logo

94 pages 3 hours read

Emily St. John Mandel

Station Eleven

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2014

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.

Part 3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “I Prefer You With a Crown”

Chapter 13 Summary

The narrative shifts to 14 years before the collapse, when Arthur is 36 years old. He and Miranda, who is twelve years his junior, leave a restaurant in Toronto after dinner; a paparazzo takes a picture of them, which will end up in Kirsten’s collection. Miranda promises to leave her boyfriend and accepts Arthur’s offer to stay with him.

A snippet from an interview in which Arthur reveals that Miranda shares his hometown transitions to an account of Arthur’s youth. He grew up on a sparsely populated island off Canada’s west coast, a place Arthur considers “gorgeous and claustrophic,” recognizing that he “always wanted to escape” (74). In his late teens, Arthur leaves for the University of Toronto, where he drops out of school to focus on acting. He takes introductory acting classes, then transfers to a theater school in New York. After graduation, he lands a small TV role and subsequently accepts the director’s invitation to look for more work in Los Angeles. There, his career advances gradually while party after party sours him to a life of “tedious debauchery” (76).

At the age of 29, Arthur is cast in a film to be shot Toronto. While there, he receives a call from his mother, who suggests that Arthur meet Miranda, who moved to Delano Island, where Arthur grew up, after Arthur left. Upon meeting Miranda, who attends art school in Toronto, Arthur is struck by her poise and maturity, considering her “the opposite of the L.A. girls” (77). He appreciates that she understands him in ways that people from big cities do not. Over the next few years, Arthur becomes increasingly famous and goes through several relationships, but he never forgets Miranda. At the age of 36, while making another film in Toronto, he decides to call her.

Chapter 14 Summary

At that time, Miranda is working as an administrative assistant at Neptune Logistics, a shipping company. During her frequent downtime at work, she works on a series of graphic novels titled Dr. Eleven. The series is set 1,000 years in the future: After Earth is captured by an alien civilization, physicist Dr. Eleven and a few hundred others manage to escape on a damaged space station, Station Eleven. Fifteen years after their escape, a segment of the station’s population, who have banded together in a region known as the Undersea, want to return to Earth; Dr. Eleven opposes them.

Miranda secretly enjoys work more than being home with Pablo, her boyfriend of eight years. After falling out with Pablo, who does not understand her passion for Dr. Eleven, Miranda receives Arthur’s call; the two go out to dinner. Miranda spends the next few nights with Arthur at his hotel. The morning after their first night together, she looks in the mirror and thinks, “I repent nothing” (89). She later wonders whether it was “dishonorable” to walk out on Pablo. Arthur counters, “Can you call the pursuit of happiness dishonorable?” (90).

Chapter 15 Summary

On the third anniversary of Arthur and Miranda’s wedding, they host a party at their home in Los Angeles. Guests include Arthur’s best friend, Clark Thompson, an English management consultant whom Arthur first met in an acting class in Toronto, Elizabeth Colton, who costars in Arthur’s latest movie, and various others who work in the film industry. As the guests talk, Miranda notices that Arthur will not make eye contact with her. Conversation turns to her work on Dr. Eleven; Miranda explains that the project is for her own satisfaction, not necessarily for publication.

At the guests’ insistence, Arthur begins to tell how he and Miranda met; Miranda leaves, using their dog, Luli, as an excuse to step outside. Listening to Arthur tell the story, she recalls parts he leaves out, including a visit to Pablo that left her with a bruised face. Watching through the window, Miranda realizes that Arthur and Elizabeth are having an affair. Clark joins Miranda outside and discreetly offers his sympathies.

That night, Miranda draws a Pomeranian just like Luli for Dr. Eleven. Afterwards, she finds Elizabeth sleeping on the sofa. Stepping outside, she asks Jeevan, one of the paparazzi in front of the house, for a cigarette and asks him why he does the work that he does. “Work is combat,” he explains (103). As Miranda returns to the house, he takes pictures of her, to her displeasure. Miranda takes a paperweight that Clark brought as a present from Arthur’s study before returning to work on Dr. Eleven. Elizabeth appears and repeatedly apologizes to Miranda (107).

Within a few months, Arthur and Miranda get a divorce, Elizabeth moves in with Arthur, and Miranda returns to work at Neptune Logistics, where she advances up the corporate ladder.

Chapter 16 Summary

This chapter is an excerpt from an interview between François Diallo, a librarian and publisher in a town called New Petoskey, and Kirsten, 15 years after the Georgia Flu. Diallo, who is interviewing Symphony members in turn, explains his work as an archivist, and Kirsten asks whether he has seen Dr. Eleven comics before; he has not.

Chapter 17 Summary

A year before the collapse, Clark and Arthur meet for lunch in London. Arthur, who is undergoing a third divorce, is on his way to visit his second wife, Elizabeth, and his son, Tyler, who live in Jerusalem. Clark grows “sick with disgust” to realize that Arthur is putting on a performance for the other guests in the restaurant (112).

Chapter 18 Summary

Diallo continues to interview Kirsten. Kirsten discusses her life as a child actor before the pandemic and how she joined the Symphony. She compares the civilized, stable towns they visit with the dangerous, unstable ones they avoid.

Part 3 Analysis

Part 3 details both the beginning and the ending of Arthur and Miranda’s romantic relationship. At the beginning of their relationship, both are excited by the possibilities: Miranda looks forward to escaping a relationship in which she feels misunderstood, while Arthur appreciates the fact that Miranda knows his hometown. (Delano Island, the fictional island where Arthur and Miranda grow up, resembles Denman Island, where Mandel grew up.) By the time of the dinner party that marks their third anniversary, both expectations have given way to disappointment: Arthur fails to understand or appreciate Miranda’s work on Dr. Eleven, and he is frustrated by her seeming inability to thrive in Hollywood’s social scene.

These chapters also continue to investigate the theme of the relationship between art and life. The title of Part 2—“I prefer you with a crown”—is what Miranda thinks when, early in their relationship, she sees Arthur dressed as a king for a part he’s playing and then meets him for dinner that night, to find him wearing a baseball cap. Her preference, at least in that instance, for Arthur in costume is an inversion of Clark’s later repulsion when he feels that Arthur is putting on a performance during their meal together. Both incidents illustrate that the boundary between the performing arts and everyday life is not absolute.

The theme of personal responsibility, particularly as it relates to satisfaction within one’s line of work, is also explored in Part 3. Although she struggles to make decisions within her personal life, Miranda dedicates herself to working on Dr. Eleven for her own pleasure, something her dinner guests in the movie industry have a hard time understanding. Jeevan, on the other hand, appears resigned to doing work that he finds morally repugnant, as when he photographs Miranda the night of the dinner party. It is not until later that he realizes that not all “work is combat” and he can find something that actually brings him joy and fulfillment.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text