63 pages • 2 hours read
Hannah Nicole MaehrerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The Villain, Trystan Maverine, recalls the time shortly after hiring Evangelina (Evie) Sage as his assistant. He immediately regretted the decision, made impulsively after she saved him in the Hickory Forest. The Villain assumed she would quit—but to his dismay, Evie stubbornly and cheerfully stays. Her infectious optimism has quickly spread throughout his entire office, much like the Mystic Illness that ravages their nation of Rennedawn.
Frustrated, Trystan confides in Kingsley, the former crown prince who has been mysteriously transformed into a frog. Kingsley, communicating through tiny signs, simply notes that Evie is attractive.
Evie later opens up to Trystan, explaining that she left school at 13 to care for her younger sister, Lyssa, after their mother abandoned them. She admits that what he mistook for daydreaming is actually her wishing on a star, though she refuses to reveal her wish. Despite his growing irritation, Trystan arranges for one of his most lethal guards to discreetly follow Evie home, ensuring her safety without her knowledge.
In the present, one of King Benedict’s knights falsely reports to the king that Evangelina Sage is dead. The king feigns sadness but calls her death merciful. Internally, the knight seethes with hatred for the king. When Benedict requests to see Evie’s body, the knight deflects, saying it is not yet ready for viewing. The king accepts this but reminds the knight that Evie’s body must be prepared for the unmasking ceremony at the end of the week, where he plans to reveal to all the nobles of Rennedawn that The Villain captured in the dungeon is Trystan. According to the king, this event will mark a new era for the nation.
The king references Rennedawn’s Story, a fable that outlines the origin of the kingdom and contains a prophecy that may hold the key to restoring the nation’s fading magic. He then instructs the knight to locate Nura Sage’s letters, hoping to discover Evie’s mother’s whereabouts. Coldly, the king comments that Lyssa, Evie’s younger sister, is also likely dead. The knight inquires about the guvres, mythical venom-breathing beasts. The king responds that they have captured The Villain to deal with that.
Trystan, confined in a dark prison cell designed to suppress his magic, struggles to maintain his composure. Worry for Evie consumes his thoughts, as he last saw her in the hands of her abusive former employer—a blacksmith who sexually harassed her and whom Evie actually killed at the end of the first novel—and the King’s guards.
King Benedict and his Guards visit Trystan, periodically beating him during the interrogation. The king demands that Trystan hand over the mated pair of guvres, which Trystan holds captive. Trystan refuses and demands that the king release Trystan’s father, Arthur, who has been falsely accused of being The Villain. When Trystan asks about Evie, King Benedict cruelly informs him that she is dead.
Trystan refuses to believe the news of Evie’s death, knowing that the gold ink magic around her pinkie finger would have alerted him if she were truly gone. Seven days later, guards drag him from his cell. A knight with familiar green eyes escorts him to the unmasking ceremony.
Desperate, Trystan attempts to escape but only manages to reach a small room where what he sees leaves him horrified.
In the room, Trystan finds Evie’s lifeless body laid out on a marble table. King Benedict, feigning sympathy, claims he wished to spare Trystan this sight and assures him that Evie did not suffer much. Overcome with fury and grief, Trystan slams the king into a wall and begins to strangle him. However, as he tightens his grip, he suddenly sees Evie’s face instead of the king’s and stops. Desperate, Trystan tries to wake Evie, but his efforts are in vain. It takes three Guards to drag him from her side. As the Valiant Guards pull Trystan away, the green-eyed knight silently mouths for Trystan to have hope.
Rebecka (Becky) Erring, The Villain’s HR manager, anxiously waits for the unmasking alongside Blade Gushiken, The Villain’s dragon trainer. Frustration builds as the event fails to start on time. Blade, disguised in stolen noble’s clothes, suddenly pins Becky against a wall, but quickly apologizes, explaining that his father, a political advisor, is in the crowd.
Finally, Valiant Guards drag a masked Trystan up an enormous staircase and chain him to a pole on a raised dais, where his father, Arthur, is also shackled.
As the crowd watches, the guards haul a glass coffin into view. King Benedict declares that it holds the body of Trystan’s final victim, Evangelina Sage. The king grandly proclaims that this unmasking marks the dawn of a new era. He is embarking on a quest to fulfill the prophecy in Rennedawn’s Story, and failure will mean the kingdom’s end.
Arthur pleads for Trystan to look at him, but Trystan ignores him, pretending not to hear as the audience pelts him with food. Arthur urges Trystan to escape before the unmasking, but Trystan, consumed by grief over Evie’s death, no longer cares.
King Benedict steps forward, accusing Trystan of multiple crimes, including the imprisonment of a guvre for 10 years and thus causing the Mystic Illness—crimes actually orchestrated by the king himself. In response, Trystan accuses the king of being the true villain.
Suddenly, the crowd erupts in shock—Evie’s coffin is empty. At the top of the staircase, an alive Evie whistles to grab everyone’s attention.
Evie ate a sleeping death fruit to feign her demise, expecting the antidote to take effect before the unmasking ceremony. Upon waking, she initially planned to escape but changed her mind when she saw Trystan.
King Benedict seizes Evie’s arm, declaring to the crowd that this is The Villain’s final, desperate attempt to escape. In response, Evie slashes the king’s cheek with a dagger and offers a deal: If he releases both Trystan and Arthur, everyone in the room will live. The king scoffs at her threat.
Evie then points out that, unlike the king’s Valiant Guard, The Villain’s Malevolent Guard is predominantly comprised of women. At her signal, the Malevolent Guard members tear off their noble disguises, ready to act.
The Malevolent Guard launches their attack, quickly overpowering the Valiant Guard. Amid the chaos, Clarissa (Clare), Trystan’s younger sister, rushes to free Arthur and Trystan from their chains. Once he is released, Trystan’s magic returns.
As he scans the room, he spots Evie gripping a rope tied to a massive crystal chandelier.
Evie pulls the rope, and the chandelier crashes down, scattering glass and candles across the room in a spectacular burst. Trystan immediately scolds her for her recklessness, but when he reaches her, she hesitates to remove his mask. At his insistence, she takes it off and finally sees his face.
Becky and Blade rush over, warning that they are running out of time before reinforcements arrive. Just then, King Benedict’s voice cuts through the chaos: He has seized hold of Kingsley.
Trystan moves to attack King Benedict with his magic but hesitates when he notices Evie’s startled expression—she can see the magic. Encouraged by Evie, Kingsley bites the king, forcing him to release the frog prince. Trystan quickly snatches up the frog, relieved to find him unharmed.
As the king threatens Evie, Trystan realizes that she has managed to steal back her mother Nura Sage’s letters. Without wasting another moment, they make a run for it.
Apprentice to The Villain picks up immediately where Assistant to The Villain left off, with King Benedict imprisoning Trystan by shackling him in specially designed manacles that suppress his magic. The king, intending to break Trystan further, uses Evie’s supposed death as psychological torture. However, the king vastly underestimates her resilience and resourcefulness. Evie has already started to evolve from a cheerful tornado of positivity into a powerful and active player in The Villain’s schemes in the first novel, which ended with her killing her abusive former boss. In Apprentice to The Villain, Evie steps into the spotlight more fully, exposing herself to the ramifications of Transformation and Sacrifice.
First, Evie sacrifices her anonymity. While readers have learned that Evie was never truly unknown to King Benedict and his advisors, when she is displayed as The Villain’s final victim, even the nobles and commoners learn her name. This unpleasant fame is dangerous: King Benedict explicitly threatens her with being a hated public figure: “I will spend the rest of my days ensuring that you will never know peace [...] the entire kingdom will know your name before this night is through—and all of them will want you dead” (66). This public exposure is a steep price Evie will have to pay as the novel progresses, adding a new layer of danger to her character’s arc.
Second, Evie sacrifices the traits that have made her endearing; to become a visible part of The Villain’s entourage, she lets go of her natural inclination to please others, her innate cheerfulness, and her optimistic worldview. Instead of continuing as the Evie readers remember from the previous novel, she plays the role of a malcontent to fit into The Villain’s coterie. Evie deliberately alludes to the story of Sleeping Beauty when she praises the king’s gathering and then laments not being invited—the same complaint that the evil fairy has in the fairytale. If Trystan wears the mask of Rennedawn’s Villain, Evie chooses to mask herself as its Wicked Queen.
This novel, like the one that preceded it, continues to explore The Thin Line Between Good and Evil. King Benedict consistently portrays Trystan as a villain, holding him responsible for much of the kingdom’s misfortune. But Assistant to The Villain revealed that Trystan’s so-called “evil” acts were self-defense—he only killed people who were trying to assassinate him. King Benedict’s true fear is Trystan’s magic, which allows him to see others’ weaknesses and thus kill them efficiently. Rather than embodying true malevolence, Trystan is simply a threat to the existing power structure of his world. The novel reminds readers that good and evil often depend on perspective and who tells the story.
Conversely, the supposedly beneficent King Benedict really is guilty of several villainous acts. Most important is the imprisonment of the guvres, creatures whose captivity has caused the Mystic Illness plaguing the kingdom. The king frames Trystan for this atrocity, but in reality, Trystan captured the guvres on the king’s orders. Under King Benedict’s direction, the creature remains imprisoned for 10 years. The king’s actions reveal a man devoid of remorse or pity, driven solely by his desire to fulfill the prophecy from Rennedawn’s Story.
King Benedict embodies the trope of the well-intentioned extremist—a specific kind of fantasy antagonist. He genuinely believes that by fulfilling the prophecy, he is acting in the kingdom’s best interests, no matter the cost. He even tries to convince Trystan to help him, insisting that Trystan doesn’t fully understand “what’s at stake” (25). Trystan counters, pointing out the king’s hypocrisy, “I suppose you think your crimes are excusable, so long as you commit them in the dark” (25). King Benedict’s unwavering commitment to his goal blinds him to the atrocities he commits, making him a more complex and insidious villain.
BookTok Books
View Collection
Brothers & Sisters
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Forgiveness
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Laugh-out-Loud Books
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection