logo

27 pages 54 minutes read

Arna Bontemps

A Summer Tragedy

Fiction | Short Story | Adult | Published in 1931

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Literary Devices

Foreshadowing

Jeff and Jennie’s trip is not revealed to be a suicide pact until the very end of the story, but foreshadowing is used throughout to indicate the immense importance of the trip and suggest that there is something ominous about it. Early in the story, as Jeff prepares to take the car around to the front of the house, he finds himself unnerved by the thought of the trip: “The mention of the car brought to his mind, with new intensity, the trip he and Jennie were about to take. Fear came into his eyes; excitement took his breath” (350). Along with Jeff’s bouts of nerves regarding the trip, Jennie repeatedly asks if he is scared. His recurring fears and doubts, coupled with Jennie’s bursts of crying, contrast with the characters’ careful preparations and donning their best clothes for what might otherwise seem to be a vacation. These hints that something is amiss add to the story’s suspense.

Dialect

Dialect is a key part of characterization, as it can indicate the social and/or geographic background of a character or characters. In the story, Jeff and Jennie Patton’s speech indicates their social and economic status as poor people in the Southern US, possibly with Creole roots. For instance, when Jeff asks for help tying his bow tie, Jennie responds, “You oughta could do a heap mo’ wid a thing like that ‘n me […] beingst as you got yo’ good sight” (349). Bontemps lived in Northern Alabama for several years, including the period in which he wrote this book, and his family origins were in Louisiana’s Creole culture. The text does not specify the Pattons’ hometown, but Jeff recalls adventures in New Orleans when they were younger, and sharecropping was primarily a Southern practice.

Flashback

Throughout the drive to the river, Jeff flashes back to particular moments from his life. The most prominent flashback occurs at the climax of the story as Jeff and Jennie approach the river; he finally admits that he does not think he can go through with their suicide pact. This memory focuses on Jeff’s youth when he went to New Orleans with a “gay young crowd” (355). His flashback ultimately represents the fleeting joy of youth; during that trip, “Slim Burns had killed Joe Beasley – the crowd had been broken up” (355). After that trip, Jeff began working at Greenbrier Plantation, where he labored day in and day out while the years “had fallen on him like waves” (356), leaving him old and worn down. The flashback provides insight into the sustained difficulty of Jeff’s life and provides additional context for his feelings of Desperation and Hopelessness.

Simile

Bontemps uses simile—a comparison using “like” or “as”—in the story to represent Jeff and Jennie’s difficult life and Jeff’s fear in the face of their suicide pact. Many similes reinforce her weakness and frailty. Jennie is small in stature, and her body is “as scrawny and gnarled as a string bean” (349). This simile reflects the toll of aging and living in poverty. Similarly, as the car approaches the river, Jennie seems “as thin, as sharp and bony, as a starved bird” (355), once again highlighting her frailty. On the other hand, simile demonstrates Jeff’s fear as he confronts the reality of their suicide pact. Thoughts swim through Jeff’s head “foolishly, hysterically, like little blind fish in a pool within a dense cave” (355). Here, the comparison of Jeff’s thoughts to fish highlights how overwhelmed he is as he convinces himself that death is his only option. Although Jeff and Jennie have discussed how intent they are to follow through with their pact, this simile reinforces the panic and lack of peace he feels about the step they are about to take.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text