logo

63 pages 2 hours read

Hannah Nicole Maehrer

Apprentice to the Villain (Assistant to the Villain, #2)

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2024

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 11-24Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 11 Summary: “Evie”

Evie and Trystan race through Hickory Woods, with Trystan pointing out that they are heading in the wrong direction—away from Massacre Manor, his home and office. As they run, Evie struggles with the long hem of her dress, which keeps tripping her. She asks Trystan to tear it off, and though he’s reluctant, he complies.

The guards close in, forcing them to make a break for the ravine. When Trystan asks if they are going over the edge, Evie confidently affirms; when they reach the right spot, she grabs his hand and jumps. Together, they plummet into the ravine, landing safely on the back of Fluffy, Trystan’s dragon. The Villain’s crew is waiting for them on the dragon, including healer Tatiana, Trystan’s sister Clare, Arthur, Becky, and Blade.

As they escape, Trystan’s thoughts drift to the guvres in their possession. He worries about the repercussions of keeping the mated pair in captivity. Aware of the potential danger, he suggests they separate the pair, concerned that they might produce a hatchling if they stay together, which could have even graver consequences.

Chapter 12 Summary: “The Villain”

Unfortunately, the female guvre is already pregnant. Trystan feels torn, deeply concerned about the potential dangers of keeping a baby guvre in captivity, yet he knows releasing the creatures would risk them falling into King Benedict’s hands.

Later, Trystan and Blade discuss Rennedawn’s Story, a text transmitted orally and used to control children’s behavior. It refers to the guvres as destined, hinting at their connection to larger, prophetic events. The text also mentions the starlight magic of Nura Sage, Evie’s mother.

Blade advises against separating the guvres, suggesting this could have unintended consequences. Their conversation is cut short when Tatiana interrupts with a letter from Arthur, who left earlier that morning. She also warns Trystan that his office is filled with people.

Chapter 13 Summary: “Evie”

Evie tries to control the chaotic crowd of employees in Trystan’s office, but quickly loses patience and resorts to threats. With Trystan’s arrival, the employees finally scatter.

Inside the cleared office, they find Evie’s sister Lyssa. Soon after, Edwin, the ogre chef, arrives with sweets. Trystan convinces Edwin to teach Lyssa how to make tarts to keep her occupied.

Evie then shares her mother Nura’s letters and a page from Rennedawn’s Story, which suggests that whoever fulfills the prophecy will rule the land. Realizing they need Evie’s estranged mother, they decode a poem in the letters, which points to a location. They plan to go there the next day.

Chapter 14 Summary: “Evie”

Evie asks Becky to search for Evie’s missing notebook while she is away.

Chapter 15 Summary: “The Villain”

Trystan feels a surge of irritation upon noticing Otto Warsen’s severed head mounted on the wall. Warsen was Evie’s abusive former employer. Trystan’s concern stems not from the fact that someone killed this blacksmith, but from the circumstances that led Evie to kill the man. When he questions her, Evie calmly explains that Warsen tried to kill her first. At this, Trystan’s death magic slips out, swirling around Evie as if trying to interact with her. Blade interrupts—Fluffy is growing restless.

Chapter 16 Summary: “The Villain”

They fly to Rennedawn’s northern border with the country of Roselia, landing near a mysterious, magical region. Shortly after, Evie disappears, prompting Trystan to follow her. He finds her standing before a sentry—an immortal, humanoid guardian of the enchanted area. Knowing how dangerous sentries can be, Trystan quickly pulls Evie away, explaining that one had nearly killed him in the past. When Tatianna attempts to pass, the sentry pushes her back with its spear. Then Evie, in a calm and polite tone, asks for permission to pass. To their surprise, the sentry steps aside, revealing the entrance to a cave.

Evie enters the cave with Trystan close behind, but the sentry blocks Tatianna and Clare from following. Suddenly, Evie falls into a trap, with Trystan plunging after her.

Chapter 17 Summary: “Becky”

Becky is puzzled that Lyssa seems to enjoy her company and often finds excuses to spend time with her. During one of their conversations, Lyssa pulls out a small knit dragon that Blade had given her. Becky immediately recognizes it as her childhood toy, a gift from her father. Lyssa offers it back, but Becky insists Lyssa keep it. They discuss Evie’s habit of prioritizing others’ needs but are interrupted by a guard informing them that the wards protecting the manor have been breached.

Chapter 18 Summary: “Evie”

Evie and Trystan fall for a long time before landing on a cloud. As Evie peers over the edge, she spots a field of dandelions below, which triggers a painful memory of her mother accidentally killing her brother, Gideon, and then abandoning their family.

Without hesitation, Evie jumps off the cloud. Trystan follows, scolding her for her lack of self-preservation. However, this time, Evie snaps, calling him a coward. Their argument escalates until Evie realizes that Trystan’s anger stems not from condescension but from his desire to protect her.

The attraction between them increases, and they almost kiss—only to break apart as the sky shakes ominously.

Chapter 19 Summary: “The Villain”

A fearsome beast lands before them, demanding to know who dares disturb him. Without hesitation, Evie shouts her name and asks the creature for its name. It responds that it has none.

With her usual charm, Evie wins the creature over, much to Trystan’s frustration. Growing impatient, Trystan demands a vial of stardust to fulfill Rennedawn’s Story. The creature laughs that he already knows Trystan’s true identity and questions why it took him so long to make the request.

Chapter 20 Summary: “Evie”

The monster explains that, as a force of nature, it possesses knowledge of all things but is powerless to interfere in human affairs. The other creators have abandoned this world, and magic is fading due to human greed. After giving Evie a vial of stardust and seeing her and Trystan off, the creature stays behind to protect its cave.

At the mouth of the cave, Tatianna and Clare are in a heated argument when a sudden yelp draws their attention—a Valiant Guard holds a sword to Blade’s throat.

Chapter 21 Summary: “Evie”

A Valiant Guard holding Evie at sword point nervously nicks her—it is his first day on duty. In response, Trystan’s anger triggers an unintentional release of his magic, which starts playfully tugging at Evie’s shoes. Evie tricks her captor, but another knight knocks Trystan unconscious. Evie rushes to Trystan’s side, but her dagger—seemingly acting on its own—strikes down a Guard who tries to intercept her. Kingsley, who has stowed away once again, Tatianna, and Clare subdue all but one of the Guards. The Guard captain orders the remaining knight to kill The Villain, but the knight refuses, turning his sword on the captain instead.

Chapter 22 Summary: “The Villain”

Trystan recognizes the knight from his time apprenticed to the king. As Evie and the knight embrace for an uncomfortably long moment, Trystan’s irritation grows. Evie then explains that the knight was supposed to meet them earlier and introduces him as her brother, Gideon Sage.

Chapter 23 Summary: “Evie”

Two weeks earlier, when Trystan was still imprisoned. Gideon, wearing his Valiant Guard uniform, startled Evie by appearing unexpectedly and offering to help free Trystan. Alarmed, Evie attacked, but when his helmet fell off, she recognized him as her long-lost brother, Gideon, whom she had believed dead for the past 10 years.

Gideon revealed that his magic suppresses other forms of magic, which was how the Valiant Guard captured Trystan. He explained that Nura’s magic outburst had teleported him to the king’s palace and had erased his memory. Over the last five years, Gideon’s memories gradually returned. The king recognized him but never revealed Gideon’s true identity. Evie then used Gideon’s connections to free Trystan.

Chapter 24 Summary: “Evie”

In the present, Trystan and his people remain wary of Gideon, keeping him confined to a guarded room. Becky informs Evie that the barrier surrounding the manor is failing and that they could not find Evie’s notebook. Shortly after, Trystan emerges from his office holding Evie’s notebook, pointedly asking about a sketch of her kissing someone, which Trystan does not realize is himself.

Gideon escapes and attempts to defuse tensions, but Damien, a new member of the Malevolent Guard, threatens to lock Gideon in the dungeons alongside his father. Overwhelmed, Evie begins to cry, prompting Trystan to kick everyone out of his office. Before leaving, Evie warns Damien never to threaten her brother again, but Damien responds with a sharp insult.

Chapters 11-24 Analysis

In Apprentice to The Villain, much of the narrative centers around two puzzling texts that the characters must try to understand and interpret: Rennedawn’s Story, a multifaceted symbol of family and fate, and the letters of Evie’s mother Nura Sage.

Because few have ever seen the original text, the meaning of Rennedawn’s Story has been distorted over time, turned into a folkloric fairy tale and used to control children’s behavior. However, when Evie acquires a rare fragment of the original text, its enigmatic message seems to touch on The Thin Line Between Good and Evil:

The person who saves the magical lands will take Fate’s youngling well in hand; when Fate and starlight magic fall together, the land will belong to you forever. But beware the unmasked Villain and their malevolent dark, for nothing is more dangerous than a blackened good heart (86).

True to prophecy tropes, the text is intentionally vague. While “Villain” and “malevolent dark” seem to refer to Trystan and his magic, these terms could just as easily apply to other characters. As characters attempt to either fulfill or prevent the prophecy, often with disastrous results, the novel condemns the hubris of characters’ believing they are destined to be the prophecy’s central figure, “the person who saves the magical lands” (86). This tension between fate and free will is a theme that resonates throughout the novel.

Evie also carries a letter from her mother, which contains a cryptic poem providing clues about where to find stardust: “Where the oaks begin to kiss […] The caves below are where the gods once lived. Retrieve the dust that makes wishes come real—Or you shall become the monster’s next meal” (88). The ominous tone of the poem suggests a perilous journey, but when Evie and Trystan finally visit the cave, things are not as threatening as they initially seemed. The creature guarding the cave is one of the nameless creators of the world, beings of immense power who have mostly left the mortal realm. This particular creature, however, stays behind to protect its domain: “I cannot abandon my piece of world, my piece of sky [...] Precious things must be protected” (119). The creature’s unwillingness to abandon the part of the world it has claimed and its correlating inability to join its fellow creators becomes a thwarted version of Transformation and Sacrifice, neither of which the creature can bear to undergo. The creature’s protective nature mirrors that of Evie and Trystan, who are similarly motivated to protect what they value most.

Stories have wrongly cast the creature as a vicious monster: “Humans demonize what they cannot understand [...] Being called a monster does not make you one” (120). This statement encapsulates one of the central messages of the novel: that The Thin Line Between Good and Evil is often a matter of perspective. The creature, though feared and misunderstood, is not evil—just as Trystan, labeled a villain, does not fit neatly into the role assigned to him. In contrast to King Benedict’s more overtly cruel actions, Trystan’s so-called villainy is relatively benign.

Hannah Nicole Maehrer also delves into the differences between blood kinship and chosen family. Gideon’s reappearance complicates the dynamic between Evie and her new allies; her loyalty to her brother is seemingly in direct conflict with her allegiances to The Villain’s crew. Trystan and his group are wary of Gideon, given his former affiliation with the Valiant Guard and the fact that his magic can negate Trystan’s powers. Yet Gideon has proven essential to Trystan’s and Arthur’s escape and has provided Evie with valuable information, including their mother’s letters and the missing page of Rennedawn’s Story. Evie struggles to reconcile her feelings of betrayal, but eventually sets aside her hurt for the greater good, suggesting that The Power of Family transcends blood ties or self-focused emotions.

The guvres, magical creatures central to Trystan’s internal conflict, also symbolize family. Trystan is concerned that keeping the guvres in captivity, particularly the female guvre who has been held for a decade, may have led to her Mystic Illness. Yet despite his worries, the novel suggests that the true crime would be separating the mated guvres and their soon-to-arrive offspring, reinforcing the importance of keeping families together, a theme that reverberates throughout the novel.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Hannah Nicole Maehrer