logo

63 pages 2 hours read

Susan Abulhawa

Mornings in Jenin

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2006

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 8, Chapters 45-47Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 8: “Nihaya O Bidaya (an end and a beginning)”

Part 8, Chapter 45 Summary: “For the Love of Daughters 2002”

Amal is shot by a sniper and dies with the words “I love you” on her lips. Sara reflects Amal was happy to have saved her daughter’s life; the sniper had intended to kill Sara. The soldier who held the gun to Amal’s head tries to lift Sara away from Amal’s body, but she begs him to shoot her so she can stay. He drags Sara to Huda’s home and gives them his water supply. Two days later, he tells them where Amal’s body is hidden so they can retrieve it. Huda, David, and Ari attend Amal’s burial. Huda has now lost Jamil as well, and Haj Salem was buried alive in the attack. Many women and children were killed in Jenin, yet the US press is reporting Israel’s claims that there was no massacre and only militants were killed.

Sara dreams often of her mother’s death, her parents, and all her ancestors in Ein Hod and Jenin. She writes letters to her mother and publishes them on a website for the world to read. She plans to return to Pennsylvania, even though her name is on a list of Israeli “security threats” (318).

Part 8, Chapter 46 Summary: “Pieces of God 2002-2003”

Ari takes Sara and David to Ein Hod, but their attempt to visit their family’s home is thwarted by the Jewish residents. They visit Basima’s grave.

Sara visits the Mediterranean shore at Haifa, as she promised Huda she would. She decides to stay in Jenin, living with Huda and working for a non-governmental organization. She is deported to the US after a year and lives with Jacob in Amal’s house. She has also arranged a visa for Mansour. David becomes close to Huda and Osama, gives up drinking, and smokes hookah instead.

Part 8, Chapter 47 Summary: “Yousef, the Cost of Palestine 2002”

This chapter is narrated by Yousef, who recounts how he could not go through with the Embassy bombing but allowed his name to be associated with it. Now, he travels around incognito, accepting any low-paid job for survival in various Arab states. He carries a gun and bullet because he was told to kill himself if he is found. He reads Sara’s website but cannot contact his remaining relatives for fear they will be harmed if he is found. He writes a letter, never sent, to Amal, telling her he waits for death. He will keep his humanity, though he didn’t keep his promises, and “Love shall not be wrested from my veins” (322).

Part 8, Chapters 45-47 Analysis

The name of this section, “An End and a Beginning,” is multi-layered. The book starts almost at the end of the story, with the Prelude in which Amal faces the Israeli soldier and defies him—and death. Now, at the end of the book, Amal’s real end has come. There are beginnings, such as a new life for Sara with her Palestinian relatives. They create a home together in the United States, reinforcing how even separated from their homeland, they are able to create community together. David’s new beginning is symbolized by his giving up alcohol and accepting himself and his past. Each of the remaining characters continues the healing journeys set up in earlier chapters; through truth, community, and reconciliation, they are able to find peace, even through extreme loss.

At the same time, Amal’s death symbolizes the death of hope to some degree, as Amal’s name in Arabic means “hope.” Cold and cruel events continue in Palestine, without hope for a peaceful and positive solution. Only Yousef stands as a beacon of love against the backdrop of decades of horror. There is a small but significant message in his stance: The individual shall not always be completely destroyed by the horror they experience. Small vestiges of hope remain that humanity can overcome trauma and override the hatred it is taught, choosing love instead.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text