logo

51 pages 1 hour read

Dorothy Allison

Bastard Out Of Carolina

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1992

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Bone’s Birth Certificate

When Bone (Ruthe Anne) is born, Anney is unconscious and is not able to lie to the doctors in order to obtain a birth certificate that lists her as married. She cares deeply about how she is perceived, and not wanting to be thought “trash,” she would have preferred that her daughter be marked legitimate on her birth certificate. She visits the courthouse over and over in order to try to get the distinction changed, without luck. Anney’s sensitivity to being called “trash” is rooted in the very real instances of class-based discrimination which she, a working poor woman, faces repeatedly both during her own adolescence and during the years she spends waitressing while struggling to make ends meet. Bone, too, feels the sting of being called “trash,” and she can be observed having to deal with this prejudice both at school and at the hands of her friends and their families.

Class, particularly as it intersects with gender, is one of Dorothy Allison’s key thematic interests, and it runs through the entirety of her body of work. The theme of The Intersections of Class and Gender in Bastard out of Carolina, which the motif the birth certificate speaks to, is observable in both the experiences of characters like Anney and Bone, and in the relationships that these characters have with various members of their family and community. Both of Anney’s husbands come from families more privileged than hers, and Glen’s family in particular judges Anney for her upbringing, her lack of education, and her job. Although Anney works hard and, in spite of her status as an enabler to Glen’s abuse, does fiercely love her family and is shown to be a popular member of her community, she cannot escape being called “trash.” This label haunts her so badly that her final act of “love” towards Bone is not to leave Glen or apologize for her role in the years of abuse, but to hand her daughter an altered birth certificate that lists Bone, finally, as legitimate. This demonstrates how deeply Anney cares about poverty, class, and labels: The new birth certificate seems, at least to Anney, to be the best gift she can give to her child.

Glenn’s Hands

Glenn’s hands are a symbol of abuse in the narrative. Like Glen, they are nervous, always on the verge of movement, and can quickly become instruments of violence. About them, Bone observes: “His hands were enormous. They hung like baseball mitts at the end of his short, tight-muscled arms” (35). It is his hands that Bone notices first, even before the abuse begins. Glen is tightly wound, anxious, and always seems to be watching her. He is prone to episodes of emotional volatility, both in the form of tears and fits of rage. Often, his hands are indicative of his emotional state, and Bone learns to watch them for clues of impending danger. He begins to grab at her, to clutch her to his chest, and to hold her tightly against his body. Even when not engaged in an act which Bones finds easy to characterize as sexual assault, his hands grip her tightly as he holds her in what feels like an inappropriate grasp. His mood swings are swift and often lack predictability or pattern, and the quick movements of his hands from a position of stillness to one of assault speak to the quickness of his temper. Even Bone’s uncles agree that, although not necessarily a man prone to fighting, Glen loses his temper frequently and cannot be trusted to remain even-tempered in the face of many stressors.

Hunger

Hunger is a pervasive motif within the narrative, and it speaks to the broader theme of The Intersections of Class and Gender. Anney’s low-paying waitressing job, the best that she can find without education in her small, rural community, is emblematic of the kinds of labor open to women in her position during the 1950s. This kind of depiction is central to Allison’s project of representing the experiences not just of the impoverished, but of poor women specifically, and through it Allison shows the way that the gendered labor market impacted women in the rural South. Although class-based discrimination and oppression is felt equally by men and women, they do experience it from markedly gendered positions, and there were greater work opportunities for unskilled male workers than female ones during that era.

Bone and Reese are often hungry, but when they complain to Anney, she tells them that they do not know what true hunger is, and shares stories of her own childhood, when there was far less to eat than what Bone, Reese, Anney, and Glen have available to them now. This shows the generational nature of poverty: Anney herself had been born into an impoverished family and, lacking resources and privilege, she was not able to elevate her class position. This is in spite of years of hard work (for Anney is never without a job) and representations like this are a self-conscious desire on the part of the author to cast doubt on the attainability of the American Dream.

That Bone dreams of better meals, and Anney herself recounts make-believe games in which she and her siblings would concoct dream meals in their mind also speaks to the way that Bone uses dreams as a coping mechanism, using her daydreams to imagine a better life for herself than the one that she is living. Although many of her dreams are focused on the possibility of a world without abuse, she also dreams of food, and this shows the impact that class and poverty have on her coming-of-age years.

Dreams

Dreams are another pervasive motif within the narrative, and they speak to the theme of Abuse and Coming of Age. It is not until Bone is old enough to refuse to live with Anney and Glen that she gains enough agency to put a stop to her abuse, and in the years leading up to that moment Bone can only momentarily escape Glen’s abuse. She does this through dreams and daydreams. Her dreams are characterized in part by an escapism that is meant to show how disempowered Bone is not only by Glen, but by her mother’s enabling: She can only escape him in her mind. She dreams of a better life for herself, and heartbreakingly these dreams often feature her actual family members: Rather than wanting to get away from Glen, she wants him to behave towards her the way that a “normal,” loving father would. Part of her understands that his abuse is rooted (at least to an extent) in his jealousy of Bone’s relationship with her mother, and she desperately wants to function as a happy, healthy family. However, her dreams also become markers for the rage that builds inside of her as the years of abuse pile up, and in addition to fantasizing about becoming a happy nuclear family, she also fantasizes about harm (or even just accountability) coming to Glen. She dreams that someone will see Glen beating her and put a stop to it. She dreams about hurting him, noting that she “would dream about cutting his heart out” (209). She conjures up a dream-agency for herself because she lacks the ability to put a stop to the abuse in real life. There is a way in which her dreams do become reality, for it is in part because Raylene becomes aware of the abuse and in part because her mother bears witness to the aftermath of it that she is finally set free from Glen. However, her dreams of a “normal” family remain unrealized, because although her mother catches Glen in the act of raping Bone, she chooses to leave with him rather than end her marriage and remain with her daughter.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text