended up eventually murdered or insane, having lost their farm. The contrast between Chapter 1’s hated Mary and the loveable Mary in the second is powerful, and effectively shows just how far Mary must have fallen in her estimation of self and others to end up murdered by journey’s end. The contrast is also effective in cautioning readers against first impressions and “judging a book by its cover.” Had Lessing started the novel with the second chapter, readers might have duped themselves into thinking of Mary as a bright and loveable character free of the racism that she is eventually shown to believe.
Chapter Two also highlights how precarious the lives of Dick and Mary were from the very beginning of their relationship. Their marriage was rushed, and the two had not genuinely liked one another for the “right” reasons, so to speak. They both settled for the other, married in near desperation. The consequences of this hasty and perhaps ill-thought out marriage speaks volumes and leaves the reader in suspense as to how their rushed marriage could have possibly ended in murder and insanity.
By Doris Lessing