51 pages • 1 hour read
Paula HawkinsA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Picking up where Rachel’s last chapter left off, this chapter covers three days: July 16-18, broken into morning and evening sections. On July 16, Rachel reads the news and learns some information about Megan, including that she is unemployed and has lost both her parents. Rachel also learns some information about Scott, including that he has a job in IT and that he and Megan had an argument before she disappeared. While riding the train to Witney, Rachel writes a list of possibilities, such as Megan running away with her lover (who Rachel is calling B), or different people hurting Megan. However, Rachel doesn’t believe Scott has hurt Megan.
That evening, Rachel gets a voicemail from Cathy saying she doesn’t have to move out so soon. On the train, Rachel recalls what happened at Witney. When she looked into the dark entrance to the underpass, she remembered being injured inside of it. Rachel also remembers a man from the train with reddish hair being nice to her. Cathy calls again, telling Rachel that the police are at the apartment looking for her.
On the morning of July 17, Rachel recalls how she lied to the police. She does not remember what happened on the night of July 13 and thinks about alcohol blackouts. Tom gave her a book with examples of people doing horrible things while blacked out, and Rachel wonders what she is capable of doing while blacked out. A policeman, Detective Inspector Gaskill, interviews her about being in Witney the night Megan disappeared. Anna reported Rachel was near Megan’s house that night. Rachel claims that she planned to visit Tom, changed her mind, and walked around the neighborhood, arriving home after 8pm. She also lies about still having her job in public relations at Huntingdon Whitely. Rachel plans to tell the police the truth.
That evening, she recalls her visit to the police station. Gaskill interviews her with a policewoman, Detective Sergeant Riley, who Rachel does not like. She admits she lied about her job because she has been lying to Cathy about it and taking the train every day to hide her unemployment. Riley explains that Anna reported Rachel took Tom and Anna’s baby. Rachel gets upset, and Gaskill suggests she have lunch and come back. Rachel buys a sandwich and goes to the park, where she thinks about how she was unable to conceive with Tom and how her infertility led to her becoming a drunk. When she returns to the police station, Rachel explains she only held the baby to stop it from crying. Riley mentions Rachel took the baby outside, toward the train tracks, and suggests that Rachel might have hurt Megan thinking that she was Anna. Rachel denies this and tells them she saw Megan having an affair from the train. Gaskill tells Rachel to stay away from Tom and his new family, and dismisses her. Rachel doesn’t want to drink.
On the morning of July 18, Rachel reads newspapers on the train to learn about Megan and Scott. She sees police in their yard as she passes on the train and wonders if they have found anything. At the library, she sends Scott an email saying she has some information about Megan. On her train ride that evening, Rachel hears news that the police are questioning a 34-year-old man, which she assumes is Scott, and feels like she won’t be able to talk to him about Megan’s affair. She is wet from the rain and has been addiction-free for three days in a row, which is a recent record for her. Rachel sees the red-haired man from the night of Megan’s disappearance and wants to talk to him, but she can’t bring herself to approach him on the train.
This chapter covers two days, March 7 and 8, in 2013. On the afternoon of March 7, Megan describes pillow talk about running away to beach towns with her lover in the Swan hotel room. It is later revealed that the lover is Tom, and he is talking about Rachel to Megan. He leaves the room after Megan falls asleep.
On the morning of March 8, Scott asks Megan how therapy is going and if she wants to continue. She says it’s helping and she wants to keep going. As he gets ready for work, she has mixed feelings about her affair.
This chapter covers July 19 and 20, in morning and evening sections. On the morning of July 19, Gaskill calls Rachel and asks her to come in to look at some pictures. While taking the train to the police station, Rachel thinks about the lists she made, including possibly contacting Scott again and/or trying hypnosis to recover her lost memories. Cathy is excited about Rachel’s few days of sobriety and goes to spend the weekend with her boyfriend. That evening, Rachel drinks and thinks about how she identified the man she saw Megan kissing in the police photos. She also saw Scott in the station and likes Gaskill.
The following morning, Rachel wakes up and tries to remember what she did while drunk. She sees on her laptop that she sent Tom an unkind email about Anna talking to the police about her. Rachel, mortified, thinks about when she took the baby out into Tom and Anna’s yard, and how Tom threatened her afterwards. Resisting the urge to drink, Rachel finds an email from Scott—a reply to a second email she sent while drunk. Rachel calls Scott back, and he asks her to come to the house. On the train to see him, she thinks about Megan.
This chapter looks at July 20 from Anna’s perspective. It’s her birthday, and Tom brings her breakfast in bed, as well as presents. Tom tells her that Rachel sent an email, around the time Rachel realizes she sent one. Anna sometimes wants to harm Rachel, and Anna believes she saved Tom from Rachel during their affair. While Tom bathes the baby, Anna sees Rachel walking to Scott’s house, number 15.
This chapter covers July 21 and 22, and the latter day only has a morning section. On July 21, Rachel thinks about her conversation with Scott the night before. Rachel lied about knowing Megan from the gallery but truthfully told Scott that she saw Megan kissing another man from the train. Rachel found Scott physically intimidating as she identified Megan’s therapist—Kamal—as the man she kissed.
That evening, Rachel notes that the papers have stopped reporting on Megan’s week-old disappearance. She reflects on Cathy taking her out to lunch and offering to help her become addiction-free. After Cathy goes to see her boyfriend, Rachel gets a phone call from Scott. Scott thanks her and talks about his argument with Megan the night she disappeared. He confesses he feels guilty about going to the bar instead of going after Megan, and looking for her at Tara’s place the next day.
On the morning of July 22, Rachel can’t get the news to load on her phone on the train. She sees a headline about Megan on the tablet being used by the man next to her, and he lets her borrow it so she can read the story. It says a 30-something man was arrested. Rachel gets off the train at Witney and runs to Scott’s house. She hesitates at the door, but Scott opens it and pulls her inside.
On the morning of March 21, Megan is upset about not hearing from her lover (who is later revealed as Tom). She considers calling him at home instead of just on his cell. Scott asks her to cancel her therapy session to have dinner with some friends instead. Megan refuses, despite Scott’s threatening tone and touch. She throws a coffee cup at the wall after he leaves.
That evening, Megan goes to therapy. She tries to embrace Kamal, and he says her attraction is transference. He says it has gone too far already between them. She screams at him. He holds her arms back (leaving bruises), and she kisses him, biting his lip, and he pushes her away.
Picking up in the evening of July 22, Scott pulls Rachel inside but lets her arm go quickly, and he explains there have been journalists and photographers. Rachel asks if they arrested Kamal, and Scott confirms this. Rachel then meets Scott’s mother, who escorts her to and out the door. On the street, Rachel sees Tom and Anna with the baby in a buggy.
This chapter covers the events of July 22 from Anna’s perspective. Tom takes Anna and the baby to the cafe where Anna and Tom met during their affair. On their way, they see Rachel leaving number 15, who smiles and walks away. Later that day, they hear that Megan’s therapist was arrested. Anna suggests they tell the police that Rachel was in the neighborhood the night of Megan’s disappearance, but Tom does not want to get the police involved.
In this section, Anna is not only introduced as a point-of-view character, but one who is in sync with Rachel. While Megan’s chapters only reach into March of 2013, Rachel and Anna’s chapters look at the same days in July, after Megan’s death. Showing the same set of events from different perspectives, such as in Chapter 9 and Chapter 10, is referred to as a Rashomon effect. The 1950 film Rashomon by Akira Kurosawa is a crime thriller that offers different perspectives of the same events. The Girl on the Train uses elements from this classic film to build up the concept of Rachel as an unreliable narrator.
Rachel’s unreliability and instability make her seem suspicious, or at least unhelpful. In Chapter 7, the police believe Rachel is “mentally unstable” (73), and when Anna has her first point-of-view chapter, Chapter 10, she refers to Rachel as “highly unstable” (109). Both Anna and the police are not only swayed by Rachel’s alcohol use disorder, but also by Tom’s lies about Rachel. Rachel’s alcohol use disorder is a vulnerability that Tom exploits—initially to make himself look better to other sexual partners, but later to cast suspicion on her in the case of Megan’s murder. Tom, as the murderer, benefits from Anna talking to the police while believing Tom’s lies.
While the police find Rachel, at best, unhelpful, Rachel longs to live a life of usefulness. Like Hawkins switching point-of-view narrators, Rachel can’t resist the urge to change her perspective. She will lie to go into number 15, to approach the house she’s “observed a hundred times from the trackside, from the street” (107). Rachel claims to have known Megan from her gallery to see Scott and tell him about Megan’s affair. Due to Tom’s abuse and her alcohol use disorder, Rachel is deeply lonely. She initially wants to connect with the male detective on the case, Gaskill. When the police dismiss her as useless, she hopes to “be of use” (123) to Scott.
Another structural change is shifting between point-of-view characters between morning and evening sections. Rachel’s chapters include both morning and evening sections, a consistent structure, until Chapter 11. The events of that evening are not revealed until Chapter 13 to heighten tension. Chapter 12 interjects Megan’s perspective as Rachel is pulled into number 15 by Megan’s husband, Scott, at the end of Chapter 11. Hawkins changing the structure offers a new kind of cliffhanger—it breaks the established pattern in a way the reader hasn’t seen in previous chapters.
Megan’s past has holes in it, which can be compared to the holes in Rachel’s memory. After pillow talk with Tom, Megan thinks, “That’s what I’ve taken from the therapy sessions: the holes in your life are permanent. You have to grow around them, like tree roots around concrete; you mold yourself through the gaps” (94). Megan’s holes are deaths she has experienced, or the trauma surrounding the untimely deaths of her brother and her baby. Rachel, Tom mentions late in the novel, ended up with him after the death of her father. Rachel’s grief, although different than Megan’s, left both of them susceptible to his lies. However, Megan’s journey with memory is being willing to tell Kamal about her trauma, while Rachel’s journey involves regaining her lost memories.
By Paula Hawkins
Addiction
View Collection
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Books Made into Movies
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Fear
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
Hate & Anger
View Collection
Marriage
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Psychological Fiction
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
The Past
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection