76 pages • 2 hours read
Joe HillA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Victoria McQueen (“Vic”) is the novel’s main character. As a child, she is the product of a struggling marriage. She is brave, precocious, and enjoys helping others find lost items—making other people happy is often her substitute for an inability to make herself happy, a condition that will follow her throughout her life. What occasionally looks like happiness in Vic is itself ambivalent to observers: “That Vic smile, where only one corner of her mouth turned up, an expression that seemed somehow to suggest regret as much as happiness” (429). Her largest regret is her perception that she is an unfit mother: “All those years of hating her own mother, Vic had never imagined that she would do worse” (364). She mourns the possibility that her relationship with her own son could be better than her relationship with her parents.
Because her parents are often careless or neglectful of her needs, even though they may not mean to be, Vic develops an unreliable streak that will characterize her experience as a mother later. She is so pessimistic about her abilities to help those who love her that she is resigned to leaving Lou and Wayne at some point, even though she doubts she will have a good reason. She understands that part of why she loves being on the road—whether she is on the Tuff Rider or the Triumph—is that it helps her feel like she is escaping from herself and all the things she dislikes about domestic life and relationships that require her to be responsible.
Vic’s life is easiest—or calmest—when she can avoid feverish emotions: “She didn’t like to feel things so intensely. It reminded her of being crazy” (359). Vic doesn’t trust her judgment, a situation that only grows worse after she is released from the psychiatric hospital. The doctors there convince her that her memories of the Shorter Way could not be real.
When Hutter analyzes her late in the novel, it is easy to see the seeds of the child Vic who would become the struggling adult, with Manx as the galvanizing force:
Like so many survivors of trauma and probable sexual assault, she was made a prisoner again and again—of her addictions, of madness. She stole things, did drugs, bore a child out of wedlock, and burned through a string of failed relationships. What Charlie Manx had not been able to do she had been trying to do for him ever since (843).
Vic understands she trapped herself in the very life Manx would have drawn for her, even though she is accomplishing it through different means. This shows the tremendous work left for survivors of abuse to rebuild their lives and their ability to forge positive social connections. Yet, ultimately, Vic trades her life to rescue Wayne, and her final words give him reason for hope.
Charles Manx is the villain of the novel. He is an unnaturally old being who shares many similarities with classic vampires like Nosferatu, a nickname he received from his wife, and which he applies to the Wraith’s license plates. Manx wears archaic clothes and speaks in the flamboyant nature of a vaudeville promoter. He is a more complicated character than he first appears. At first glance, Manx seems to be a sadistic child murderer who enjoys sadism and cruelty under the guise of protecting the children he abducts. However, as the novel progresses Vic sees that Manx believes in the decency of his motives. He is willing to exploit the children he abducts and drain them to extend his life, but he also believes that it spares them the suffering they would encounter in the real world, had they been allowed to grow old.
Manx has a mean streak toward women, and he speaks venomously of his wife, and how she scolded him for buying the Wraith. He says that his two daughters were the first visitors to Christmasland, which he describes as a place of ultimate delight, where there is no suffering. However, Manx has lost his humanity. He has no empathy, and perhaps he never did. One of his primary characteristics is that he is no longer able to feel happiness, even if he does not acknowledge it. Instead, he settles for amusement, which is obvious in the games he plays with Vic, and Vic mirrors this amusement as a substitute for happiness in her own half-smile.
Interestingly, Manx is not given an origin story, unlike most vampires in popular novels. In popular novels like Anne Rice’s Vampire Chronicles series, the stories’ most satisfying set pieces often involve scenes in which the reader learns how the respective vampires were created, where, and by whom. In NOS4A2, the reader does not see Manx’s evolution toward monstrosity or away from his humanity, if such a thing even occurred. This makes him more fearsome in some ways, as it presents him more as an inevitable force than a corrupted human who slowly became a monster. He is the third in his line of Manxes, and the reader may glean that either he reinvents himself with each purported death or he is the recipient of generational violence as equally as he causes it.
Lou Carmody is Wayne’s father. After he saves Vic from Manx, they start a relationship that results in Wayne’s birth. He is a kind man with a natural gift for mechanics, although he wanted to start his own comic book company. His father—a Marine—shamed him for his unserious interests and Wayne has always regretted not standing up to him. For most of the novel, Lou’s primary characteristic is insecurity about his abilities, his weight, his capacity to assert himself, his ability to help Vic with her mental struggles, and an intense streak of self-loathing.
Like many of the other characters, Lou is pulled by compulsions: “What he hated, what made him squirmy and ill inside, was his own inability to change his habits. He genuinely could not say the things he needed to say, could not order the salad when he smelled French fries” (505). He knows there are better choices he could make, but they are always out of reach, even though they are small. Lou knows that his habits put his health at risk, but he seems unable to resist his appetites any more than Manx can resist his, or that Vic can suddenly morph into a peaceful person who no longer needs distraction and travel.
Lou often wishes for second chances, which makes him feel worse. He asks himself, “Was there any urge more pitiful—or more intense—than wanting another chance at something?” (427). The author here uses Lou to illustrate the weight of possibilities. Once a choice is made, one reality is chosen, but inscapes create a reality in which the possibility still exists for the other reality. Lou’s self-loathing is different than Vic’s, however. Lou’s insecurities are not based on his largest mistakes, but on his accumulating habits and his interests, which he views as childish, an attitude that is largely a function of his macho father’s disapproval. Thus, while the sins of Vic’s father result in catastrophic choices for Vic, the sins of Lou’s father result in smaller poor choices that add up to catastrophe for his health, both mental and physical.
Vic disagrees with Lou’s self-image. She tells him:
You are a real honest-to-God hero. And I don’t mean because you put me on the back of your motorcycle and drove me away from this place. That was the easy part. I mean because you’ve been there for Wayne every single day. Because you made school lunches and you got him to his dentist appointments and you read to him at night (902).
Thus, just as Lou’s small poor choices add up to his endangerment on a grander scale, his small positive choices also have a grand-scale positive effect on Wayne. In a telling moment, Lou admits to himself that his proudest moment was saving Vic from Manx, but he also robbed himself of the chance to tell Wayne about his triumph, because he promised Vic that only she could speak about Manx with their son.
Bruce Wayne Carmody—who goes by Wayne—is the son of Vic and Lou. His nickname is from the Batman comics, which takes on a greater resonance when Lou reveals that he always wanted to start a comic book company and when Vic’s travels across the Shorter Way involve bats with her face on them. Like Vic, Wayne is a melancholy kid, which is largely a product of the struggles his parents face. Vic’s difficulties are particularly hard on him. During his brief life, she has been committed to a psychiatric facility, struggled with addiction, and left most of the parenting to Lou. He has few memories of being happy or peaceful:
Bruce Wayne Carmody had been unhappy for so long that it had stopped being a state he paid attention to. Sometimes Wayne felt that the world had been sliding apart beneath his feet for years. He was still waiting for it to pull him down, to bury him at last (406).
In some ways, his mother’s struggles force Wayne to grow up too soon. However, it is not until Manx takes him that Wayne begins to literally lose his innocence. He is a kind, thoughtful boy, and he notices immediately when awful images start to entertain him.
Wayne does not understand exactly how pure his humanity is until he realizes that it is slipping away from him. When the novel ends, Wayne has been struggling with feelings that would be familiar to Vic. He worries that he will never be okay, and that he will never be able to move on from the experience. However, when the novel ends, he no longer feels Manx’s influence, and his character arc is shifting toward optimism for the future.
Margaret Leigh (“Maggie”) is the librarian from Here, Iowa. She is the first-person Vic meets who can also travel with an inscape. Like many librarians, Maggie is a passionate generalist, a lover of literature, and a curious person. Her primary role in the narrative is to assist Vic in her conflict with Manx, and then to provide her with information about the inscapes. Maggie is quirky, curious, and playful, but her light attitude masks profound suffering. Maggie’s experience with her inscape comes at a cost, particularly when she is older. Her use of the Scrabble tiles causes her to stammer and leads her into addiction and destitution. In a particularly disturbing piece of characterization, Maggie harms herself—through cigarette burns—to clarify her thoughts, reduce her stammer, and increase the efficacy of the Scrabble tiles. It is the equivalent of Vic’s headaches, only it is self-inflicted beyond the decision to use the tiles.
The sight of Maggie’s deterioration mitigates the tragedy of Vic’s death. The use of the inscapes eventually takes everything from Maggie, and there is little reason to think that Vic would have experienced a better outcome had she continued to live and travel.
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
#CommonReads 2020
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Fantasy
View Collection
Horror, Thrillers, & Suspense
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Mystery & Crime
View Collection
Religion & Spirituality
View Collection
Science Fiction & Dystopian Fiction
View Collection
SuperSummary Staff Picks
View Collection