90 pages • 3 hours read
Mary E. PearsonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
On their way back from the mission, Ethan and Jenna pick up Allys at her community project, which is at a medical center. Allys volunteers at the same hospital where she receives physical therapy. Allys explains to Jenna why she blames earlier, unethical medical practices and the overuse of antibiotics for the loss of her limbs and declares her support for the Federal Science Ethics Board (FSEB), the organization that now monitors and regulates medical treatments. Under this new system, medical procedures are assigned a point value system, and each person only a certain number of points. Once they have used up these points, they are denied further medical care. She mentions Bio Gel, which Jenna recognizes as her father’s invention; Bio Gel makes it possible to recreate organs using neurochips, but each organ costs many points and Bio Gel brains are illegal. Ethan is annoyed by Allys’ unfailing support of the FSEB, noting that such “intelligent and qualified people” (96) ruined his life years earlier. As Jenna waits for Ethan to finish conferencing with their teacher, she is approached by Dane. He knows Ethan has warned Jenna to stay away from him, but maintains that his only flaw is honesty, while Ethan can’t accept the truth. He asks to be friends, and Jenna hesitantly accepts. The next morning, Jenna sits in her room as more and more childhood memories come back to her. She decides to explore the house and discovers a hidden, locked closet in her parents’ bedroom. She finds the key under her parents’ bed, but before she can unlock the closet, she is interrupted by Lily, who tells her that Ethan is outside. Jenna and Ethan go for a walk, where he reveals that he spent a year in juvenile hall for severely beating a man. Moved by his honesty and feeling that he understands her in a way others can’t, Jenna kisses him.
Jenna and Lily fight about whether Jenna should have kissed Ethan, with Lily arguing that it’s “not right” (107), but refusing to explain why. Jenna watches the last home movie. It is of her last ballet recital before the accident. In the video, “old” Jenna argues with her mother about her choice of makeup and announces that this is her final dance recital. Mother objects, claiming that Jenna loves to dance, but Jenna replies that she is five foot nine, not five-seven like Mother, the perfect height for a ballerina. In the present, Jenna feels guilty for how badly she treated Mother, and resolves to be kinder. But, at the first opportunity, Jenna sneaks into the hidden closet. There, she discovers three computers. Once has her name on it. She tries to pull it off its table, but cuts her hand open on one of the metal brackets; she is horrified to find that underneath her skin is a thick layer of blue Bio Gel. She hysterically confronts Mother, who explains that not only Jenna’s hand, but her whole body, was horribly burned in the accident and had to be replaced. Jenna notices, for the first time, that she and Mother are the same height. She is two inches shorter than she used to be. Jenna has been artificially re-constructed using Bio Gel. “How much is me?” (117), Jenna asks Mother. Lily reveals that only ten percent of Jenna’s brain could be saved, nothing more. Mother fiercely maintains that it was the “most important ten percent” (117). As Jenna lies in bed, agitated and confused, Mother explains that after the accident, Jenna was dying, despite the doctors’ best efforts. Mother and Father chose to save her illegally, using Bio Gel and secretly transported her to a private facility, then to California.
During the night, Jenna remembers Lily sprinkling her with holy water when she was in a coma and telling her to let go. Father arrives home the next morning. He does his best to explain to Jenna the details of her situation. With the exception of some of her skin and the ten percent of her brain they saved, Jenna is artificial, but identical to the person she was before the accident. He was able to recreate her body down to the last freckle using all the home movies. Her skeletal structure was replicated and her brain infused with additional Bio Gel and then her scanned brain was uploaded to her new body. Jenna realizes that her memories of being in suffocating darkness, wanting to die but unable to, are from when her uploaded brain was outside a body.
Though Father thinks this is an amazing scientific breakthrough, Jenna is horrified. She realizes that just by existing, she is highly illegal, and that is why her family moved to California. Father reveals that as well as having to hide, her Bio Gel has a shelf life and could be compromised by the cold, making California more suitable than Boston. At the mention of a shelf life, Jenna explodes with anger. Father maintains that they did what any parent would do. Jenna proclaims herself a freak, causing Mother to nearly slap her. Jenna asks her father where he put her soul in this new body. He can’t answer. The next day, Jenna goes for walk, still trying to make sense of what she’s learned. She wonders if she is actually human. She and Lily talk, and Lily says that, unlike Jenna’s parents, she thinks there are things worse than death. That night, Jenna asks her parents why they didn’t tell her the truth when she awoke from the coma. Mother tries to explain to Jenna how painful watching your child die is, and reminds Jenna that she is not the only one who suffered. Father and Mother beg Jenna not to tell anyone what she knows—for all their sakes.
The overarching theme of this section is “choice.” Though Jenna is introduced in the novel as a helpless, passive participant in her parents’ dubious moral decisions, she now has the capacity to make her own choices, as well as evaluate the choices of others. After she and Ethan pick up Allys from her volunteer project at the medical center, the conversation turns towards medical research and practices and the FSEB, who regulates and controls every physician, hospital, and research facility. Allys, who blames an overuse of antibiotics for the loss of her limbs, supports the FSEB and the checks and balances they place on individual choices. “‘Just because we can doesn’t mean me should’” (95), she maintains (95). The points system, while it takes away doctors’ and patients’ choices, also creates a level of fairness. Jenna doesn’t yet know the truth about her own medical history, but still sees this approach as “simplistic” (95). Ethan is similarly conflicted--while Allys is able to put her trust in “‘intelligent and qualified people’” (96) to make decisions for her and take away the burden of choice, Ethan’s own life experiences has taught him not to put such faith in others.
Witnessing this argument about individual freedom affects Jenna, who decides to fully explore her house for the first time. “It only just now strikes me as odd that I have been like a houseguest...never feeling free to roam the rest of the house” (100), she says. Her desire for freedom wins out over trusting her parents and results in her finding the locked closet and its key, which will eventually lead to her most important discoveries. Before she can unlock the door, she is interrupted by Ethan’s visit, at which point she must make another choice: stay with him, or return to the locked closet. “I choose Ethan for now” (103), Jenna says, and the implications of her choice are clear. When forced to, she will choose interpersonal relationships and emotional growth over mystery and the potentially gritty truth. Ethan reveals his dark past, but Jenna is undisturbed by what he’s done, acknowledging that “sometimes there is just no choice” (105).
When Jenna does eventually discover the truth of her existence, her parents’ explanation hinges on a similar lack of choice: “‘Any parent in the world would have made the choice we did’” (118), her mother insists, implying that by virtue of their relationship with Jenna, Mother and Father were incapable of making a different choice. Unlike Ethan, Jenna refuses to let her parents off the hook so easily, raging internally about her father’s decision to put her in an “endless vacuum” (128) and asking, “How could you do this to me?” (128). Jenna believes, despite everything that her parents have said, that they did have a choice, and that they made the wrong one.
In the wake of her discovery, Jenna’s use of dictionary definitions to understand her world begins to unravel. She looks up the word “human,” but remains confused. “How many definitions for human can one person find?” she asks. “And how do you know which one is correct?” (134). While the dictionary once gave Jenna a concrete foundation, her discovery has forced her to see the world not in terms of black and white definitions, but in shades of grey.
This section also illuminates Jenna’s relationship with honesty and the idea of the “truth.” While talking to Lily, she finds she can “accept [Lily’s] bluntness easier than lying” (132). She is conflicted by her budding friendship with Dane because while she is disturbed by the “emptiness” (98) in his face, she also appreciates his self-described honest nature and the fact that he was the first to tell her that she walked funny, when no one else would. When Jenna discovers the Bio Gel under her skin, her first question to Mother is: “‘When were you going to tell me!’” (115). She confronts her mother for lying before she asks what is under her skin. In Jenna’s mind, the most significant discovery is that her parents lied, not that they altered her body.
By Mary E. Pearson