logo

67 pages 2 hours read

Chloe Gong

Our Violent Ends

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 5-10Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 5 Summary

Benedikt is in a market when he encounters a group of Scarlets attacking a young White Flower messenger. The messenger calls out Benedikt’s name, and the Scarlets turn on him. Benedikt, in his grief over losing Marshall, at first thinks he has nothing to live for but realizes as the Scarlets are about to kill him that he doesn’t want to die. At the last moment, someone (later revealed to be Marshall) shoots from above, killing all the Scarlets and sparing Benedikt and the messenger. As Benedikt runs away, he wonders who would bother watching and then saving him.

Chapter 6 Summary

Juliette attends a meeting for the Scarlet inner circle. She presents Paul’s research and proposes the Scarlet Gang create a vaccine and give it to the whole city for free, arguing it is in their best interest; the “new Larkspur” loses all power if everyone is immune to the “madness.” Tyler counters that they should only give it to the Scarlet Gang for free and charge everyone else. Tensions mount, and Lady Cai interrupts, saying they should table the discussion until after the vaccine is made. Tyler taunts her in French so the rest of the Scarlets can’t understand. He implies that he suspects that Juliette was not actually “tricking” Roma when they worked together. The only reason he is unsure is because he believes Marshall is dead. If the truth comes out, Juliette knows she will lose her role as heir of the Scarlet Gang to Tyler. She’s afraid of his power and tired of the pointless blood feud.

Roma trains Alisa in self-defense. She gets frustrated and grumbles that Juliette probably learned how to fight quickly. Roma freezes and tells Alisa she shouldn’t want to be like Juliette in any way. He leaves her, wishing he had fewer reminders of Juliette. Dimitri intercepts Roma, telling him that Lord Montagov wants to speak to him. Roma’s recent turn to extreme violence has secured his place as heir of the White Flowers, and he tells Dimitri his father can wait.

Chapter 7 Summary

Juliette and Kathleen map labor strikes, trying to predict where the next will occur. Juliette thinks back to the protest the day she betrayed Roma and wonders if things could have gone differently but dismisses the idea. Tyler would have killed her if she’d shown any allegiance to Roma. Lady Cai enters and encourages Juliette to get a new Chinese qipao to wear instead of the Western-style dresses Juliette prefers. When Juliette and Kathleen both decline, Lady Cai departs, leaving Juliette’s door open so she can hear an argument from Lord Cai’s office. A Nationalist officer yells that Lord Cai is supposed to keep order in Shanghai and instructs him not to pay the blackmailer. Lord Cai agrees but reminds the Nationalist that this means there will be an attack.

Lord Cai tells Juliette that the latest demand is for military weapons, not money. They speculate on the blackmailer’s identity but come up empty. Juliette tells her father to send her to the French Concession, where the letters originate, but Lord Cai produces photographs of the latest attack and says he won’t send his daughter into a scene as disturbingly violent and unknown as this one. Juliette insists, and Lord Cai says he will think about it. Juliette leaves her father’s office and encounters a maid cleaning up mud and a pink petal. Juliette recognizes the petal—it’s from flowers outside the Montagov residence—and remembers that, months prior, her father claimed there was a spy in the household. The maid says she has been finding petals for months.

Kathleen attends a Communist meeting to keep up her connections and thinks about how infrequently she sees Rosalind. She muses about her father’s mounting insistence that they move to the countryside. She also wonders what he would do if she called herself “Celia,” her chosen name when she transitioned, instead of “Kathleen,” her dead sister’s name that her father instructed her to adopt if she wished him to accept her as a woman. She worries more about Rosalind, though, who socializes with the French, “[playing] diplomat.” Kathleen resolves not to do what her father wants, “Filial piety be damned” (71). After all, she is loyal to Juliette, who has far more power than Kathleen’s father. As the meeting goes on, Kathleen spots Dimitri in the crowd and wonders what he is doing there.

Chapter 8 Summary

Juliette and her father are driving to a location Lord Cai won’t disclose. To her shock, they’re meeting Lord Montagov and Roma. The two gang patriarchs are calm, but Juliette and Roma pull weapons on each other. Juliette feels numb; this enmity is her fault. Lord Montagov proposes that Roma and Juliette work together to discover the blackmailer. Lord Cai agrees, and Juliette realizes she has no choice but to give in. If she protests, she will have to reveal her history with Roma to her father. Privately, Roma reveals that this plan was sprung on him as well, and he is supposed to secretly regain Juliette’s trust and spy on her. As far as Roma knows, Lord Montagov doesn’t know that Juliette has already done this. Roma says that Lord Cai only agreed because the White Flower spy in the Scarlet Gang talked him into it. Roma and Juliette agree to go along with their fathers’ plan but are both wary. Juliette insists on the arrangement being public so Tyler can’t usurp her by spreading the rumor that she and Roma are lovers. Though he agrees to the plan, Roma reminds Juliette that he hasn’t forgotten his revenge.

As Juliette and Lord Cai leave, Juliette reminds her father they can still use the opportunity to ambush Lord Montagov, but Lord Cai brushes her off, treating the blood feud as less important than other concerns. He tells Juliette to keep the White Flowers distracted but doesn’t reveal from what.

Chapter 9 Summary

Juliette is sneaking about her house at night when she notes that Rosalind is awake. Rosalind has a list of French names (revealed in Chapter 35 to be the five monsters). Juliette says Kathleen is worried about Rosalind interacting with foreigners, but Rosalind brushes off this concern; the foreigners don’t want to hurt the Shanghainese themselves but want to sow discord so the different Shanghainese factions harm each other. The real danger in Shanghai, Rosalind says, is politics. Juliette pivots to discussing Rosalind’s new necklace (revealed in Chapter 35 to be from Dimitri, Rosalind’s lover). She’s worried it is a sign that Rosalind plans to run, as jewelry is portable wealth, but Rosalind says she isn’t and insists there’s nowhere she could go in any case. Juliette thinks of all the places she has considered going herself.

Juliette leaves to go to the safe house where Marshall is hiding. Marshall is bored and lonely but otherwise in good condition, and he and Juliette banter playfully until Juliette realizes that Marshall has gone outside. He reveals that he is the vigilante protecting Benedikt and stopping other feud business before it turns fatal when he stumbles across it. Juliette wants to scold him but finds she can’t—it’s her fault Marshall is stuck here. Marshall promises nobody will see him, but Juliette remains anxious.

Roma meets with Dimitri and Lord Montagov. Lord Montagov instructs Roma to track the Scarlets’ progress with the blackmailer and vaccine and keep an eye out for clients the White Flowers wish to poach from them. Dimitri tries to take credit for this information, but Roma rebuffs him. Dimitri accuses Roma of being hostile to White Flowers and welcoming to Scarlets. Roma protests, saying he is only working with Juliette until he can kill her, and Dimitri asks why he hasn’t done so already. Roma storms off, conflicted. He wants to believe that Juliette is up to something, but killing Marshall is unforgivable. He vows to be as bloody and ruthless as Juliette has been, regardless of how badly it hurts him.

Chapter 10 Summary

Unionized workers march in protest of both foreign and gangster rule, despite threats of beheading for causing civil unrest. Violence seems imminent between workers and police when the monster appears. Everyone scatters, though the monster does nothing. This time, the monster has stopped the violence.

Chapters 5-10 Analysis

The question of how best to protect loved ones in a city consumed with violence appears throughout these chapters. Marshall protects Benedikt by playing vigilante, Roma protects Alisa by teaching her to protect herself, and Juliette seeks to protect all of Shanghai from the monsters. Meanwhile, Tyler wishes only to protect the Scarlet Gang and their affiliates.

As in These Violent Delights, the monsters bring Roma and Juliette together despite their animosity. Once again, Juliette hates being forced to work with Roma, though for the opposite reason as in the previous novel. In the first book, she didn’t want to work with Roma because she believed he had betrayed her; in this one, she doesn’t want to work with him because she has made him believe that she has betrayed him. In both cases, this supposed betrayal was for the same reason: to protect the person they love. Juliette likens this to a game, suggesting the novel’s increasing attention to the political conflict as the real war, as opposed to the blood feud.

This cyclical pattern of events, which mirrors the previous novel to an extent, evokes the cycle of violence in which both gangs are trapped. Ironically, they are brought into cooperation by their fathers, the same men whose thirst for vengeance has made their love impossible. Unlike in the previous book, however, Lord Cai treats the blood feud as immaterial and is more concerned with politics, even when he has the chance to eliminate Lord Montagov.

These chapters develop the growing tension between the Communists and the Nationalists. While Kathleen begins to explore her sense of identity outside the gang while attending a Communist meeting, the Nationalists meet with Lord Cai and tell him to allow an attack to happen rather than pay off the blackmailer, though they both believe the monsters to be controlled by their common enemy, the Communists. When Dimitri’s scheme is revealed later in the book, it turns out that Lord Cai and General Shu were not entirely wrong, though Dimitri’s plan to align with the Communists was not due to his political affiliation but born out of a desire to be the hero of a workers’ revolution. Ironically, he is seeking personal gain, an attitude that adheres more to capitalism, which prioritizes the individual over the collective. Just as these powerful men reconcile themselves to allowing the monsters’ violence, the monsters change tactics, disrupting a protest peacefully rather than turning it into carnage.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text