60 pages • 2 hours read
Mikki BrammerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Clover travels to a Harlem death café, where she once again meets Sebastian. He strikes up a conversation with Clover and defends his presence at the café, explaining that his concern about his grandmother’s death is real. Clover finally reveals that she works as a death doula and is not keen on discussing her job. Sebastian complains about his family’s reluctance to talk about his dying grandmother. Clover then makes a hasty exit, unsure how to address the situation and her lie regarding her grandmother’s death.
Clover reminisces about her grandfather, whose death still casts a shadow over her life. In fact, the chapter reveals that she was diagnosed with persistent complex bereavement disorder, which she calls “chronic grief,” because she had failed to move on eight months after her grandfather’s death. However, Clover defends her process of grieving, arguing that everyone grieves differently and there is no set timeline for an end to grief. Thus, she maintains the weekly tradition of dining at their favorite diner and visiting the bookstore, as she did when her grandfather was alive. At the bookstore, she observes two men sharing a special connection while browsing books, highlighting her own longing for intimacy. She recalls a client’s advice about changing her perfume to mark new life chapters. Unexpectedly, Sebastian calls her seeking her help as a death doula for his grandmother. Despite initial reluctance, Clover agrees, beginning a new chapter in her life.
In a flashback to her ninth birthday, Clover receives a thoughtful gift from her grandfather: a navy blue leather-bound notebook, a silver fountain pen, and a pair of binoculars. Her grandfather emphasizes the importance of curiosity and keen observation. He takes Clover on a birthday outing to Central Park to teach her about the lamppost numbering system and the art of birdwatching. He also advises her about observing people’s behaviors and identifying their patterns. Clover learns that each person is unique, and understanding their individual patterns can help her be of service to others.
When meeting Clover, Leo teases her about her self-imposed isolation, as she hasn’t left her house or interacted with others in a week. However, Clover values her own self-sufficiency and expresses her reluctance to open up to others. Leo, who is a widower, shares his perspective on the value of love and human connection, highlighting the importance of letting people see the real you.
Clover grapples with a yearning for companionship while using her binoculars to observe a couple, Julia and Reuben, who live in the neighboring building. This voyeuristic activity provides her with material for her romantic fantasies, as well as a semblance of intimacy and connection without actual interaction.
Clover’s solitary life evolved over time. Her fascination with death was an important factor—for example, her classmates often exhibited judgmental attitudes toward her. Clover recalls a brief attempt to befriend a girl named Priya in high school, who ultimately rejected Clover because Priya wanted to fit in with the other classmates.
After a painting class meant to honor an elderly woman’s unfulfilled artistic dream, Clover tries to avoid Sylvie, her new neighbor, but eventually agrees to have coffee with her. During the conversation, Sylvie learns about Clover’s work and becomes intrigued. As the two chat, Clover starts to open up, sharing personal experiences, including the loss of her grandfather, one of the factors that led her to become a death doula. Sylvie’s warmth and genuine curiosity prompt Clover to consider the possibility of forming a new friendship, sparking a sense of hope and connection in her life.
Clover meets Sebastian, and the two go to a beautiful townhouse where Clover meets Claudia, Sebastian’s grandmother. Sebastian admits that his grandmother believes Clover is an art enthusiast rather than a death doula, because he could not tell his grandmother about her diagnosis. In the garden, Claudia greets them warmly. Concealing her anxiety over the lie, Clover discusses Claudia’s unconventional career as a female photojournalist in the 1950s. Claudia acknowledges that women’s rights have a long way to go, although things are better than in her day.
Claudia naps in the sunshine as Clover returns to the townhouse, left alone by Sebastian to tend to his grandmother. The decor is sparing, reminiscent of the preserved celebrity homes that Clover has seen on her travels. Sebastian brings his cello to play for Claudia, sharing a warm moment with her. Sebastian offers to drop off Clover at Washington Square Park. In an Uber, they discuss Claudia’s family dynamics, her health aides, and Sebastian’s hope that Clover can ease Claudia’s emotional burden at the end of her life. Clover reveals her own past, and Sebastian is apologetic for asking. He pleads with Clover to continue visiting Claudia. Clover agrees to give it two weeks.
After being dropped off at Washington Square, Clover indulges in a tradition she shared with her late grandfather—watching dogs at the park. She then stops by a pharmacy, where she encounters Leo, and they decide to have a meal at the nearby diner. Leo shares neighborhood gossip, including the mysterious case of a bodega cat that went missing. A cat that looks identical appeared in its stead, the only difference being that it was a male cat. Leo speculates that it was the doing of a cat-breeding ring. As they walk back home, a sudden rain shower begins. While seeking shelter, Leo, who typically walks at a slower pace, encourages Clover to embrace the moment and enjoy the rainfall. They stand together, savoring the experience.
Sylvie invites Clover to join her for yoga, and despite initial hesitation, Clover decides to give it a try. They prepare for their early morning class, with Sylvie providing some pointers. During the class, they both struggle to maintain focus, especially during guided meditation, where they’re on the verge of laughter when the instructor pronounces the word “cocoon.” The session ends with Sylvie’s proposal to continue their yoga outings at another time. As they part ways, Clover reflects on how the experience marks a positive shift in her life, embracing newfound friendships outside of work.
In a flashback to Clover’s 20th birthday, she works as a volunteer at a nursing home in Antigua, Guatemala, which she has been doing between college semesters. She reflects on her interactions with the elderly residents, including Arturo, a poet, and Rosita, who exudes joy. Clover’s feelings for Tim, another volunteer, grow stronger, and she plans to reveal her emotions to him on her birthday. Tim has been asking Clover to cover for his shifts and other such favors, which she mistakes for affection. However, she discovers Tim with Felicity, another volunteer, during an intimate moment, which leaves Clover heartbroken.
In these chapters, Clover’s life is marked by solitude and introspection, but as the narrative progresses, she gradually starts her journey toward forming meaningful relationships.
Sebastian becomes more central in these chapters. His family’s reluctance to discuss his dying grandmother mirrors Clover’s own avoidance of emotional conversations, highlighting the parallels between the characters. Sebastian’s decision to reach out to Clover for assistance as a death doula and her subsequent acceptance initiate a significant shift in Clover’s life as she risks opening herself to new relationships. The contrast between Sebastian’s openness and Clover’s reluctance when it comes to relationships mirror Clover’s openness and Sebastian’s reluctance when it comes to death. Clover and Sebastian, while not compatible as romantic partners, are complementary characters: Each teaches the other an important lesson. Clover teaches Sebastian that death is a part of life and that it is not shameful to acknowledge one’s emotions when faced with the death of a beloved person. Sebastian teaches Clover that taking risks and creating chaos in one’s life sometimes leads to worthwhile encounters.
Clover’s loss of her grandfather highlights the recurring theme of The Complexity of Loss and Grief, casting a shadow over her habits and relationships. The emotional vulnerability she experiences emphasizes the human need for connection and the consequences of emotional detachment. These chapters delve deeper into Clover’s relationship with her grandfather. Her Sunday traditions, which include dining at the diner she used to go to with her grandfather and visiting the bookstore owned by a mutual friend called Bessie, serve as a means of preserving the memory of her grandfather.
Clover’s grandfather’s birthday presents to her—a navy-blue leather-bound notebook, a silver fountain pen, and a pair of binoculars—carry symbolic weight. They symbolize the grandfather’s role in shaping Clover’s identity, as he emphasized the importance of curiosity and keen observation. Clover maintains the habit of noting patterns and valuable insights. She keeps three notebooks, entitled “REGRETS,” “ADVICE,” and “CONFESSIONS,” in which she writes down what her clients tell her at the end of their lives. She finds that their words always fall within one of these categories. This also connects Clover’s current preoccupations with her early curiosity about one’s last words, expressed in the first chapter, when young Clover witnesses the death of Mr. Hyland. This represents the continuity of Clover’s preoccupation with death but also the fact that observation is a natural impulse. In Clover’s case, observation is directed at everything that surrounds death, which isolates her from her peers in school. At the same time, this habit makes her an invaluable member of the community because she can support those who are at the ends of their lives with care and compassion. Finally, Clover’s observation manifests itself as a voyeuristic habit of watching a couple through binoculars from her window. This habit serves as a coping mechanism for her solitude.
Along with Sebastian, Clover’s budding relationship with Sylvie, her new neighbor, represents a turning point in Clover’s relationships and emphasizes the transformative power of interpersonal connections. Sylvie’s warmth and genuine curiosity break through Clover’s emotional barriers, inspiring her to consider forming a new friendship. Sylvie’s invitation to yoga and the ensuing experience mark a positive shift in Clover’s life, marking her gradual embrace of friendships outside her profession. Their friendship also speaks to the variety of human experience and contradicts the pattern that informed Clover’s experiences up to this point. The friendship also challenges the lens through which Clover observes the world. While the world and society do follow patterns, as Clover’s grandfather taught her, this does not exclude diversity and chance encounters. Although Clover’s past relationships were hurtful, Sylvie proves to be the opposite of all those people: compassionate, genuinely interested in Clover’s profession, and patient with Clover’s need to approach a friendship slowly. The friendship between the two women challenges societal stereotypes, which cast such sincere relationships as impossible due to the underlying pressures of society and the competitive spirit. Due to this, Brammer’s choice to depict a friendship between women of the same age based on mutual respect and encouragement speaks to the author’s feminist standpoint.
Chapter 22 takes readers back to Clover’s time in Antigua, Guatemala, where her unrequited love for Tim unfolds, as well as Clover’s disappointment with her friend Felicity. This episode provides the background for Clover’s vulnerability and emotional complexity. In addition, it puts into perspective Clover’s reluctance to consider Sebastian as a possible romantic partner.