53 pages • 1 hour read
Esmé Weijun WangA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Index of Terms
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Further Reading & Resources
Content Warning: This section contains discussions of suicide.
Wang opens this essay with a paragraph she wrote during a psychotic episode referred to as Cotard’s delusion, “in which the patient believes they are dead” (145). Despite thinking she is dead, she knows that because she thinks, she must exist.
In 2013, Wang began training to perform talks aimed at destigmatizing mental illness. Before this, she experienced her longest psychotic episode, which was signaled by weeks of scattered thinking and behavior. During this period, she accomplished many minor tasks in an attempt to “assemble the parts of [her] mind which had begun to fall apart” (146).
Cotard’s delusion is a rare disorder that is theorized to be related to Capgras delusion, or the lack of emotion toward loved ones’ faces that leads to a belief that they have been replaced. Wang refers to an episode of Hannibal, which features Cotard’s delusion in a crass manner and results in a woman killing people in horrible ways. She remarks on the irony of the feeling and how joyous it made her to think she was getting a chance to start over with a new life.
It was also during this time that Wang’s doctor implied that they had tried every relatively safe medication, and it was time for her to accept her diagnosis and live with it. She began to wonder if she was going to fully succumb to the disorder and never come out of it again, and thus, she wondered whether her “self” would still exist. She refers to this as a perdition period, largely inspired by Home by Marilynne Robinson and the concept of losing one’s chance at happiness forever.
Wang sold many of her possessions, thinking that none of it mattered anyway. She dressed up and focused on her weight and appearance in an effort to remind herself, “You have a body” (157). One night, Wang asks C to describe her life, her personality, and the world to her. It helps somewhat but does not diminish the delusion that she is dead. She ends the essay by explaining that when perdition ends and she no longer feels like she is dead, it is not a moment of celebration, as it only returns her to the other problems she faces.
Wang deeply admires photographer Francesca Woodman, who died by suicide at age 22. Wang went to see her work when she was 28 during a particularly dark period of her life. She sees Francesca as having been “cannily ambitious and fully aware of her own gifts” (162).
In a series of self-portraits, Francesca’s photographs show her as a dark, pale part of the scenery in various parts of a house. Francesca is said to have ended her life due to a lack of recognition for her work, and Wang relates to the sentiment, reflecting on how she has always relied on external recognition for validation.
Francesca’s ambition to make herself into art is also part of Wang’s inspiration for writing essays featuring her own thoughts and experiences. Wang also takes Polaroid photos of herself in an attempt to connect with the outside world and express what she is feeling. Wang considers the way Francesca will be immortalized forever through her art and how she did not have to experience the slow dissipation of her life, self, and everything she loved. Conversely, Wang feels that her life’s limitations are only increasing.
Wang’s essays, “Perdition Days” and “L’Appel du Vide” share a death motif. These are the darkest of Wang’s essays, as the first one features her experiences with Cotard’s delusion and being convinced she was already dead and the second discusses Wang’s admiration for photographer Francesca Woodman, who died by suicide. In the first essay, Wang describes feeling as if she were already dead and makes a dark joke: “I was crying with joy. ‘I’m dead’” (148). In the second, she describes how she feels like she is slowly fading away and confesses feeling jealous of Francesca’s immortality and young death. She feels that Francesca is immortalized through her art and did not have to slowly watch her life slip away. Because of Wang’s mental illness and various physical ailments, she sees herself as a burning candle and wonders if she will also be immortalized. She admits that part of her fear is rooted in her need for external validation, which Francesca shared; Francesca supposedly ended her life due to a lack of recognition, and Wang regularly confesses her need for such validation (for instance, when she changed her manner of speech during her talks at the Chinatown clinic). When Wang was told that she would never recover from her disorder, she again wondered about a separate self aside from the disorder and whether it would be preserved:
The question instead became about percentages. What percentage of my life was going to be spent in psychosis? What percentage of functioning I could expect […] What percentage of insight I could expect. No one could, or can, answer these questions, of course (150).
Due to her Hope in the Face of Great Challenges, Wang persists despite this supposedly doomed diagnosis and focuses on her writing, drawing inspiration from Francesca’s drive to create art in the darkness.
Wang’s essays on death are scattered, like her symptoms of psychosis, jumping back and forth through time and between points. These disparate points are woven together through the idea of perdition, which Wang uses to describe her status as someone with a permanent mental disorder. Wang’s feelings of being dead are also symbolic, representing her belief that her life will slowly deteriorate into nothing. Inspired by Francesca Woodman’s photographs, which often symbolize her isolation and darkness, Wang took Polaroids of herself during psychosis. These photos are usually blurred as if Wang is not fully able to see herself. They show approximations of emotions—a shadow of her true self. When she looks back on these photos, she interprets them with a new perspective: “The well person has the job of translating the images that the sick person has left behind as evidence” (166). Wang’s essays on death rely primarily on pathos to access the reader’s emotions. She describes in potent detail how she feels while believing she is dead, the way she acts, and the distant self-perception that occurred in that state of mind. Wang’s Cotard’s delusion lasted for several months and remains an experience that shaped who she is, illustrating The Interweaving of Mental Illness With Identity.
Asian American & Pacific Islander...
View Collection
Disability
View Collection
Essays & Speeches
View Collection
Health & Medicine
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Mental Illness
View Collection
Psychology
View Collection
Science & Nature
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection