logo

56 pages 1 hour read

Annette Saunooke Clapsaddle

Even As We Breathe

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2020

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 1, Chapters 6-11Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1: “Bones”

Part 1, Chapter 6 Summary

Cowney meets Lee and Solomon, called “Sol.” Sol is overbearing and shows an inclination to bully Cowney. At first, Solomon says nothing and refuses to shake hands with Cowney. The first thing Cowney does is find clothes, ending up with overalls that are far too big for him. He goes out and chops loads of firewood for the guests for that evening. As he mistakenly goes back to the front door of the Grove Park Inn, the military officer who first greeted him stops him. Cowney quickly makes his way back out and goes to the dining hall where he encounters Lee and Sol. Sol leaves his plate for Cowney to carry into the kitchen. When he sits down, Sol digs his elbow into Cowney’s shoulder and gives him a warning, letting him know he is unwelcome. Sol reminds Cowney of his Uncle Bud: “I closed my eyes just briefly enough to see Sol’s face melt into that of Bud’s” (46). When Lee returns, he seems remorseful for the way Sol treats Cowney. Cowney believes the two of them are a matched pair like Jekyll and Hyde.

Part 1, Chapter 7 Summary

Cowney sees Essie in the dining hall on the first night. As they discuss their first day, she reveals there is a secret room upstairs. She tells him she has a master key that will get her into any room in the Grove Park Inn. She talks Cowney into going with her the following evening to investigate the room, which is room 447. He goes back and forth with himself all night long because he does not want to lose his job. Similarly, he doesn’t want to let her take the risk by herself. He determines that she is a much more adventurous person than he had imagined: “How did she arrive with such assurance on her very first day when I was still too cautious to even enter the main building willingly” (53). The next night he meets her in the basement. Together they go through the lobby and up the stairs to the secret room and let themselves in. Essie leaves the room briefly to find a working light bulb. They discover 447 is a sitting room or a library rather than a bedroom. They discover a box of dominos and play for hours, discussing what the future holds for each of them.

Part 1, Chapter 8 Summary

Cowney digs a hole near the perimeter of the compound surrounding the inn one day and makes a surprising discovery: “Covered as it was in soft dirt, I only recognized its solidity at first. But as my fingers curled around it, I recognized it for what it was—a bone” (58). He takes it with him when he goes back to the dormitory, wraps it up, and puts it in a suitcase so he can take it home, hoping he can find a means through his junior college anatomy textbook to identify it.

Part 1, Chapter 9 Summary

Cowney finds a newspaper article about the heroism of a North Carolina Cherokee who apparently survived the Bataan Death March, but whose whereabouts are now unknown. He saves the paper. He tells Essie about the bone he found as they sit in room 447. She is curious and asks him what he knows about it. Cowney wonders if he has told her too much and does not show it to her.

Essie surprises Cowney when he asks if she wants to read the newspaper article, and she is not interested. He remembers he has seen her looking at one piece of stationery over and over and assumes it is a letter from her home in Cherokee: “Probably from someone back home ensuring that her summer paycheck made its way back to Cherokee. I guess she was homesick enough to read even that multiple times” (63).

Part 1, Chapter 10 Summary

Cowney brings home the newspaper article. Cowney and Lishie discuss his father’s service in World War I and the fact that his Uncle Bud was with him. His grandmother has told him the story many times, but he asks her to tell it again. As Lishie prepares to tell the story, she says, “Well, now the army and Bud have a little different story, so what I take as truth is really just me piecing the two together” (68). The story goes that a renegade group of enemy soldiers attacked American soldiers in the night. It is likely that Cowney’s father heard a shot and rushed out of the barracks with his gun. There was another American soldier caught in barbed wire and defenseless against the advancing Germans. Cowney’s father got on the far side of the barbed wire and tried to protect the soldier from the advancing enemies. Eventually, the enemies retreated, allowing the Americans to claim the body of Cowney’s father. Unlike those Americans killed in the earlier parts of the war, his father’s body came back from France to North Carolina. Bud arrived home soon afterward to attend services for Cowney’s father.

Part 1, Chapter 11 Summary

Cowney wakes on Saturday morning with the smell of something burning. He realizes there is a forest fire outside. Preacherman Davis arrives. He and Cowney close the house against the smoke getting in, which takes all morning. As they eat lunch, Bud arrives and tells Cowney he wants him to drive him to the fire line. Once there, Bud produces a shotgun and says he is going hunting. His plan is to shoot animals as they run away from the burning fire. As Cowney says he does not think this is fair, Bud shoots a doe. Cowney is suspicious about the fire’s origins:

Of course Bud and I both knew these fires weren’t usually the handiwork of Mother Nature. There had been no storms, so it wasn’t like lightning struck a tree and then all hell broke loose. No, these summer fires, especially the drought fires, were set by locals (74).

Bud says he wants Cowney to check with some of the Japanese prisoners at the inn to see if any of them have connections willing to buy the gallbladder of a black bear. He has heard that these organs are highly regarded by the Japanese, who will pay great sums of money for them. Returning to his cabin, Cowney thinks about the possibility of selling some of the bear gallbladders to help him provide for his grandmother.

Part 1, Chapters 6-11 Analysis

The second section of the novel focuses on the new beginnings Cowney and Essie foster for themselves. Just like the stories Cowney has heard about Indigenous servicemen in the military, so too his co-worker punishes and threatens him with additional work. As with other Indigenous Americans before him, Cowney ignores Sol’s Hypocritical Bias Against Indigenous Americans for the sake of keeping his job.

Cowney also receives verbal abuse from a soldier when he blunders into the main building through the wrong door. Concerned about Essie’s welfare, he inadvertently snaps at the soldier, referring to a lieutenant as a private. Stunned, the soldier changes his tone and addresses Cowney respectfully, opening the door to more casual conversations. The soldier is Lt. Peter Franks, who will befriend Cowney and Essie. Despite his apparent friendliness, Peter will implicate Cowney in the disappearance of the Italian child in Part 2, saying he saw Cowney talking to her. When the military eventually rules out Cowney as a suspect, Peter approaches him and confesses that he himself is responsible for the child’s disappearance—he is, like Sol, yet another character who uses Bias Against Indigenous Americans to his own advantage.

The novel refers to two locations where growing, curious individuals can engage one another with integrity and experience acceptance and healing. One of these places is the waterfall pool Cowney will soon discover and the other—first mentioned in this section—is room 447. When he first enters the clearing of the waterfall and anxiously wonders if danger lurks in the cave behind it, Cowney is fearful. When he enters 447, he is equally afraid. Both of these places appear to be spiritual sanctuaries provided by the Eternal Earth for two young people becoming adults. Essie finds the room and Cowney finds the waterfall. Though tempted to tell others about their sanctuaries, the young people resist the urge to let others know. Interestingly, Essie does not bring Andrea to the secret room, suggesting she believes that outsiders will disrupt the healing, accepting nature of the space.

Clapsaddle reintroduces the topic of Life and Death as an Eternal Cycle in the second section. When Cowney finds the bone, it intrigues him. The bone symbolizes the link between life and death. Cowney cares for the bone—which he judges to be of human origin—by cleaning and storing it carefully, taking it with him whether at home or the inn. He senses that he should keep it rather than turning it over to the military or the police. Thus, the mystery of the bone remains with Cowney, prodding him to learn more. At the same time, he reads of a heroic Cherokee soldier who died in a Japanese prison camp, but the article does not contain the soldier’s name. Cowney is spiritually confronted here: the story of the bone and the name of the soldier are both precious and both lost. If Cowney breaks ties with his land and heritage, he will lose his story as well.

There is also a glimpse of the tangible rewards of a sincere Christian Faith in this section. When a forest fire results in billows of smoke descending upon Lishie’s cabin, Preacherman Davis arrives and works for several hours to prevent the smoke from invading Lishie’s cabin. Throughout the narrative, Preacherman proves to be a person of great integrity. Later, when Cowney describes his “social safety net,” he comments that he knows he will never starve, saying his church would not let that happen. Symbolically, the smoke is emblematic of uncertainty and brewing trouble. When Preacherman helps to block the smoke from getting into Lishie’s cabin, he theologically affirms that Lishie’s faith likewise saves her from uncertainty.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text