51 pages • 1 hour read
Nedra Glover TawwabA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The author relays a story about a couple, James and Tiffany, who had frequent arguments about James's mother, Debra. While James wanted to spend a lot of time with his mother, Tiffany found her mother-in-law overbearing and intrusive.
Tawwab coached James to create boundaries with his mother to protect his wife’s feelings and their privacy as a couple. James found it very difficult to establish boundaries with his mom, but over time was able to stop her from infantilizing him. He also declined to overshare with his mother about his relationship. Tawwab notes that she helped Tiffany become supportive of this process, which was a challenge for her husband.
Tawwab explains that setting boundaries with one’s parents is a sign of maturity and adulthood, since it shows an awareness and concern for one’s own needs. The author claims that the parent-child dynamic can make it especially difficult to set boundaries. Parents are accustomed to having some influence over their children’s lives and most adult children worry about disappointing or alienating their parents. People’s boundaries with their parents may be about maintaining personal space, not being asked personal questions, maintaining privacy about one’s partner, or being able to freely express a differing opinion. Changing holiday traditions is another way of setting boundaries, which may include changing activities, staying in a hotel instead of with family members, and not feeling obligated to visit with all family members.
Tawwab claims that setting boundaries with one’s in-laws can be particularly difficult. She recommends that partners communicate with each other about issues that arise and create boundaries with their own sides of the family. If the partner fails to make clear boundaries with their own family members, Tawwab suggests that the other spouse should be able to. Tawwab argues that in-laws need boundaries if they gossip or say negative things about one’s spouse, disrespect parenting choices, or are controlling or intrusive about making decisions for the family.
The author reiterates that boundaries are an essential part of enjoying relationships with siblings and other family members. She recommends identifying behavior that is hurtful, such as guilt-tripping or arguing, and creating specific rules to prevent it. For example, someone may explicitly say that they will not mediate family conflicts or ask a sibling to not bring up controversial topics at family dinners.
Boundaries can also benefit co-parents and their children. Tawwab suggests that co-parents should avoid name-calling or gossiping about each other with the kids, respect custody arrangements and ask a mediator for help when they cannot communicate well. Similarly, setting boundaries with children helps them feel safe and teaches them how to behave appropriately. Tawwab’s examples of setting boundaries with kids includes setting bedtimes, giving them healthy food, and discussing their feelings with them constructively. Moreover, parents need to remember that children are not “confidants” or “companions” and should not overshare or burden their kids with their problems (186). The author asks the reader to reflect on how family members may react to them setting boundaries, and to think about which boundaries they feel they need to create with their family.
The author relays the story of Malcolm and Nicole, a couple who increasingly argued about household expectations and the state of their relationship. Nicole wanted to be married and was hurt by Malcolm’s lack of commitment and sulky response to arguments. Meanwhile, Malcolm felt nagged and disliked Nicole’s passive-aggressive attempts at communicating. Tawwab observes that this couple had never communicated about what was and was not acceptable in the household, or during arguments. The author helped Nicole make more “assertive requests” about how Malcolm needed to contribute to the household, and she helped Malcolm articulate his nervousness about commitment (191). Malcolm and Nicole established new agreements and compromises to break their cycle of poor communication and arguing.
Tawwab laments that many couples neglect to communicate about long-term expectations, such as marriage or kids, in the beginning of the relationship, which can cause problems later on when partners realize they want different things. The author recommends bringing up these subjects after a few dates and being upfront about long-term goals. She insists that this will only “scare away” people who are “mismatched” with them anyways (194).
The author recommends explicit communication about shared values, how to argue and resolve problems, and any rules either partner needs in the relationship. Other topics for long-term relationships include finances, fidelity, household duties, kids and more. She claims that feelings of “resentment, burnout, frustration, settling, uneasiness and anger” are red flags that couples must communicate and solve problems together (194). Tawwab urges people to prioritize communicating clearly with their partners through “open communication” by clearly stating their feelings or desires without yelling or insults (198). She maintains that communication problems are the main cause of unhappy relationships and breakups.
Certain life transitions can be particularly challenging for couples, such as the first year of living together, becoming parents, or having kids leave the home. Tawwab encourages couples to value their relationship and make time for it. She concludes her discussion on romantic relationships by asking the reader to think about their “top five needs” and how they might set boundaries with their partner to meet those needs (203).
In Chapter 12, Tawwab explores setting boundaries in friendships. She reflects on a client named Kevin who felt burdened by his best friend’s constant complaining. Tawwab helped Kevin try different strategies, such as talking about himself more, asking his friend about positive life events, or declining some of the phone calls. In the end, Kevin decided to limit his chats with his friend.
The author argues that, in healthy friendships, friends support each other, show understanding, and allow the relationship to change over time. Unhealthy friendships, however, form when people share unevenly, feel emotionally drained or embarrassed, feel competitive or disrespect boundaries. Tawwab advises the reader to take action, like changing the topic, to protect themselves from “chronic complainers” (208). Such redirection can be a gentle way of setting a boundary about not discussing certain topics, too.
Tawwab recommends considering boundaries for oneself and friends around lending money, offering unwanted advice, and sharing problems. She clarifies that “enmeshment” is not a helpful or healthy way to be a friend, as this makes people lose their distinct identities and take on too many of someone else’s problems (214).
If friends often violate boundaries and the friendship becomes hurtful, Tawwab suggests ending the friendship by reducing contact to more superficial interactions, or not engaging with them at all. The author asks the reader to write down their own definition of a positive friendship and think about the friendships they most enjoy. Then she recommends reflecting on friendships which need boundaries.
As the author begins Part 2 of her work, she continues to give clear, frank advice to the reader on how to best communicate in their relationships. For instance, she firmly instructs the reader to speak up for themselves or risk feeling resentful towards their loved ones. She writes, “Telling your partner what you need allows them to honor your boundary. Staying quiet will piss you off” (198). Tawwab continues to provide specific examples of how family or friends may accidentally disrespect boundaries and makes equally detailed suggestions for the reader. For instance, if family members “have no filter in the opinions they share to you” Tawwab suggests setting boundaries by “not allowing family members to comment on your dating status, weight, or any area of your life that you aren’t comfortable discussing” (180).
In these chapters the author takes the advice she articulates in Part 1 and applies it to specific types of relationships. In doing so she is able to advance her theme The Childhood Roots of Boundary Problems. Tawwab asks, “How do you stand up to the most influential force in your life? [...] For your entire life your parents have been acquainted with you inside and out. They know what to say to trigger you and get what they want” (173). While long-standing patterns and dynamics can be particularly challenging to overcome, Tawwab urges the reader to embrace boundaries as a rite of passage to adulthood and develop their “own way of existing in the world” apart from their parents (176).
Tawwab also builds on this theme by encouraging the reader to consider how their coparenting dynamics are influencing their kids. She highlights the importance of respectful boundaries between parents, both for their own sake and for that of the children. She explains, “Parents may unknowingly affect their kids negatively by having a contentious relationship with each other [...] Through observing your relationship, you are teaching your kids how to exist in their own relationships” (182-83). This point is illustrated in one of the author’s anecdotes about a couple with communication problems, as the man reveals that he is avoidant about commitment after witnessing his parents’ own troubled marriage. Tawwab explains, “For the BIG conversation about marriage, Malcolm admitted to having anxiety about it because of his parents’ dysfunctional relationship and other marriages he’d witnessed” (192). By emphasizing how children learn about communication and boundaries by observing their parents, the author underscores the importance of modeling these behaviors for them.
Tawwab also emphasizes the inherent connection between open communication and boundary setting. She stresses, “The number one reason couples seek therapy is to improve their communication. In fact, I would argue that most relationship issues boil down to communication” (194). Tawwab claims that, in her work as a therapist, most clients admit to hiding things from their partner due to fear of how they may react. As resentments build, couples expend more energy arguing about the problem than identifying a solution. According to Tawwab, this is a reactive way of dealing with problems, as it allows issues to arise and fester before pointing out one’s needs. In contrast, open communication and the boundaries it produces means that “You’re no longer simply reacting to every problem; you’re proactive about the issues in your relationship” (197). By pointing out how a lack of communication tends to exacerbate existing disagreements and make them worse, the author motivates the reader to overcome their fear or discomfort and be more honest with their partner.