logo

44 pages 1 hour read

Charlotte McConaghy

Once There Were Wolves

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 16-20Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 16 Summary

Chapter 16 begins with a recounting of Aggie’s impromptu marriage to Gus. Inti does not like Gus, and she is angry that Aggie made a hasty decision and did not invite their mother. She thinks Aggie is out of control, but Aggie does not care. Inti gets a job rewilding wolves in Denali, and the three of them move to Alaska.

In the present day, Bonnie, a policewoman, brings Inti into the station for more questioning. She tells Inti that they are treating Stuart’s disappearance as a possible homicide. Inti uses her night with Duncan as her alibi, though she does not admit that he went out later that night. She still suspects Duncan but needs more information before she can confirm anything. She cannot find any information about Duncan online, so she invites his friend Fergus for a drink to learn more. Fergus reveals that when they were teenagers, Duncan killed his father, who had beaten Duncan’s mother to death with a cricket bat.

At the cottage, Inti wakes startled from a nightmare. She vomits from morning sickness and is taken aback when Aggie refuses to work with their horse because she believes her ex-husband could be outside. Inti has another dream about running into the forest with the wolves.

Chapter 17 Summary

Once, Inti killed a wolf in Alaska. It was an accident, a tranquilizer dart that pierced the wolf’s lung. Aggie and Gus took her on a hike to Mount Denali to cheer her up, but there they met two hunters who bragged about killing wolves for sport. Later, Gus confessed to Inti that he killed a woman during one of his surgeries. He said he will never tell Aggie because a woman should not know that about her husband.

Chapter 18 Summary

Two months have passed since Stuart’s death, and Inti continues to watch the development of the wolves. Two have mated, and the pups in the Tanar Pack have matured; they too will soon find mates. Unexpectedly, Inti picks up Number Ten’s signal and realizes that she has returned to the Glenshee Pack to protect her sister, Number Eight, who will soon give birth. Two wolves kill each other over territory, and Eight has been injured. Inti must find out if her pups have survived and if Six can be treated.

It is summer, and Inti hopes that the townspeople will give up on finding Stuart. Inti has stopped seeing Duncan, and she avoids thinking about her pregnancy. She is still suspects Duncan of Stuart’s murder and has taken to following him when he leaves work. One night, he goes into the woods, searching for Stuart’s body. Inti accosts him and asks if he is the killer, but Duncan does not answer.

At home, Inti finds Aggie is cowering on the floor; she believes Gus is stalking her outside. Inti lies, saying that she killed Gus, which eases Aggie’s anxiety. The next morning, Inti finds Aggie outside riding their horse, Gall.

Still not convinced of Duncan’s innocence, Inti calls her mother to ask what to do after someone has been murdered. Her mother tells her to create a timeline and assume everyone is lying to discover what can and cannot be proven true. When Inti asks her mother why she does this work, her mother reveals that she had an abusive stepfather.

Chapter 19 Summary

Inti begins her investigation by speaking with Red McRae, who tells her that Duncan locked Stuart in jail the night of their argument. The timeline does not make sense with her finding Stuart’s body in the middle of the night, nor with finding Duncan gone from his house at 3 AM. Inti does not understand why Duncan would kill Stuart and leave his body to be found. She admits to herself that a wolf attack is more likely.

Inti wants Duncan to appreciate the wolves, and after many months apart, she invites him to the team’s hide in the forest. Duncan tells her that his limp is from his father breaking his leg with a cricket bat when he was thirteen. His mother did not want to anger the father by taking Duncan to the hospital, so she set it herself and it healed badly. He tells her that he has not been involved with Lainey for a long time. Lainey would not date him after he killed his father because she was afraid of him.

Inti tells Duncan that to spot a wolf, you must track its prey. They find deer and watch in awe as Number Six, whom the team has named “Ash,” wades into the river to kill a doe. The trip brings Inti and Duncan closer, but Inti still does entirely trust him.

Chapter 20 Summary

Chapter 20 is a flashback to the sisters’ time in Alaska. Five years into the marriage, Aggie and Gus’s relationship has become volatile, and Inti witnesses her sister’s deteriorating emotional state. One night, Aggie goes to a party at the home of one of her fellow language teachers and gets drunk. Gus and Inti arrive to pick her up, and Gus is rough with Aggie as he tries to put her into the car. Inti confronts him and warns him that she will not let him hurt her sister. The next day, Aggie tries to convince Inti to move out, and Inti realizes that Aggie is trying to protect her from Gus.

Chapters 16-20 Analysis

The chapters in this section continue the primary storyline of Inti investigating Stuart’s murder, and they prepare for the climax of the secondary narrative, Gus’s rape of Aggie.

Two full chapters, Chapter 17 and Chapter 20, are dedicated to Inti’s past in Alaska. In these sections, Inti experiences growing concern about Aggie’s wellbeing. McConaghy never reveals what compels Aggie’s reckless behavior; the reader is left to assume that she has a risk-taking personality. Her relationship with Gus is passionate, but like Lainey, Aggie pretends to enjoy their “games” more than she really does. Unbeknownst to Inti, Gus has threatened to hurt Inti if Aggie tries to leave.

Aggie’s behavior mirrors that of the other women in the story, including Lainey, who try to placate their abusive husbands, knowing that provoking them will put them and potentially others in danger. Inti’s critique of Duncan’s lack of intervention represents the wider issue of women in abusive relationships receiving little support and protection. Women who leave these relationships may be forced to return for lack of care, risking further violence.

McConaghy uses dramatic irony to heightens narrative tension. Duncan’s murder of his abusive father makes Inti suspect him of Stuart’s murderer, even as it shows her Duncan’s protective nature. The reader knows more than Duncan about Inti’s movements the night of Stuart’s murder, and Duncan’s reluctance to give Inti a clear response about his whereabouts signals that he has his own suspicions.

McConaghy also uses a triangulated plot structure to heighten tension and weave the novel’s complex storylines together. The triangulating element in Inti’s and Duncan’s suspicion of one another is the wolves. Both fear that the wolves are to blame for the attack. Inti is desperate to make Duncan understand the wolves—how they hunt, track, and kill their prey, how they communicate and the lengths to which they go to avoid human contact. Their day observing wolves brings them closer, but their core concerns remain unresolved.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Charlotte McConaghy