42 pages • 1 hour read
J.L. CarrA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Birkin admits he seldom engages Moon in chatter during what quickly becomes a daily ritual of morning tea—after all, he says, all he has to share are “nerves shot to pieces, wife gone, dead broke” (34). Instead, Birkin commits himself increasingly to the work of uncovering the mural. In the first few days, he recovers what he is sure is the figure of Christ, bearded and robed in blue vestments, standing at the apex of the mural. He is convinced more than ever the mural depicts the Last Judgment, and here is that Christ—not the tender and merciful Christ, but the judgmental, “threatening” Christ (33). Even as he works to recover mere bits from under the layers of whitewash, Birkin feels a kinship with the painter himself, even talking to the artist across the long dead centuries. The world outside the church becomes like a dream to him. The painting, slowly emerging under his patient care, is more real to him.
Kathy Ellerbeck, the 14-year-old daughter of the stationmaster, visits for the first time. Birkin enjoys the company—he finds the girl’s irrepressible joy therapeutic. He even recalls her smiling moon-face that he noticed when he first arrived. She admiringly calls Birkin an artist; she can tell by his disheveled appearance and fondness for being alone. Birkin corrects her: “I am no artist, I am a laborer who cleans up after artists” (37). Kathy tells Birkin her family worries about him in the bell tower all alone day after day. When she visits, Kathy brings food her mother cooked. She brings a gramophone and offers to play music while Birkin works. The church is flooded by the sound of hymns, among them George Frederick Handel’s “Angels Ever Bright and Fair” and Arthur Sullivan’s “The Lost Chord,” both ruminations on the Christian sense of the beauty in the inevitability of death.
Ten days into his employment, Birkin, taking a Saturday nap outside the church in the oppressive August heat, is awakened by Alice Keach, the young and beautiful wife of the parson. Birkin is immediately smitten by the young woman’s “enchanting” (43) features and cannot help but think how Keach could have had the great fortune to secure such a wife. Alice, concerned about Birkin’s comfort, offers to bring a rug to cushion his sleeping bag. He shows her the mural and explains how the work, cleaning off the centuries from the wall, is like completing a jigsaw puzzle, the mural yielding each small piece only after diligent and careful work. Later, Moon verbalizes what Birkin is thinking: “Keach catching her? It’s an outrage. Almost as big an outrage as society arranging that from the moment he got her to sign on the sanctified line, other men could go as far as that line and no further. It’s a devil” (44).
Kathy invites Birkin to Sunday noon dinner. He accepts reluctantly. After Mr. Ellerbeck delivers an unusually long grace, the meal itself is largely eaten in silence. Birkin distracts himself by observing the intricate design of an oil lamp suspended over the table, fascinated as much by its careful and precise design as by its clean efficiency. After dinner, Birkin accompanies Kathy to her Sunday school where, despite his protestations, he is asked by an overworked teacher to watch three of the class’s older and more unruly boys. Afterwards on the way back to the church, Kathy convinces Birkin to pay a visit to a friend of her, Emily Clough. Emily is dying of consumption, a particularly virulent and, at the time, untreatable viral strain of tuberculosis that relentlessly destroys the patient’s ability to breathe. Birkin is impressed by the child’s careless optimism—and by her promise that when she gets well, she wants to see the recovered mural in its glory. Birkin says little, but when they depart Emily’s eyes meet his.
Because he has not received any payment yet for his work, Birkin decides to go to the vicarage and ask for some part of his stipend. He is surprised when Alice answers the door and even more surprised when she launches into a sad admission of how lonely it can be living in a parsonage. She gives him a tour of the huge home, and Birkin finds the cavernous rooms with their bare furnishings depressing and dark. As they tour, the family cat intrudes with a dead songbird hanging from its bloody jaws. Birkin leaves feeling something deep and urgent for Alice, and he forgets to insist on his pay. But the next day a messenger from the parsonage arrives at the church with an envelope with a few crumpled pound notes: an installment of his stipend.
In these pages, Birkin, under the coaxing encouragement of his new friends in Oxgodby, begins imperceptibly to emerge from his own protective whitewashing. He says, “I told [Alice] that [the mural] would be like a jigsaw—a face, a hand, a shoe, here a bit and there a bit. And, imperceptibly, it would come together” (43).
Set against Birkin’s explanation to Alice of his work, the novel reveals how from the beginning of his month in the country, Birkin himself will emerge. He will be restored a bit at a time—or more specifically a single small encounter at a time. The parallel between Birkin the burned-out ex-soldier and the church mural suggest that, like the mural, which turns out to be a stunning masterpiece, Birkin himself is an unsuspected work of art.
In these pages, Birkin begins to move out of his retreat. If he has come to a remote village in search of isolation and anonymity, the town of Oxgodby and its residents simply will not permit him to hide. They know little about this stranger, save that he has been hired to work on the mural, yet they refuse to allow him to stay apart, alone in the bell tower. He needs others, they show him; they reveal in all but words: he needs community.
In this, Birkin’s commentary on the mural and his reaction to the figure of the Christ is instructive. The Christ who stands at the apex of the mural dispensing justice in those apocalyptic last moments—Birkin calls the figure the Oxgodby Christ—is temperamental and uncompromising, with menacing, even cruel eyes. He is a “wintry hard-liner” (33), there to render justice “but not mercy” (33). This is the Christian God Birkin lives with and which justifies his sense of his moral failings, his surrender to the overwhelming evil of the war, and his failure in his marriage. He is a broken man and a fallen man—later he will compare himself to the mural figure he terms the falling man tumbling into Hell—waiting the judgment that will gratefully dispatch him to perdition. “What about Tom Birkin,” he asks rhetorically, “nerves shot to pieces, wife gone, dead broke” (34). By any measure, Birkin sees himself a failure.
The slow work of the townspeople, however, will reveal the beautiful masterpiece beneath such perception. This will allow Birkin to gradually ease back into the community of others and to find in that interaction a reviving sense of his own worth. That restoration begins with Kathy Ellerbeck. She brings first the gift of herself and the reassuring chatter of idle conversation. She refuses to let Birkin stay alone. She brings music to ease his solitude. She invites him to their house for Sunday dinner. She convinces him—against his better judgment—to help out teaching Sunday school. And perhaps most importantly, she gets Birkin to meet the dying Emily Clough—it is a difficult moment for Birkin as he has come to the north country to think about anything but death. When their eyes meet, Birkin feels his humanity stirred. He is not as dead as he thinks he is; he is not a fallen as he believes he is.
Meanwhile, Alice Keach presents a particular problem for Birkin. In these pages, readers find out she is beautiful—"Botticelli beautiful,” a reference to the famous painting “The Birth of Venus” by Sandro Botticelli. Alice is lonely, given that her husband dedicated to his parish. The parsonage where they live is cavernous, stripped of its furniture, and gives Birkin a feeling that it is a haunted house. His own marriage in ruins because of Vinny’s multiple infidelities, Birkin initially sees in Alice a woman who needs to be rescued. To him, she is a beautiful, lonely woman who needs to fall recklessly in love and who needs to feel passion—specifically, with Birkin. He is encouraged by Moon who expresses outrage that a cold-hearted, passionless preacher could have ever married such a woman. At this point, Birkin sees Alice as an opportunity to interfere with others, not to interact with them. His perceptions of the minister’s wife are narrow and uninformed, and ultimately he will reject these perceptions.
It is a measure of how far Birkin still needs to go to complete his own restoration that at this point, some two weeks into his summer project, the town of Oxgodby is becoming irrelevant to him—“like a dream” (47). For him, the world inside the church is “real” (47); that is the artificial world of his art, safe from any interactions with others. Something, however, is amiss. In a telling moment as he prepares to depart the parsonage after Alice’s tour, Birkin notices the flat iron and the washing machine sharing a corner in this “wilderness of a house” (60). He sees the two “huddled together for the comfort of each other’s company” (60). Even machines, he tells himself although he is not ready to listen, need one another.