logo

74 pages 2 hours read

Shannon Messenger

Keeper of the Lost Cities

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2012

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 44-49Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 44 Summary

Sophie wakes briefly and hears men talking. They staged a deadly tidal wave that supposedly kills Sophie and Dex, whose identity pendants are found by searchers on the sea floor. Sophie sends out a desperate mental call for help, but she’s in a place that blocks outgoing thoughts.

A captor tells her, “You’ve served your purpose” (422). They try but fail to erase her memories, then drug her again into unconsciousness. When she re-awakens, a man who talks in a whisper asks her to tell him what’s hidden in her mind. Again she sends out a desperate plea for help but aims it at Fitz. He struggles, thinking she’s supposed to be dead. Sophie insists she’s still alive but not for long.

She asks the whispering man if he’s Fintan or at least part of the Black Swan. He merely laughs. Despite his best efforts, he can’t read her mind. Frustrated, he tells his henchmen to prepare a poison: “I’m done with both of them” (426). Someone places a cloth over her face, and she blacks out.

She feels a person carrying her. He says he’s rescuing her. She says Dex must be rescued, too. He says he’ll deal with Dex later, but she struggles and kicks until he gives up, goes back, and picks up Dex. Sophie asks who he is; he says it’s his job to help them. They enter fresh air, and after a short walk, he sets them down, gives them medicine to drink, and then leaves.

Sophie curls up to Dex and weeps. She recalls being a little girl before her telepathy started. This soothes her, and she falls asleep.

Chapter 45 Summary

Sophie and Dex wake up. They’re in an alley in a human city. Their pendants and bracelets are missing. She remembers their rescuer leaving something for her, searches around, and finds a note with the words: “Alexandre, Lantern, Concentrate. […] Hurry” (432).

They walk. She explains everything to Dex, from her telepathic powers to the Black Swan. He’s stunned. She realizes that if her captors were trying to read her mind, they’re not the Black Swan.

They round a corner and bump into an old man sweeping a storefront. The man scolds them, and Sophie apologizes. Dex asks what language she was speaking; Sophie assumes English, but Dex couldn’t understand a word. In the distance, Sophie sees the Eiffel Tower. They’re in Paris, and Sophie spoke French, a language she’s never studied.

They need money. She stops at an ATM. Dex volunteers to work it. Sophie worries about getting caught, but Dex pushes the buttons and pulls $1,000 from the machine. He realizes he might be a Technopath.

Sophie locates an Internet cafe, where she searches for “Alexandre” and “Lantern” and learns about the Alexandre III bridge that’s lined with elaborate street lamps. They walk to the bridge at sunset and search the lanterns until Sophie finds, atop one lantern, a light-leaping crystal.

They must wait until the sun’s rays return in the morning. Even then, without her nexus bracelet, Sophie might die during a light leap. She wonders why the crystal is located in Paris, a Forbidden City. From behind them, a voice intones, “So we can come and go as we please” (140). It’s the kidnappers.

Chapter 46 Summary

The gang leader points a weapon at Sophie. She says people are watching; he shows them a black orb, an Obscurer, that hides their presence. As they tie her up, Sophie sends another telepathic plea to Fitz. One of the goons shakes her to stop the transmission. Dex escapes his bonds and tackles the leader, whose weapon knocks free. Another goon grabs it and shoots Dex, who tumbles back and lies still.

Sophie recognizes one of the captors by a scar on his hand. He pushes her forward, and she stumbles. The leader orders a henchman to take Dex somewhere and kill him. A dark rage fills Sophie. Her body shakes with it. Suddenly all three kidnappers are lying on the ground, writhing. She snaps her bonds like paper, goes to the leader, removes his pathfinder, drapes Dex over her shoulder, and they light leap.

Without her nexus, the leap is extremely painful. The light beam was “pulling and pushing in so many different directions she couldn’t tell if she was being ripped apart or crushed” (446). She concentrates and manages to hold both of them together. They land somewhere and collapse onto the ground. She feels herself fading away but sends a last, desperate message to Fitz. She can sense him holding the gifts she gave him and thinking about her funeral. She glances about and sends him a brief description of their location. To Dex, she sends an apology.

Footsteps approach. Thinking it’s the kidnappers, Sophie lets herself be pulled away by the blinding colors of the light.

Chapter 47 Summary

Sophie floats in the bright warmth beyond life. A word nags at her: “Sophie.” Someone’s calling to her: It’s Fitz. Her body is in terrible pain. Fitz asks her to squeeze his hand; she can’t, but she sends him a thought: “I’m here.”

She worries suddenly about Dex. Fitz says he’s ok. Elwin arrives and gives her a sedative. She’s afraid of losing consciousness, but he says she needs to. She fades into sleep.

She wakes at Everglen. Elwin gives her small sips of liquid. He says she’s been out for two weeks. Alden and Fitz visit. Alden says Sophie’s secret is out, and she doesn’t have to hide her telepathy anymore. Biana bursts in and hugs her. Sobbing, she confesses that she did befriend Sophie on orders but became fond of her and was devastated when they lost her. Keefe walks in, says, “enough girly drama” (454), then lays claim to his part in saving Sophie: He recognized her location from her description to Fitz.

She realizes that her new friends didn’t abandon her. In his thoughts, Fitz tells her that, though he still can’t read her mind, he can now transmit easily to her. He hands her Ella; Sophie hugs the plush toy.

Dex enters and scolds Sophie for focusing too much on trying to save him. Sophie says she did her best at the time with poor concentration. Alden says her concentration is, in fact, superb and that Dex came through unscathed.

Grady and Edaline walk in. They look gaunt. Both are crying. Edaline hugs Sophie for dear life while Grady squeezes the girl’s arm. They explain that their decision to cancel the adoption was a huge mistake due to a terrible fear of losing yet another beloved daughter. Tearfully, Sophie thanks them and says she loves them. Grady pulls out Iggy, who promptly snuggles against Sophie’s cheek. Edaline says Iggy came to them and led them to the caves, but Sophie was gone by then.

Still weak, Sophie again falls asleep. Iggy lies next to her, “snoring like a chain saw” (459).

Chapter 48 Summary

Sophie’s dreams are a “horror show.” She wakes to see a huge, gray creature hovering near her. She screams. The creature collapses in pain. Alden tells her to stop hurting the goblin bodyguard. He explains that she’s become an Inflictor, one who can impose pain on others. Having more than one ability is rare, but she’s also a Polyglot who can speak any language, and her concentration has increased greatly. Abilities often manifest under stress, and Sophie has recently been stressed to the limit.

The goblin, Sandor, gets up. Sophie apologizes to him, but he says it’s good that she can defend herself if he can’t.

Alden asks Sophie for any thoughts about her kidnappers. Sophie says the leader is a Pyrokinetic: His hands burned her skin. Alden says it can’t be Fintan, who knows something but has been under arrest since Sophie disappeared. She says her captors weren’t from the Black Swan; she thinks they rescued her from her first captivity.

One assailant was the jogger: His hand had the same scar. She projects onto her memory log images of the scar and the jogger. Alden wonders why the jogger didn’t grab her at her home. Sophie recalls Mr. Forkle stepping between them and realizes it was he who recently saved her and Dex.

Forkle has been guarding Sophie all along. He was there when she hit her head and could have implanted into her mind secret information, plus extra abilities to help her protect herself.

Alden says it’s time the Council contacted the Black Swan. They should be able to track down Forkle and the jogger and interrogate them. Sophie counters that they’ve managed to hide her and themselves from the Council, and the kidnappers also elude them.

For thousands of years, says Alden, elvin society was stable and safe. When humans began producing world-destroying weapons, many elves wanted to sequester humans, but the Council refused. Now there are two secret organizations bent on doing something about the danger. One, using Everblaze, already has tried to destroy the humans.

Sophie quietly turned 13 a few months earlier—birthdays aren’t a thing among the elves—and Alden tries to make her promise she’ll leave the detective work to him and instead focus on being a normal teenage girl. Reluctantly she agrees on the condition that if he needs her abilities, he’ll call.

Chapter 49 Summary

The Tribunal hall is filled with people, both friendly and hostile, as Sophie once again awaits judgment. Bronte reads all 16 charges, a record. In her defense, Sophie states that her goal was to save lives. If the Council chooses to punish her, at least she’ll go to her fate with a clear conscience.

The Council deliberates telepathically. Emery announces the decision: They have decided unanimously that, due to their own mistakes, Sophie has already suffered tremendously. Her record will show a conviction, but her sentence will be marked “already served.”

As to her schooling at Foxfire, the Council notes that, in Sophie’s absence, finals already have come and gone. Bronte wants her out, but her Mentors protest. Tiergan declares that Sophie is far and away the greatest telepath he’s seen. Her ability, while at death’s door, to transmit thoughts halfway around the world to Fitz earned her a perfect score in her Telepathy class. He offers to remain at the school and continue as her Mentor. The other teachers insist that Sophie’s recent, expert use of the things they taught her rate a perfect score in each of their classes.

The only holdout is Lady Galvin. She says Sophie struggled with Alchemy, and she simply can’t pass her. Councillor Bronte beams, but Alden suggests that Sophie simply needs to qualify for eight classes in her next grade level. She has manifested a new ability, inflicting, which can replace alchemy as the eighth course. Bronte objects loudly, but the Council votes in Sophie’s favor.

The audience cheers. Bronte declares that, as the only officially documented Inflictor—the ability is extremely rare—he must Mentor her, and he promises to fail her. Alden tells Sophie they’ll worry about that later, but she’s back at Foxfire for now.

Emery clears the court of spectators. He tells Sophie that Grady and Edaline, as well as Alden’s family, have offered to adopt her, and she must choose. Alden whispers that she can go with either and will always be welcome at his home. Because she, Grady, and Edaline have lost loved ones and need each other as a family, Sophie opts for Grady and Edaline.

Alden hugs her and says she made the right choice. Fitz and Biana assure her that they love her either way. Della presents her with a shiny-new bejeweled nexus bracelet in case she still needs one. Alden also gives her and Dex their replacement registry pendants.

It’s time finally to sleep in her own bed. She takes Grady and Edaline’s hands. Grady lifts his pathfinder wand, and they light-leap: “Sophie Foster was going home” (488).

Chapters 44-49 Analysis

The final chapters reach a climax of tension and adventure as Sophie faces deadly threats and searches for a way to survive. These chapters also tie off loose plot strings that involve her legal situation, her future at Firefox, and her evolving relationships with the Vacker and Ruewen families.

The biggest puzzle is Sophie’s connection to the Black Swan. Stories that contain mysteries usually drop clues here and there—a type of foreshadowing—but the clues are obscured to make it a game for the reader. Early clues—a scar and a voice—help Sophie determine that the jogger and Mr. Forkle are entangled in her kidnapping.

In Chapter 28, Dex reconfigures Sophie’s iPod to run on solar power. This foreshadows the moment in Chapter 45 when he extracts cash from a human ATM: “I just knew what buttons I needed to press” (436). Thus, months earlier, he had already manifested as a Technopath who can make machines do his bidding. Likewise, early clues about Sophie’s strange speech as a toddler foreshadow her natural ability to speak elvin and her polyglot skill with any language, as revealed in Chapter 45.

For readers, these sudden abilities also serve as aspirational fantasies: It would be nice to know how to fix things or speak another person’s language without the years of study normally required.

Under the enormous stress of two kidnapping assaults, Sophie’s mental powers increase. A new one, Inflicting, manifests when she disables her assailants with her mind. Stress also stimulates a boost in her psychic powers when she light-leaps with Dex while unprotected by nexus bracelets. The resulting stresses on her body prove nearly fatal, and she needs the massive strength of her mental powers to hold her body together while simultaneously sending out a distress call to Fitz.

At the second Tribunal, Sophie receives a suspended sentence. It’s the Council’s way of apologizing to her for its pain-causing blunders. She also resolves the adoption question by choosing Edaline and Grady. This is the right choice: She and they need each other to help them overcome losses they’ve already suffered. Alden, Fitz, and Biana, the other possible family, are a happy discovery for her, one she’ll revisit on a regular basis. In effect, she has two families, one official, the other informal—the best of both worlds for all involved.

In Chapter 48, Sophie apologizes to the goblin Sandor for accidentally inflicting pain onto him. He replies by pointing out that her ability to defend herself is actually a good thing. Sandor’s eloquence serves as a reminder that the elves aren’t the only intelligent species besides humans on the planet. Lurking among the “gnomes, dwarves, ogres, goblins, trolls” (26) are many stories waiting to be told.

Alden reassures Sophie that, armed with her evidence, the Council will put down the rebellion. Alden always says things are going to be fine, and he’s always wrong. He has a bureaucrat’s way of smoothing over things that should be inspected more carefully. It’s a weakness that seems embedded in elvin governance. If, for this reason, the bad guys persist in staying one step ahead, Sophie will have to continue to rely on her own resources protect herself and her loved ones in the books that follow Keeper of the Lost Cities.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Shannon Messenger