43 pages • 1 hour read
Lauren WolkA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
As soon as she arrives in New Bedford, Crow realizes she has no real plan and is overwhelmed by the busy city. Asking around, she learns that the New Bedford orphanage is now a hospital. She decides to go there in hopes of finding someone who remembers Jason. At the hospital, she’s directed to a woman named Mrs. Pelham, who worked at the site when it was still an orphanage. When Crow asks Mrs. Pelham about Jason, Mrs. Pelham becomes serious, asking Crow why she wants to know. Crow tells her she suspects she may be his sister, and Mrs. Pelham radiates joy.
Mrs. Pelham no longer knows where Jason is, but she tells Crow about his past. Since he came from Penikese, most people at the orphanage avoided Jason, and he stayed in an isolated area. He did not speak until he was five years old, and then, only to talk to patients at the hospital. Jason grew up very independent and prone to wander. Mrs. Pelham tells Crow that trying to raise Jason was “like trying to keep a cat close” (152). Jason is now a sailor, and returns to visit the hospital now and then. Mrs. Pelham does not think he is on the Shearwater. Having learned all she can from the hospital, Crow leaves, since “all I wanted to do right then was to go home” (155).
Crow heads back to the harbor, but the ferry back to Cuttyhunk won’t return for a while. She asks the dockmaster about the Shearwater; he tells her it was sailing for Maine. To her horror, Crow sees the large man from Penikese. Since he does not notice her, she decides to follow him. He enters a pawnshop, and then leaves apparently upset. Crow asks the pawnbroker what the man wanted. When the pawnbroker tells her the man pawned some jewelry, Crow tells him “that man who was just in here stole that necklace,” infuriating him (160). As she flees the shop, she barely manages to avoid running into the big man on the street. Later, she sees him at the dock, “standing square and tense, looking right at me” (161). She makes it onto the ferry and heads back to the Elizabeths.
When Crow gets back, gentle Osh is as close to anger as he can be, telling her “Don’t ever do that to me again,” acting “as if there were a fire in his chest and he was doing everything possible to contain it” (163). He is upset at Crow for deceiving him and for lying about Maggie. She apologizes. Maggie is hurt for the same reasons, and Crow again asks for forgiveness. Osh tells her that baby birds born in nests up high don’t try to leave before they’re ready. With peace restored, Crow tells them what she learned about Jason and about seeing the large man. Now even Osh must admit Penikese was not “a wild-goose chase” (167). Nevertheless, he wants the whole business to be over with, wondering if Crow will ever be satisfied. She counters that she just wants to learn about her past, just as Osh knows about his.
Crow is excited to find out that a letter from Evelyn has arrived. Evelyn’s writing is suspicious, since “not everyone can be trusted” (170). Her letter reveals that the big man from Penikese is Mr. Kendall. Evelyn met him when he was a roofer working in Louisiana. He asked about a pendant Evelyn wore—a pendant Susanna had given her after discovering some treasure on Penikese while digging for cinquefoil root to heal sores caused by leprosy. Kendall became very interested in both Evelyn and her story, asking many questions about Penikese and Susanna. The necklace and Mr. Kendall disappeared soon afterwards, and Evelyn assumes that he stole it. Evelyn knows more details about Penikese, but won’t reveal them in a letter to someone she doesn’t know.
Evelyn does explain the cryptic words from Crow’s baby letter stored in the cinnamon box. Its mention of the feather, lambs, and ring confirm that Crow does indeed come from Penikese, and that Susanna and Elvan are her parents. Evelyn also tells Crow that her birth name was Morgan, which means “bright sea” in Celtic (173). Crow is relieved to finally know something about her family, but Osh is crushed and walks off.
Crow’s newfound information about Jason paints a vivid portrait that connects him with both his sister and her adoptive father. From Mrs. Pelham, Crow that Jason was treated as a pariah at the orphanage, held at arm’s length from others and growing up in semi-isolation. He internalized this treatment: “[h]e acted like it hurt to be touched” (151). This parallels Crow’s experiences in Cuttyhunk, where residents are afraid to make contact with her. At the same time, while Jason was exclusively treated this way, Crow has grown up with a loving adoptive family.
Crow also sees a link between Jason and Osh. Jason was completely silent for the first several years of his life—“[f]ive years old before he said a word” (152)—only spurred to speak when he decided to comfort a young girl who had been burned in a fire. This is similar to Osh, who did not speak at all when he first arrived in the Elizabeths, only starting to talk when he took in the newborn Crow. This shared character trait of helping others unites Crow’s biological and adoptive families.
By Lauren Wolk