92 pages • 3 hours read
Margaret WalkerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Walker undermines the notion of Southern hospitality by showing how the slaves’ ceaseless service, provided only through their being forced into a lifetime of bondage, made such extraordinary provisions a possibility. By enumerating the items that Aunt Sally and, later, Vyry cooked for the Dutton household, Walker demonstrates that slavery was key to Southern presentations of refinement and good taste. Ironically, black people, who were deemed barely human, were the only ones who knew how to cook the extraordinary dishes that the white planters and their guests enjoyed, while the slaves were never able to sample the fruits of their own labor, unless doing so undercover.
What many white Southerners resented in the aftermath of the Civil War was not only that black people would now enjoy many of the same freedoms as whites, but that white people would no longer be entitled to slaves’ unyielding service, which was provided only under threat of the lash. Mrs. Jacobson, the wife of Innis Brown’s employer in Alabama, seems gracious and willing to help the Browns but bristles when Vyry announces that the family is moving; therefore, Vyry will no longer be able to cook for them. Mrs. Jacobson takes this to mean that, with black people no longer forced to work under enslavement, they will be disinclined to work at all. It never occurs to her that Vyry and her family have their own needs and ambitions. These facts are insignificant to someone who has been conditioned to view black people only in the context of her own needs.
Families on slave plantations were complex, spontaneous, and dysfunctional. White slave masters, such as Vyry’s owner and father, Marse John, frequently fathered children with their female slaves. However, the law determined that a mixed-race child’s condition was determined by its mother, thereby making Vyry her own father’s property, unacknowledged both by him and her siblings, John Jr. and, in adulthood, Lillian. In childhood, however, Vyry and Lillian are playmates, and the latter openly acknowledges Vyry as kin. Only when she becomes a young woman, thereby bound to notions of Southern propriety, does her mother correct her association. Lillian and Vyry, however, resume something of a sibling relationship in adulthood after Lillian goes mad in the aftermath of a rape. Vyry’s concern and protectiveness over her sister—the only member of the Dutton family whom she worries about—reveals that the South’s strict racial hierarchy and denial of these bonds did not always erase them in the minds of those who were aware of their relations.
In instances in which blood relations were denied, slaves created family. They give each other titles, such as “Brother,” “Sis,” and “Aunt” to demonstrate their connection through a common condition. After Vyry’s mother, Sis Hetta, died in yet another childbirth, Vyry first has Mammy Sukey, then Aunt Sally, as maternal figures. From Aunt Sally, Vyry learns how to be a superb cook. She also learns resilience by adapting Sally’s habit of singing through hard times.
These familial relationships, whether genuine or ersatz, cannot be forced. For instance, Marse John could not convince Jake to be a father to Vyry. Aunt Sally later tells Vyry that she was moved out of the house so that Jake wouldn’t kill her. Jake’s aversion to Vyry is due to his awareness that she is the daughter of his “wife” and lover, Hetta—a living representation of Jake’s powerlessness both to protect Hetta from rape and to maintain the sanctity of his intimate relationship.
One of the things that is most remarkable about African American culture is how enslaved black people were able to find joy and purpose amid incessant suffering and seeming hopelessness. Aunt Sally sings as a means of helping her to get through yet another day of drudgery, while songs also become a covert method for her to protest what she witnesses on the plantation, such as Grimes’ savage beating of the old man, Tom. Vyry takes up this tradition, long after the Duttons sell Sally and remove her from the plantation. Vyry is deprived of yet another loving maternal figure but learns from Sally, not only how to cook exquisitely, but also how to assuage her pain through songs that later became known as spirituals—that is American songs derived from black people’s experience of slavery in the South. Some of the songs were variations on hymns, such as “There’s a star in the East on Christmas morn,” re-appropriated to speak directly to enslaved people’s hopes for salvation.
Similarly, Brother Ezekiel preaches to the slaves about the coming of a Moses who will rescue them from slavery. As the only literate slave on the plantation, Brother Zeke embodies the danger that slave masters fear—awareness of his condition, particularly as a result of being able to read and interpret the Bible for himself, while other slaves rely on masters and pro-slavery ministers to tell them what the text means. As with Aunt Sally’s reliance on song, Brother Zeke maintains hope that slavery will end and that better days will come through his understanding and interpretation of the Bible. Songs and stories both give slaves a much needed creative outlet and a sense of culture that is uniquely their own.
Rooted in Classical ideas of hierarchy and the medieval feudal system, the Southern class system upholds feudal ideas about Southern white women as ladies and Southern men as honorable gentlemen, in the mold of knights. Grimes admires Salina Dutton for being what he considers a proper and true Southern lady, quietly wishing that his wife, Jane, a product of poor product of hill country were more like her. By coveting Salina, Grimes exhibits the class consciousness and aspiration of many poor Southerners who were also compromised by the planter system.
The Southern plantation system was not much different from the feudal system that existed in Middle Ages Europe. A handful of planters, like lords, held possession of the land. The overseers and pater-rollers helped them to defend it, not unlike knights, and quietly admire planters’ refined wives. At the bottom are the slaves who, like serfs, were relegated to a lifetime of servitude on land that would never belong to them. Worse, slaves looked down on poor, starving white people, while poor whites could take pride in not being black. The planters’ ability to turn enslaved blacks and poor, but free, whites against each other helped to ensure that neither group would disrupt the status quo.
After the Civil War and the failure of Reconstruction, race alone determines class status. As a result, Grimes can usurp John Morris Dutton’s place as he had always secretly wished, becoming the banker of Dawson and plotting to buy Shady Oaks plantation. In both systems, black people were victims of violent oppression, more vulnerable after emancipation due to their bodies no longer having monetary value. Walker shows, too, how poor whites who were not as enterprising as Grimes still remained at the mercy of landholders, as is the case with the poor white couple who release themselves from a sharecropper’s clutches by conning Vyry and Innis to take over their rented property.
By Margaret Walker