logo

34 pages 1 hour read

Allie Brosh

Hyperbole and a Half: Unfortunate Situations, Flawed Coping Mechanisms, Mayhem, and Other Things That Happened

Nonfiction | Graphic Novel/Book | Adult | Published in 2013

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Humor through Simile, Metaphor, and Hyperbole

The literary techniques of simile, metaphor, and hyperbole are common across a great deal of creative writing. They are used to exaggerate or to enhance the impact of a text through vivid imagery. Brosh uses these techniques across chapters of her graphic memoir Hyperbole and a Half. Primarily, Brosh uses these techniques to create tension and conflict in what might otherwise be a humdrum anecdote about her everyday life. Many of the pieces in her book are reliant on these techniques for both their humor and their narrative momentum.

Brosh often uses simile in descriptions to underscore some dimension of a character. For example, she describes one of her dogs as “uncoordinated in a way that would suggest her canine lineage is tainted with traces of a species with a different number of legs—like maybe a starfish or a snake” (20). In describing her dog as like a starfish or snake, Brosh uses simile (note that she is not declaring that her dog is, in fact, actually a starfish or a snake). Yet in this example, Brosh is also using hyperbole: her dog is not displaying a regular level of lack of coordination; rather, her dog is uncoordinated to such a level that Brosh wonders whether her dog’s very genes are tainted.

Similarly, Brosh uses these literary techniques to describe her own behavior. She says that with the help of procrastination, she can delay responsibilities to a later date “while hurtling toward failure at eight hundred miles per hour” (42). Eight hundred miles per hour is a hyperbolic speed achievable only with the assistance of a spacecraft. Rather than simply describing her behavior as normal procrastination, she depicts it as “hurtling toward failure”—vivid imagery that connotes a speedy trajectory toward an unfortunate conclusion. The humor comes from how fast she hurtles toward failure as well as her frantic attempts to convince herself to behave another way.

In addition to using these techniques to describe herself, Brosh uses them to provide context for her behavior. For example, when she tells a childhood narrative about stealing and eating her grandfather’s birthday cake, the cake itself is no ordinary specimen. Rather, she waxes poetic about the cake decorations; she describes it as “slathered in impossibly thick frosting” (54). Clearly, the thickness of the frosting was indeed within the realm of possibility, seeing as Brosh managed to eat it. Yet this hyperbole serves to underscore how delicious she perceived the cake to be, hence providing a reason for her obsession with eating it.

Throughout the book, as well as the eponymous web-comic on which it was based, Brosh uses these literary techniques to turn ordinary life events into humorous episodes. The extent of her hyperbole is more than usual—so much hyperbole, in fact, that it is hyperbole and a half. 

Cognitive Distortions in the First-Person Point of View

A recurring theme throughout Brosh’s graphic memoir is her self-awareness regarding her cognitive distortions as well as how these distortions function in her overall emotional landscape. Throughout, she uses the first-person point of view both to narrate her experience of these distortions and to analyze them. The distortions appear in the context of her self-examination. She discloses everything she feels, regardless of how that disclosure might make her seem to an outside viewer or to the reader, and this vulnerability gives her character emotional depth.

Brosh uses humor to display her use of the distortions. In a chapter where she examines the distance between how ethical her behavior actually is compared to how ethical she wants it to be, she narrates that “[t]hankfully, I have an entire system of lies and tricks in place to prevent me from realizing how shitty I actually am” (345). A bit of sarcasm is present in this first-person statement. Based on her narration from earlier scenes, the reader is aware Brosh does not actually feel gratitude about her distortions. In fact, instead of viewing them as a potential coping mechanism, she views them as a “system of lies and tricks”—i.e., as a form of deceit. Also, she describes her behavior not as an active choice that might be changed or as a potential ability to improve her own ethical qualities but rather as an innate form of “shittiness” (345).

Disclosure is a hallmark of memoir, and Brosh takes it to heart: she bares the workings of her mind to the reader. She admits that “a majority of the feelings I feel are simply a reaction to reality not complying with my arbitrary set of rules” (269). This reaction is due to the distance between the rules she places on reality and the way she actually experiences reality. Her emotional capacity is defined by this distinction. The rules she creates are described as “arbitrary,” so she is well aware of how they function as a distortion. Therefore, Brosh is also in on the joke.

When Brosh feels guilt over procrastinating due to the cognitive distortion that she can morph overnight into a perfect adult; the guilt leaves her “almost completely useless for anything other than consuming nachos and surfing the Internet like an attention-deficient squirrel on PCP” (223). This simile is very descriptive and underscores the emotional qualities of her distortion. Given her initial work was on a blog and web-comic, her selection of this particular image would appeal to her main audience, who are presumably web-savvy.

The Mysteries of Animal Behavior

Across several chapters of Hyperbole and a Half, Brosh examines the mysteries of animal behavior. In particular, she focuses on the behaviors and communication patterns of dogs. Her own two dogs, whom she refers to as simple dog and helper dog, are the primary canine communicators she analyzes. To a lesser extent, she also incorporates her thoughts about the behaviors of birds, especially birds who live near her dwelling in a suburban environment.

Brosh devotes several chapters to behavioral analysis of her dogs. She takes a multi-faceted approach to this analysis. In Chapter 2: “The Simple Dog” and Chapter 5: “The Helper Dog is an Asshole,” she uses a limited third-person point of view to describe and contextualize her dogs’ behavior and personalities. However, in Chapter 15: “Dogs’ Guide to Understanding Basic Concepts,” she directly addresses her dogs in an attempt to get them to comprehend her reactions to their behaviors. She uses a casual, conversational level of diction to tell her dogs that “you guys have displayed an alarming lack of common sense” (287) and that their “alarming lack” is the reason behind her explanations of the world to them. Though in reality her dogs cannot communicate back to her beyond vocalizations and behaviors, in Chapter 15 she imagines them being able to discuss their behavior with her directly.

Though Brosh characterizes her domestic dogs as quirky but ultimately harmless creatures, she characterizes birds as rage-filled dinosaurs hellbent on violence. She claims that “most geese are dangerous psychopaths that become extremely violent for absolutely no reason” (254). Instead of trying to communicate on a level playing field with the goose in Chapter 13: “Dinosaur (The Goose Story),” she treats it as she might a home invader: with adrenaline-fueled attacks and weaponry. Birds also appear in Chapter 14: “Thoughts and Feelings.” Brosh describes their vocalizations not as communication but as “sounds” (282), and she attempts to telepathically harm the birds to stop their vocalizations. Although to Brosh birds appear to retain approximately the same communication capacity as her dogs, she views their actions as personal attacks deserving of interpersonal violence.

Despite the discrepancy between how Brosh views various types of animals, she remains consistent in her description of animal communication as being beyond her purview. She fails to understand both her dogs and birds, though she seems to blame the dogs’ comprehension on them rather than on herself. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text