65 pages • 2 hours read
Winona Guo, Priya VulchiA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Chapter 1’s introduction describes the authors’ interaction with Alfred and Darlene at the Alaska Native Heritage Center. After Vulchi exclaims that “it’s crazy that [this place] is part of America,” Alfred replies that, “This place is more American than any other part of America. We are more American than any other American. We were here first” (12). He also educates another visitor about the derogatory term “Eskimo.” The authors then explains how race and racism impact all areas of life: “From our televisions to our artwork to our health care, race is a cancer that impacts every part of our lives. It often determines anything from where we live, to whom we know, to how we walk through the world” (13). The authors stress the need for awareness of race’s widespread impact if change is to occur.
Chapter 1 then details the stories of 16 people. Jennifer L. describes her family’s racism toward Black people—racism that she adopted. However, she soon saw her own privilege as an Asian American person—a member of the so-called “model minority”—with light skin. She argues that white people should be less self-centered and instead ask questions like “‘how can I support you?” and “what do you need from me?” (17). Footnotes explain the model minority myth, the definitions of “stereotype” and “ally,” and the median household income for Asian Americans.
Alexa, an undocumented immigrant from Mexico, details her school experiences as a light-skinned Latina and the bullying by classmates who called her “white.” After moving to a predominantly white school, she felt trapped between being too Latina for school and too white for her family. She notes how gender intersects with race, as Latina women earn even less than white women when compared to white men, and she stresses the additional difficulties that come with being undocumented. Footnotes explain code-switching and the legal education rights of undocumented immigrants.
Education can also impact racism at home, as experienced by Justin, a Latino from a low-income immigrant family. He experiences light-skinned privilege in his neighborhood while having to code-switch between his white school culture (where he experienced racism) and his home culture, where his family sometimes views him as white because of his school experience and English skills.
Queen Esther explains how race impacts perceptions of music; people are surprised that she is a Black country singer. She explains that American musical genres comes from African music: “[H]olding a banjo and singing country music was not me straying from my Blackness, but me reclaiming it” (23-24). She describes other inventions by Black people and how Black people built America. She also discusses the creation of whiteness and Blackness as a constructed dichotomy that erased enslaved people’s understanding of their own histories. Footnotes address Black women’s bodies, their rights, and slavery, as well as changes in Texas history textbooks that ignore slavery and racism.
Justin E., a Black cultural anthropologist, addresses the difference between the framing of slavery in Senegal versus the US: In Senegal, slavery is conceptualized as something in the past, whereas Black people in America are conceptualized solely in terms of their history of enslavement. He argues that white people should teach each other about racism; people of color should not bear the entire responsibility. Footnotes explain the difference between saying “Africa” and specifying a geographical location on the continent and discuss Joy DeGruy’s idea of “Post Traumatic Slave Syndrome,” which describes slavery’s impact on current generations.
Nick, a member of the Oglala Lakota Nation, has an Indigenous American mother and a Jewish father; his story considers the intersection of these two identities and its effects on his resistance and service. He discusses the impact of race on poverty, focusing on Indigenous communities, and emphasizes how the struggle for equity permeates all communities of color. Footnotes accompanying his interview describe US treaties with Indigenous nations and define racial equity.
Vic, an Asian woman, addresses the impact of race on interracial relations—namely, how Asian people attempt to create change by “being respectable” in the eyes of white people. She argues that true change occurs through community organizing. Footnotes explain the term “positionality,” Chinese communities now called “Chinatowns,” and how the first US immigration law banned women traveling from China; its purpose was to limit Chinese American infants and families from gaining citizenship, retaining Chinese Americans as laborers only.
Melina recognized her color-blindness in college and journeyed toward teaching other white people about racism. She emphasizes long-standing systems of power created by a combination of patriarchy, capitalism, and white supremacy and considers whether these systems should be challenged jointly. She also addresses the need to address white privilege and behavior that stems from white supremacy, noting that white people bear this responsibility. Footnotes explain Janet E. Helms’s “Model of White Racial Identity Development” and define white privilege.
Race and culture interact for Rylee, Marley, and Parker, who discuss the impact of race on them as Hawaiians and the ideas of cultural appropriation and reparations (addressed in the footnotes). Liz addresses the effects of race and culture when traveling as a Nigerian American person; she felt more racism in Europe and Australia and more comfortable in East and South Africa. The footnote provides a quote by W. E. B. Du Bois on how Black people experience “double consciousness,” or constantly viewing oneself from the dominant perspective.
Race impacts vocation, as Ed and Chef Tu demonstrate. As an African American meteorologist, Ed has helped communities of color deal with and prepare for weather disasters, and he illustrates the impact of race in this arena. Chef Tu, who is part Vietnamese, explains the influence of race on food, which connects cultures and also defines them. Footnotes cover emancipation, the number of African American meteorologists, the number of ethnic groups in Vietnam, and the number of Vietnamese refugees during the Vietnam War.
Vineela and Tyler G, an interracial couple, share how race influences dating through discussion of their experiences; Vineela’s mother was hesitant about Tyler, who is white. A footnote explains the benefits of sharing stories about identity, culture, and race
The introduction to this chapter describes the authors’ travels in Mississippi, which has the most African Americans, the lowest education rate, and the poorest population in the US. The authors visit Cleveland Central High School, which integrated in 2017, and they provide statistics on school desegregation, including how 180 districts in the US had ongoing desegregation cases in 2015. Arguing that racism is not relegated to the past in Mississippi, they note that the number of police killings of Black people in the present day surpasses the number of lynchings in the past. The 11 interviewees address how the past impacts the present in their lives, towns, and families. Susan is the mother of Heather Heyer, a counterprotestor who was killed when a person drove into her group at the 2017 white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia. Heather’s family could not afford her funeral, so her friends started a GoFundMe campaign and raised $220,000, which her mother used to start the Heather Heyer Foundation to teach other white people about race, a topic she considered only after her daughter’s death. She describes learning about white privilege when Heather’s boyfriend described being followed when shopping because he is Black; she finally understood the difference between her struggles as a poor white woman and those of Black people. A footnote explains white flight.
Other interviewees, such as Ashley, Lisa, Juanenna, and Jackie, discuss the discrimination they face as African Americans and their diverse perspectives on racism. Ashley, a lawyer and first-generation college graduate, argues that race permeates society, and Juanenna describes how sundown towns (white towns that people of color should leave before sunset) still exist in Arkansas. Konnor and Aaron discuss the integration of Cleveland and East Side High Schools in Cleveland, Mississippi, compared to integration in other areas of their town. Konnor shares how he avoids interracial relationships. Lisa relates a story about visiting her grandfather, a sharecropper, and being told to use the back door of his landowner’s house. Jackie describes the problematic aspects of passing, which she and other family members have engaged in, including its effects on younger family members who did not realize they were Black. Footnotes discuss the terms “Cajun” and “Creole,” the historical concept of “one drop” of Black blood making a person Black, passing, the Three-fifths Compromise, statistics involving race and murder, the Confederate flag, current Ku Klux Klan (KKK) numbers, the definitions of desegregation and sharecropper, and stereotypes.
White interviewees share stories of the past, such as the story of the 1916 lynching of Jesse Washington in Waco, Texas. This spurred Jo and others to advocate for a memorial service for him. Archibald, a white man from a wealthy family, acknowledges his privilege but believes there is too much anger surrounding some racial issues, citing violence at colleges during protests against far-right speakers. Footnotes discuss these protests, the problematic term “mentally retarded,” and statistics on lynching.
Autumn, an Indigenous American, explains how US history teaches Indigenous American history wrong, while Rhonda, an Iñupiat Athabaskan (Indigenous Alaskan), describes her fight against racist depictions of Indigenous Americans in her daughter’s textbooks. Footnotes explain the 1969-1971 Alcatraz occupation by Indigenous American people, the concept of the Seventh Generation in Indigenous culture, and the problematic definition of “Indian” and its use to erase the diversity of tribes.
These chapters emphasize the broad impact of race and racism. The interviewees’ broad experiences with racism highlight the prevalence of racism as an inescapable ill throughout society—one that persists despite changes to laws and past practices—as well as in individual daily experiences. The implied conclusion is that racism cannot be ignored at the societal or individual level, nor can it be seen as a problem confined to the past. Many of the interviews concern how slavery and segregation still impact the present through inequity and the continuing existence of segregated schools and neighborhoods. Chapter 2 emphasizes how even though contemporary society might seem different, “the cloud of racial inequality hangs over every part of our nation. In many ways the past is still present” (53). The book notes that while many Americans assume that school segregation is a past practice, ongoing desegregation cases challenge that perception. Segregation also exists both from neighborhood to neighborhood and in the South’s sundown towns.
What’s more, the history of racism influences how people interpret the past, as Queen Esther’s interview demonstrates. She explains that America would not exist without the work of Black people, from slavery to inventions: “This country wouldn’t be what it is without my ancestors. This country’s music would not exist. This country in and of itself would not exist […] You owe Black people for everything” (24).
For all these reasons, the authors and interviewees therefore stress that we do not live in a “post-racial” world. The idea that we do results in what Melina calls “color blindness,” or trying to ignore race in one’s dealings with others in a way that ultimately perpetuates racism: “[I]f we stop using racial categories, then we will not be able to identify racial inequity” (Kendi, Ibram X. How to Be an Antiracist. One World, 2019). The authors, like many writers and activists, therefore advocate for “antiracism” instead. Racism exists on a continuum, from microaggressions, to the erasure of racism from textbooks, to white supremacist organizations and rallies, and an antiracist perspective promotes awareness of racism’s insidious nature. They suggest that reading and sharing Stories and Conversations About Race and Identity will help people recognize the continuing problem of racism.
This project must involve those who have benefited most from white supremacy—i.e., white people—so Tell Me Who You Are includes many interviews with white Americans. Chapter 1 emphasizes sharing one’s experiences as a part of one’s identity because life experiences (including racism) impact identity and vice versa. A person who has a racist family, such as Jennifer L., may have difficulty disentangling their family identity from their views of race. The often unconscious positioning of whiteness as the norm contributes to the problem, heightening the sense of in-group belonging. This construction of whiteness has historical roots, and Chapter 2 shows how that history continues to influence current ideas about whiteness. The ongoing occurrence of white supremacy rallies is an extreme example. Susan Heyer’s interview exemplifies how past ideas of race impact the present so strongly that a white supremacist rally was held in Charlottesville in 2017. However, her interview also reflects the positive effects of Acknowledging Systemic Inequalities and Privilege, as becoming aware of her own positionality as a white woman has inspired her to reach out to others about racism.
These chapters also suggest that people of color have varying roles to play in the fight against racism. Racism impacts people differently, including different people of color. For example, people of color with lighter skin tones who can “pass” as white experience a kind of privilege and can perpetuate a form of racism known as colorism (considered further in Chapter 6). However, this privilege also comes with its own challenges—e.g., the erasure of family history, or the sense that one doesn’t belong to any group. Individuals who participate culturally in “whiteness” may feel similarly left out, as Justin’s story demonstrates.
Ultimately, because race impacts all of society, these chapters frame racism as a fight that everyone must take up. Nick explains:
All people of color have a shared history of struggle. I don’t believe in the pure sovereignty of indigenous communities unless it also has an equity lens, just as I don’t believe in the sovereignty of the African-American people or the Asian-American community if it doesn’t have an equity lens […] We have much more to gain when we work together toward a more equitable world (30).
Identities, and the ways in which they interact with systems of oppression, are not only racial—a topic that Chapter 3 addresses.