Death Cloud

Amyus Crowe and Mycroft Holmes might both be considered surrogate father figures to Sherlock Holmes. How do their temperaments differ? How does the nature of their guidance for the budding detective differ?

Sherlock undergoes a transformation throughout the story. Describe him at the beginning of the novel as compared to his changed perspective at the end. What experiences contribute to this evolution?

Bees are featured throughout the story. However, the perception of them changes depending on the viewer. Give examples of the various ways the characters see them. Who perceives them accurately and why?

Matty’s life is very different from Sherlock’s. Compare and contrast the way he survives with that of his new friend. How does his economic hardship shape his perception of life? How does this trait benefit Sherlock?

Think of three separate investigations that Sherlock undertakes. Are these sanctioned by his family and tutor? Why does he continue? Are his actions justified?

Sherlock begins the tale as a “loner” but eventually comes to appreciate the support of others. Give several examples of situations that he wouldn’t be able to resolve without help. How does Crowe’s advice on this subject modify his behavior?

Baron Maupertuis is the undisputed villain of the novel. Do you think he has a legitimate grievance against the British Empire? Do you think his alternative plan is justified? What are his motives for collaborating with the Paradol Chamber?

Sherlock Holmes is known for his curiosity, persistence, and reliance on logic and evidence. What episodes in the novel illustrate young Sherlock developing these characteristics?