logo

64 pages 2 hours read

Ernest Hemingway

A Farewell to Arms

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1929

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Book 5, Chapters 38-41Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Book 5, Chapter 38 Summary

Book 5 opens in the fall of 1917. They are renting a house in the mountains of Montreux, the place Catherine had chosen earlier. They enjoy their secluded cabin, rarely seeing anyone except for Mrs. Guttingen, who brings them their meals. They go for walks in the cold mountain air and find it invigorating. But Frederic is aware of the war that still rages on—the papers say thing things are going very badly, and it wakes him at night. They go into the town sometimes. Even though most of the big hotels are closed, most of the shops are open and eager for customers.

As they walk about town, Frederic tells Catherine: “Oh darling, I love you so” (252). His use of “darling” mimics Catherine’s language. Catherine also has a bit of a role reversal when she decides to drink beer with Frederic since the doctor says that “beer will […] keep [the baby] small” (252). She mentions how the doctor says she has narrow hips, so it would be good to deliver a small baby. When Frederic is concerned, she brushes away his concerns. Then she says they’ll get married after she gives birth, so then she can be an American.

The snows finally arrive, and Mr. Guttingen tells Frederic that his son can teach him how to ski. Catherine worries that Frederic must be bored with only her company, and he assures her that he doesn’t need anyone but her. He does admit to worrying about those people still in the war, especially Rinaldi. Catherine suggests that Frederic grow a beard and jokes they should have matching haircuts so that they can be alike. They feel like they are one identity, needing the other to feel complete. Catherine has picked up Frederic’s language as well, using the word “grand” (253) the way he does.

Book 5, Chapter 39 Summary

By mid-January it is full winter, and everywhere is packed hard with snow. They continue to take long walks in the snow. They talk about the child, assuming it’s a girl, and Catherine asks, “She won’t come between us will she? The little brat” (260). They also discuss their finances. Frederic has received more money from his family, who know he’s in in Switzerland now. Catherine asks if he cares anything about them, and Frederic says, “I did, but we quarreled so much it wore itself out” (261). Catherine says she’d probably like them a lot.

Catherine says again that she wants to cut her hair after the pregnancy and when she’s thin again, Frederic will fall in love with her again. Frederic says how much he already loves her.

Book 5, Chapter 40 Summary

The clear cold days of January and February are nearing an end. It is now March 1918, the last year of the war. The rains have arrived. They decide they should move into town to be near the hospital. They take the train from Montreux to Lausanne. At the hotel, Catherine realizes she needs to go shopping for baby clothes the next day. She also wants to decorate the room so that it seems more like a home.

They are at the hotel for three weeks, often staying in and having their meals in the hotel room, but sometimes walking into town as the weather is getting warmer. They occasionally go for long carriage rides in the country. The baby’s arrival is coming soon, and they know they have limited time together before it comes.

Book 5, Chapter 41 Summary

Catherine starts feeling labor pains in the middle of the night. They get ready to go to the hospital, but no one is around to get the elevator, so Frederic brings it up himself. They then have to wait for the taxi, which seems to take a long time. They check into the hospital, and when asked, Catherine replies that she has “no religion” (268). While the nurse is with Catherine, Frederic waits outside the room, praying. In the middle of labor pains, Catherine worries about Frederic and tells him to get some food, especially because his presence makes her self-conscious.

When he returns to the hospital, Catherine is in the delivery room. She is given gas to help her with the pains. By noon, she is still in labor, and Catherine worries about the doctor, telling him he should eat lunch. She suggests that Frederic can give her the gas while the doctor eats. Frederic is happy to have something to do. At 2 pm, he leaves again to get lunch.

When he returns, the doctor says he will examine Catherine. While waiting, Frederic feels awful that their love has trapped Catherine. He wonders what would happen if she dies, and then he immediately renounces the possibility. This question keeps coming back to him. The doctor returns and says they must decide whether to do a high forceps delivery, which is dangerous, or a Caesarean section, which the doctor says is no more dangerous than an ordinary delivery. The doctor advises the C-section, and Frederic agrees.

When they go back in the room, Catherine is happy to have the C-section. She then starts to sob because the gas no longer seems to work for her pains. Frederic turns up the dial but is nervous to give her too much. Catherine says she is no longer brave but broken. Frederic promises her that she won’t die. They rush her into surgery.

The doctor brings out the baby, which looks like a “freshly skinned rabbit” (277). Frederic has “no feeling” for his son because “he nearly killed his mother” (277).He goes back to Catherine, who looks dead. The doctor is sewing up the wound after her C-section, and Frederic thinks it looks like a drawing from the Inquisition. The doctor says she is all right, and Frederic goes to talk to her. When she asks about the baby, Frederic says that he’s fine. The nurse says he must leave because Catherine should not be talking. Outside the room, the nurse talks to Frederic, telling him that the baby is dead; the cord was wrapped around his neck

The nurse tells Frederic to leave and get supper, which he does. A man at the café has a newspaper, and Frederic can see an article about the front. Frederic doesn’t want to leave too early, but then suddenly realizes he should head back to the hospital.

At the hospital he finds out that Catherine is hemorrhaging. Frederic is not allowed in yet, but he proceeds to pray to God, over and over, begging him not to let Catherine dies. He then is allowed inside. Catherine says that she knows she is going to die. The doctor tells her she won’t die. While he is outside, Catherine suffers hemorrhages repeatedly, and then she dies.

He goes to her room and sends out the nurses. When he looks at her, he doesn’t see Catherine. He thinks she just looks like "a statue" (319). He leaves the hospital and heads out into the rain.

Book 5, Chapters 38-41 Analysis

Book 5 opens up in the mountains of Montreux. Unlike the war-scarred, rainy mountains that the beginning of the book opened with, these mountains are cold and snow-covered. Frederic and Catherine are sheltered and taken care of by the Guttingens, a couple Frederic and Catherine admired. The book ends with Frederic and Catherine ripped away from this shelter, and Catherine’s own body ripped open in order to deliver the baby. Although Frederic has feared for his own safety throughout the whole book, especially after he was wounded, it is a shock to him to see that it was Catherine, the woman who nurtured him throughout his recover, who was vulnerable that whole time.

Hemingway rewrote this ending, some say 41 times. In some endings, the baby lives. In others, there is more information about the end of the war, specifically what happens to Rinaldi and the priest. Hemingway chose an ending he felt captured the novel’s stripped down, spare style: the world came and broke Catherine. By breaking Catherine, it broke Frederic as well. Their time together was up, and the war continued on.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text